West Indian Slaves DBQ Essay

1145 Words3 Pages

The tragic history of the West Indian slaves is a tale of exploitation and dehumanisation. By examining the range of sources, we can gain insight into the extreme conditions endured by the enslaved individuals. In this essay, we will analyse the sources to see if they illustrate the inhumane conditions of the slaves in the West Indies. From the backbreaking labour of cultivation to the callous calculations of slave owners regarding the expendability of human life, the evidence presented will underscore the profound injustices perpetrated against enslaved individuals in pursuit of profit and power. To start off, the appalling conditions on the sugar plantations are described in Source A, which also highlights the high death rates among Africans …show more content…

Moreover, Source D provides evidence of the difficult tasks slaves faced, describing demanding tasks with heavy tools and worn-out equipment. However, it doesn’t definitively prove the inhumane conditions, as it does not mention punishments, labour conditions, or the emotional impact left on the slaves. To fully get the truth about the inhumane conditions, we need to cross-reference with other sources, such as Source F, which, highlights a system based on the exploitation and exhaustion of human resources and exposes a systemic disrespect for life through its startling statistics: slaves are replaced every 19 years due to high death rates. This is consistent with the insane workload described in Source D, indicating that the difficult assignments were not only inhumane but also possibly fatal because of the system's innate contempt for the welfare of people. We can only fully comprehend the degree of the brutal treatment done to enslaved people by cross-referencing the separate viewpoints provided. Thus, Source D does prove the source true by cross-referencing, but isn’t

Open Document