Ways In 'Praise Song For My Mother And Harmonium'

896 Words2 Pages

To explore the ways in which the poets present relationships, I selected three different poems: ‘Nettles’ by Vernon Scannell; ‘Praise Song for my Mother’ by Grace Nichols; and ‘Harmonium’ by Simon Armitage. Each of these poems develops relationships, but all show a different relationship between an offspring and a Parent. To understand these different perspectives of relationship, it is important to understand the culture from which these came from. Simon Armitage is from England, Marsden which is a large village in West Yorkshire. Scannell also comes from England, from a small market town called Spilsby. Different from the two, Grace Nichols comes from Guyana, South America, in a small rural village. These different cultures may show a different understanding of relationships.
All these poems are similar in theme but their attitudes and purpose are completely unique. ‘Harmonium’ celebrates through the musical instrument the golden memories of their relationship which are indirectly implied through the harmonium. ‘Harmonium’ is about the rather easy relationship between a father and an elder son. On the other hand ‘Nettles’ explores the impulse for a parent to protect their offspring. ‘Nettles’ is about the inevitability of downfalls (“wounds”) being experienced through life. Whatever the father does the nettles will always grow back, and his beloved son will be hurt once again. ‘Nettles’ focuses on the reaction of the father to portray the relationship as the son is too young to communicate well, so the protection is the sign of the fathers love. The poem ‘Praise Song for My Mother’ is very unique compared to the others. ‘Praise Song’ is a traditional song from African cultures to celebrate a lost friend or relative. The poem i...

... middle of paper ...

... the harmonium literally, ready to be “carried out”. The second stanza expands on the harmoniums features, with relationships to the father. The third stanza considers the history of the harmonium, which once brought people together over generations. The last stanza involves the description of the harmonium being taken away, paralleling the eventual approach of the father’s death. ‘Praise Song’ is based around the first three stanzas of three lines each which are very similar in format. The forth stanza is introduced the same way as the others but this time it is extended. It brings attention to the ‘Praise Song’ final line about the mother’s advice to the daughter’s future and moving towards “wide futures”. This last line intrigues me as she is reflecting on the ways in which her mother nurtured her and supported her allowing her to grow and follow these ambitions.

Open Document