The Impact Florence Nightingale Had On Medical Care In Scutari

1311 Words3 Pages

The extract from General Sir John Burgoyne to Lord Raglan could be considered relatively limited in terms of identifying the impact Florence Nightingale had on medical care in Scutari.
The source provides insight on the influence of Nightingale’s compassionate attitude. There is a brief comment on the mental state of those wounded in Scutari, who were noticeably appearing in a way that indicated “amendment rather than despondence”. This suggests that Nightingale’s presence and changes to the management greatly improved the wellbeing of the soldiers and the medical care they received. This is true, as while the war waged, soldiers in Scutari wrote ballads about Nightingale, one believing her to be ‘One of Heaven’s best gifts’, implying that …show more content…

In the letter, General Burgoyne does not refer to the dire and disgusting conditions Scutari was in prior to Nightingale’s arrival. Before her presence, there was no stock of necessities in the Scutari, with Nightingale needing to purchase three hundred scrubbing brushes in order to clear, what she described as, an ‘inch of liquid filth’ that covered the floors. Additionally, Nightingale increased the distance between patient beds, reducing the spread of infectious diseases, implemented a healthy diet, and cleaned and dressed wounds regularly. This significantly improved medical care in Scutari, as the vast majority of soldiers who died, died as a result of poor hygiene and sanitation. Furthermore, the source is limited by the fact that it was written in late March 1855 - meaning the letter was written before the enormous affects of the Sanitary Commission were to be seen. The commission employed two hundred Turkish workers to change flea-ridden floors, as well as drain the cesspool beneath the hospital and arguably had the largest impact in reducing the death toll in Scutari. Thus, the source is relatively incomplete and limited regarding the actual previous medical care and hence the impact Nightingale had on supposedly improving it. During the course of the war, 80 per cent of the death rates were a result of men dying from disease or wounds, majority of which, such as cholera, were preventable with improved hygiene and cleaner water. By February 1855, the mortality rate had fallen from 60 per cent to 42.7 per cent. This dramatically reduced further to 2.2 per cent after a fresh water supply was introduced. The source has no recollection of this, limiting it in the sense that there is no mention of the scale of which medical care was problematic in

Open Document