The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini should not be taught in schools because it is poorly written and does not offer educational value to students. The characters, language, and themes have been poorly developed and do not make the story one worth teaching. To start with, the characters are lacking depth (Murphy). They have very surface beliefs about life, and don't seem to grow throughout the story. For example, the protagonist Amir is only concerned with looking good in the eyes of those he admires, and he doesn't care who could be hurt by his actions. One of these instances is when he and Hassan ran the last kite. He knew that if he was able to bring the kite home, his father would finally be proud of him. So instead of protecting his friend, …show more content…
Similar to the violent content, it is graphic, plentiful, and inappropriate for students. Hosseini describes the rape scene with detail and leaves few things unsaid. This level of description is unnecessary because the readers can understand the same events without using specific and graphic details. Hosseini also sexualizes scenes that do not need to be portrayed that way. For example, while Amir is talking to Assef, Assef "brushed his lips against Sohrab's ear" and "kissed the side of Sohrab's neck" (Hosseini; 281, 282). Assef is a thirty-some-year-old man, and Sohrab is a little ten-year-old boy. The actions between them should not be sexual, yet Hosseini uses words to try to get you to think of them that way. There are many scenes with this kind of sexual material, from Assef's inappropriate behavior with Sohrab, to Amir and his wife "making love", to accounts rape and implied rape. These types of scenes would cause movies to be rated as unsuitable for children, yet schools continue to use books that include sections like this in their classes. The amount of sexual content, as well as the way that the content is depicted, makes many of the scenes seem unnecessarily tasteless, and creates a book that is inappropriate to be taught in …show more content…
The plot includes many unrealistic and dramatic twists. To give a quick overview of these twists: Amir finds out Hassan was really his half-brother when he returns to Pakistan to meet Rahim Khan. Then, Amir is told that Hassan is dead and there is no way for Amir to talk to or to apologize to Hassan. But, Rahim Khan tells Amir, Hassan's son is still alive. Amir must go save him from the dangers in Afghanistan because a couple is waiting to adopt the boy. When he gets to Kabul, Amir finds that the leader of the Taliban in Kabul is Assef, his childhood enemy. Amir must then fight Assef in order to win Sohrab, Hassan's son. Upon returning to Pakistan, Amir finds out that there was never a couple waiting for Sohrab. So, Amir decides he will adopt Sohrab because he and his wife are unable to have children. These nonsensical plot events are so far-fetched that they bring no more reward by reading the book than you would get from watching a soap opera, and therefore the book brings no benefit when taught in
Throughout the thought provoking and eye opening narrative, The Kite Runner, Khaled Hosseini provides a vivid and in depth story told through the eyes of a privileged young narrator who is forced to come of age in the capital of Afghanistan. As a story told from a different cultural perspective,culture and morals in this society are different from foreign beliefs. A reader will not fully comprehend The Kite Runner without discerning the differences between social classes and understanding the importance of honor in the Afghanistan culture.
The purity of a child is often tainted by the morbid realities in society. Unfortunately, there is no typical way that it is stolen. It can happen from movies, television shows, a regretful event, or a book. One Flew Over the Cuckoos Nest, by Ken Kessey, is an example of such a book with its descriptions of systematic torture, sexual discrimination, and scrutinization of the mentally impaired. Furthermore, the book has been banned in multiple schools due to its graphic descriptions being deemed inappropriate for children. However is protecting the innocence of a child a justified exception of the First Amendment? Despite the First Amendment protecting freedom of speech, One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest should be banned from school curriculums
The Kite Runner, is the first novel written by Khaled Hosseini. The Kite Runner is set in Afghanistan before the war in the city of Kabul, and then eventually in America. The novel relays the struggles of Amir (A young Shi’ boy), Hassan (a young Hazera servant boy) and Baba (Amir’s father) as they are growing up in an ever-changing Afghanistan. The young boys face difficult challenges most adults will never have to experience. Amir, Hassan, and even Baba must overcome cruelty in every aspect of their lives.
Betrayal, redemption, and forgiveness are all major themes in The Kite Runner written by Khaled Hosseini. The novel also focuses around the theme of a broken relationship between father and son as well as facing difficult situations from ones past. Amir and Hassan are best friends with two completely different personalities. Each character in the novel faces their own hardships and eventually learns to overcome those difficulties. Beginning with betrayal then the characters have to make their way to gaining redemption and forgiveness from others, as well as their self, is carried on throughout the novel. It is a continuous story of the relationships between Amir and his father Baba and facing their challenges from the past every day of their present.
Trying to learn a new language, new customs, and adapt to the new quality of life that the new country has to offer. The kite runner is shaped by how the past torments the character’s present, and also how these past occurrences have shaped their lives. The four literary elements have shown how it ties in to the theme and main idea of the story. The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini was banned due to its underage sexual violence, which was depicted at least twice throughout the book and also homosexuality.
