Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Explain the medical and social model
A social model of mental disorder
Explain the medical and social model
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Explain the medical and social model
Mental health is the measurement of a human’s levels of psychological well-being. The levels of a human’s well-being can dictate their life through mental illnesses, which are seen as deviant in today’s society. Through the years many psychologists have delved into the abstract that the concept of mental illness is socially constructed. The last 50 years have seen an ultimate rise in this area in terms of research which in return has given psychologists a vast insight into this topic also providing great contributions into our understanding of the origin of mental illness. In this essay I will be delving into different examples to support and deny the idea that mental illness is socially constructed. Thomas Szasz (1960) criticised the idea …show more content…
These being; how culture influences the illness, the experience as socially constructed, and medical knowledge as constructed by society. Firstly, it is important to acknowledge that the social constructionism approach to illness is based on the distinction between disease (this is biological) and illness (which is socially constructed) (Eisenberg 1977). The medical model provides the idea that all diseases are universal regardless of culture or time, however social constructionism draws heavily on the idea that illness rather is shaped by cultural beliefs Gusfield (1967). Perring (2005) provided us with an anthropological study in non-Western countries which found that behaviours interpreted as signs of mental disorders in Westernised countries were found to be completely normal in non-westernised countries. An example of this is Christian teachings; where suicide in Catholic belief goes against Christ and his teachings and abodes to poor mental health however in ancient Japanese traditions suicide was seen as noble and a way to atone for your sins (Kawanishi, 2008). Furthermore, in Russia where until the ‘Russian Mental Health Act’ was passed in 1993 protecting the rights of those who are mentally ill, it was seen as deviant and those who showed signs of mental illness were locked up and treated with harsh conditions. This meant that individuals suffering from mental illness believed that is was merely a social deviance and therefore had to abide to the norms in the hope of not getting locked up. The contrast between cultural views on mental illness can also vary on the way it is collected. In places like Russia where mental illness is still looked down upon and seen as a nuisance or a sign of weakness a smaller percentage of citizens would be keen to discuss their experience or admittance to suffering with a mental related illness. Therefore, figures would not be as
Star,S.A.(1955). The public’s ideas about mental illness. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the National Association for Mental Health.
Corrigan argues that clinical diagnosis might exacerbate the stigma of mental illness. In Corrigan’s study clinical diagnosis adds groupness for the collection of people with mental illness which worsens the level of prejudice (Corrigan 34). Corrigan states that this ultimately leads to overgeneralization, as there is an assumption that all individuals diagnosed with the same mental disorders behave the same way (Corrigan 34). According to Corrigan the stereotypic description of mental illness perceives to the public that, people with diagnosis are not likely to recover from those disorders, which can lead to pessimistic attitudes from the public (Corrigan 35). Corrigan suggests that one of the solutions is to understand the diagnosis dimensionally rather than the traditional categorical diagnosis (Corrigan 36). Another solution Corrigan suggests is for the mental health providers to have individual contact with people who are recovered from mental disorders as they are living a life that challenges the stigma (Corrigan 36). The final solution Corrigan suggests is to replace assumptions of “poor prognosis with models of recovery” (Corrigan 37). Corrigan mainly focuses on the stigma of mental illness in independent living and work settings. One might wonder how the stigma of mental illness can influence in university settings, where the average age of people influenced is younger than people in work settings. Universities must use variations of education and contact in their initiatives in order to effectively reduce the stigma of mental illness.
Misrepresentation of Mental Illness Mental illness is often portrayed wrong in the media. Most movies and television shows exclude the details that truly go along with mental illnesses. We must clarify the actual effects of mental illness versus the misrepresentation we are shown on television and in movies. Mental illness is unfortunate, becoming a cliché.
The discussion of mental health is slowly being brought to the social surface to create a more inclusive society for those dealing with a mental illness. However, those with a mental illness are continuously being affected by stereotypes, prejudice and discrimination by those who simply don’t comprehend the complexity of the human brain (Glaser, G.2017). As more people become mental health activist, they are exposing the plethora of issues surrounding the overall mental and physical stability of those who are negatively affected by the social construct of what it means to be normal.
Purpose: The stigma of mental disorders continues to dissolve, however it remains clear that we need take control of the issue, spread awareness, and educate the public on detecting mental illness and equipping the public with tools on how to be resilient. This purpose paper taps into brain disorders, mental health stigmas and how early detection along with mindfulness contributes to the enhancement of overall well-being.
