The Nurse's Tale

1426 Words3 Pages

There is a recurring trope cycling through the stories assigned for the class to read: what the reader perceives to be real and what the reader understands to be supernatural. The topics are not static and dependent upon the traditional ghost story narrative. In fact, the stories illustrate a range of supernatural themes from psychic foresight, omens of impending disaster, and possible poltergeist or demonic activity. When dealing with paranormal subjects, however, there is always the question whether the event is actually taking place or if there exists psychological elements that can explain the character’s perception of the phenomena. In “The Nurse’s Tale,” by Elizabeth Gaskell, the reader is presented a case of supernatural occurrences …show more content…

Where the other stories have plots that can be analyzed as wholly paranormal, “The Open Window” features a plot with false supernatural elements presented in the beginning that frame the semi-comical ending of the story. There is no need to analyze the story for psychological elements pointing towards whether what the man was perceiving was real or not. Based on Saki’s use of language, it can be easily inferred that what the man saw was real: the family and the dog coming through the bay window. His perception of them was definitely skewed by Vera’s musings, however, and led him to believe that he was viewing tangible evidence of the sprits. Moreover, when setting up the premise, Saki creates the perfect foundation for an appealing and interesting ghost story with Vera’s story of her grieving aunt waiting for her ‘deceased’ family and dog to come through the bay window. At first, the reader is led to believe that the ordeal actually happened. It is not until the very end when the man flees upon sight of the ‘apparitions’ that it becomes apparent that the supernatural is not the focus of the plot. Instead, Saki uses elements of the paranormal to create the setting for the trick punch line at the end where it is revealed to the reader that Vera was using the harrowing story to entertain herself. Saki does not provide particular attention in explanations for the supernatural. He uses the supernatural as a vehicle to communicate his story and mislead the reader so that the ending is unexpected and

Open Document