Amir goes through many events that take place in the book that change him, and the way he is perceived within the book. Amir is a young boy, who is tortured by his father’s scrutinizing character. Amir is also jealous of Hassan, because of the fact that his father likes Hassan instead of Amir. Amir fights for his father’s approval, interest, and love. This is when Amir changes for the good as he deals with the guilt of the rape of Hassan. Amir witnessed Hassan getting raped, but decides to nothing in order to win over his father’s interest. The guilt that Amir builds up is carries from his premature times as a child to his mature times. From Afghanistan to
As implied by the title, kites play a major role in the novel The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini. They appear numerous times within the text and prove to be surprisingly versatile in their literary function. They provide common ground for characters whose interests do not normally intersect. They are also present as a very powerful symbol, which adds an extra dimension to this already literary rich novel. Reversing the roles transcending generations, it shows itself to be a multifaceted medium.
Although this book uses offensive words, it is such an important part of this time period. Some adults may not want their kids reading these stories in school because they can repeat the words and use them offensively. People could also feel that this book isn’t appropriate because it was written so long ago and uses old-fashioned phrases that don't teach students proper English. People will always have their own opinions.
I personally believe that the story, To Kill a Mockingbird should not be banned in schools, and the story should be allowed in students’ curriculum. The first reason to why I believe this to be true would be the fact that it allows students the opportunity to learn about human mistakes and how to be better people in the future. A second reason would be that students are able to learn important parts of our history within the book. It also teaches students important morals that may be hard to teach without the context of a book such as this one.
The Kite Runner is a book about a young boy, Amir, who faces many struggles as he grows up in Kabul and later moves to America to flee from the Taliban. His best friend and brother , Hassan, was a big part of his life, but also a big part of guilt he held onto for many years. The book describes Amir’s attempt to make up for the past and resolve his sins so he can clear his conscious. Amir is worthy of forgiveness because although he was selfish, he was very brave and faced his past.
The other source of tension in Amir’s life is his relationship with Baba, his hard-driving and demanding father. Desperate to win his father’s affection and respect, Amir turns to the sport of kite flying, and at the age of 12, with the assistance of Hassan, he wins the annual tournament in Kabul. Amir’s victory soon is tarnished when he witnesses a vicious assault against his friend, who raced through the streets of Kabul to retrieve the last kite, Amir had sliced from the sky, and fails to come to his aid. Amir’s cowardness is compounded by a later act of betrayal that causes Ali and Hassan to leave their home, and he now faces the nightmare, bearing the burden of his poor choices for the rest of his life.
The book’s opening chapter focuses on Amir's conversation with Rahim and Amir’s "way to be good again” (Hosseini 1). The reason Amir flies all the way to Pakistan leaving behind his wife and life in America is Rahim Khan. Amir desires to make up for what he did to Hassan, so he answers Rahim's quest to “be good again” (Hosseini 1). This meeting allows Rahim to tell Amir what he must do to make up for his past. Rahim tells him he must put his own life in danger to save Hassan’s son, Sohrab. At first, Amir wants to refuse Rahim Khan’s wish, thinking of his life back home. He also thinks about how Hassan’s life may have been different if Hassan had the same opportunities he had. Then he realizes, “ But how can I pack up and go home when my actions may have cost Hassan a chance at those very same things?” (Hosseini 226). Rahim Khan warns Amir that it cannot be anyone else; Amir must make up for his own sins. Although he knows it's dangerous, Amir agrees to get Hassan’s son for Rahim as his dying wish. Amir believes that saving Sohrab is “A way to end the cycle” (Hosseini 227). Amir’s commitment in the face of danger proves his determination to be better and finally atone for his sins. Amir realizes his mistake and knows he can't change what he’d done. Eventually, with Rahim's help, he begins to see saving Sohrab as a “way to be
In my view The Kite Runner is an epic story with a personal history of what the people of Afghanistan had and have to endure in an ordinary every day life; a country that is divided between political powers and religiously idealistic views and beliefs which creates poverty, and violence within the people and their terrorist run country. The story line is more personal with the description of Afghanistan's culture and traditions, along with the lives of the people who live in Kabul. The story provides an educational and eye-opening account of a country's political chaos. Of course there are many things that are unsaid and under explained in this tragic novel which, in my observation, is an oversimplification. There is also a heavy use of emotional appeal, and an underlying message. This is a flag for propaganda.
Kite Runner depicts the story of Amir, a boy living in Afghanistan, and his journey throughout life. He experiences periods of happiness, sorrow, and confusion as he matures. Amir is shocked by atrocities and blessed by beneficial relationships both in his homeland and the United States. Reviewers have chosen sides and waged a war of words against one another over the notoriety of the book. Many critics of Kite Runner, by Khaled Hosseini, argue that the novel would not have reached a lofty level of success if the U.S. had not had recent dealings with the Middle East, yet other critics accurately relate the novel’s success to its internal aspects.
The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini is a novel based in Afghanistan that shows the betrayal between two boys with two different social backgrounds. Four years later “The Kite Runner” was filmed by David Benioff, which shows the meaningful message that the book delivers in a movie. Throughout the book and movie, Amir the protagonist must live the rest of his life with guilt from his childhood. Although the movie gave the same meaningful message that the book delivered, the book was further developed, which had more detail and kept the readers wanting more. Ultimately these details that were present in the novel gave the readers a better understanding of the characters, which led to the relationships