And some researcher has suggested that this model does not reduce stigma. (Thomas Szasz, 2002) states “Liberation by oppression: a comparative study of slavery and psychiatry”. Szasz argues that mental health is a rhetorical invention itself. Psychiatric often stigmatise by insisting that mental illness problems are brain diseases and most Psychiatrist doesn’t see these things as ‘disease ‘ . Thomas SZAZ claims mental illness would only refer to behavioural deviations that have a well-defined organic basis. Other deviant behaviours the product of “problems of living”. Brown and Harris (1978) found major negative life events make people vulnerable to clinical depression. Other researchers found that certain types of life events are more likely to be associated with a development of mental disorders than others—events that are “no normative, unexpected, uncontrollable, clustered in time.” The key problem with this explanation is that coerced and forced medication is generally wrong and that psychiatrists do not warn individual about many of psychiatric drugs potential side
However, mental health is more than just the absence of mental disorders and there are a number of problems that can interfere with a person’s cognitive, social and emotional abilities. Biological approaches to mental health view all psychiatric disorders as being caused by organic factors such as genetic and biochemical factors. The role of psychiatrists or clinical psychologists is to help the patient cope with the illness or control the effects of it by means of medication or therapy (Cardwell, Clark, and Meldrum, 2008). In contrast to the biological theory, the social theory to mental ill health offers a holistic approach to try and understand mental disorders. This means that there may also be social factors that may influence a person’s resistance or susceptibility to psychiatric disorders. These could be triggered by certain life events such as a tragedy or stress. It also takes into consideration the labelling theory where society labels a person as ‘mentally ill’ who then accepts that status (self-fulfilling prophecy) and may lead to a severe mental
“I was feeling really depressed yesterday.” “She looks so anorexic.” “I’m really OCD about my room.” “My boyfriend is acting so bipolar.” We all hear variations of these sentences daily and may even use them ourselves. Although it is not intended to cause harm to anyone, mental illness should not be phrased as adjectives. The National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) says that one in five Americans has a mental illness but those seeking help are not taken as seriously as they would be if they were exhibiting a physical health problem. According to the NHS Human Services, “92 percent of people with physical health problems receive the treatment they need, but by comparison, only 26 percent of people with mental
Social policies are regulations, procedures and principles that affect the living conditions in favor of human welfare. They are in place to improve and change problems seen in society. One such problem is the mentally ill population being placed in prisons for criminal activities. Mentally ill can be defined as any medical condition that interrupts a person’s intelligence, disposition, capability to communicate with others, feelings and basic daily activities. The prisons in United States are overly represented with people suffering from mental illness.
Although about 450 million people in the world currently are suffering from a mental illness, many untreated, the topic still remains taboo in modern society (Mental Health). For years, people with mental illnesses have been shut away or institutionalized, and despite cultural progression in many areas, mental illnesses are still shamed and rarely brought to light outside of the psychiatric community. The many different forms in which mental illness can occur are incredibly prevalent in the world today, and there is a substantial debate about the way that they should be handled. Some people are of the opinion that mental illness is merely a variance in perception and that it either can be fixed through therapy or should not be treated at all, and that treatment can have negative side effects. Other groups of people believe that mental illness is a very serious affliction and should be treated as a disease through a combination of counselling and medication because people suffering from an untreated mental illness are a danger to themselves and society as a whole. This debate is a popular one, discussed everywhere from the medical field to the dinner table, and it is such because of the numerous lives it affects on the well-being of fellow members of society and the economy. People suffering from mental illnesses are afflicted with anything from delusions, to manic periods, to periods of deep emotional darkness due to experiences and brain chemistry (Johnson). Due to the negative effects untreated mental illness has been proven to have on the human well-being and society as a whole, medication should most certainly be seen as a valid and sometimes necessary way to treat those who suffer from mental illnesses.
There is no greater time to create a platform to discuss the overhaul of a system of care such as the mental health system in America. Over the past 2 decades, the increase of violent acts in our communities have been attributed to the untreated and abandoned individuals who suffer from mental illness. Despite the government’s best efforts, the lapse in judgement has proven to be devastating to our community and change is a necessary component for intervention and prevention. The purpose of this manuscript’s existence is to bring to light to this overlooked correlation and identify solutions that will be effective and practical.
This essay will focus completely on Mental illness in the UK. To gather my research I used various resources such as websites and books. I have also viewed YouTube videos in order to expand my knowledge. The statistics gathered may not be totally accurate in discussing mental health within the UK for the sources are secondary but it is reliable for giving a view of what the distribution is like amongst gender, age, class as well as ethnicity.
In the past, people with mental health problems were doomed to isolation and contempt of other, “normal” people (Cameron, D. and Fraser, 2001). Often, people with a mental illness were subjects to discrimination and humiliation from the part of other people who did not have such problems. The ...
There are many ways in which the mentally ill are degraded and shamed. Most commonly, people are stated to be “depressed” rather than someone who “has depression”. It is a common perception that mental illnesses are not a priority when it comes to Government spending just as it is forgotten that most mental health disorders can be treated and lead a normal life if treatment is successful. The effect of this makes a sufferer feels embarrassed and feel dehumanized. A common perception is that they should be feared or looked down upon for something they have not caused. People experience stigma as a barrier that can affect nearly every aspect of life—limiting opportunities for employment, housing and education, causing the loss of family ...
This essay will look at the cultural and historical perspectives on mental wellbeing, mental health and mental illness. This essay will also look at attitudes and beliefs which have an influence on people’s behaviour who have a mental disorder and the causes of stigma, and social exclusion. Lastly the essay will look at the major aspects of the legislative and policy frameworks which are applicable to the humans of individuals who have mental health. The world health organisation defined mental health as “a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity” (WHO,2001).