The Other Paris Analysis

706 Words2 Pages

The fairytale depiction of love and romance seems to no longer exist in society. With the growing divorce rate and the increase of loveless marriage, it is rare to find an honest depiction of twenty first century love. Using the relationship of Carol and Howard as a hyperbole to modern day romance, Mavis Gallant explores the theme of algorithmic relationships to develop a commentary on the lack of love in modern day relationships. The characterization of Carol and Howard as an engaged couple lacking love and the use of abstract ideas, analogies, and hyperbole, “The Other Paris” tells the dismal future of relationships. Gallant’s use of “The Other Paris” as the title sets the tone for the short story. It is a commonly told tale of the romance …show more content…

“He had proposed at lunch, over tuna salad,” is used to contrast the romantic imagery previously depicted. This strengthens the narrator’s idea of the superficiality of romance. From Carol’s perspective, love and romance are not Paris fantasies but rather the “sober, old enough…and absolutely reliable.” The author chooses to characterize Carol this way to comment on the expectations following entering a modern day marriage. Marriage is no longer about who you love, but the practicality of marrying them. Carol’s perspective on love is that it is fabricated “by the film industry, and almost entirely responsible for the high rate of divorce.” The author contrasts this with “no reason for the engagement to fail” to depict that Carol believes the roots of a successful marriage are dug into material attributes rather than …show more content…

Tuna is used to show the lack of glamour in relationships. Champagne is contrasted with wine. Champagne being a metonymy for celebrating, and wine being a metonymy for convenience. Flowers also play a significant role in the work. Unlike the classic roses and violets, Carol compares love to geraniums, cheap, easy to care for flowers purchased on convenience. The diction that Gallant chooses creates a narrator voice that emphasizes on settling. With the use of hyperbolic characterization and settling diction, Mavis Gallant creates the theme of modern day romance being the wrong Paris in her short story “The Other Paris.” This short story is used to commentate that romance ceases to exist in modern day relationships as they become based on material desires on societal pressures. Gallant is commenting that society sets the rules for marriage to the point that “I do’s” are not answered to the question of love but rather of financial

Open Document