The Haunting Of Hill House Analysis

954 Words2 Pages

Eleanor’s state of mind
Was Eleanor mentally healthy or unhealthy? In the book The Haunting of Hill House, written by Shirley Jackson, the main character was Eleanor Vance. She was a 32-year-old woman that showed signs that she was mentally unhealthy. After receiving an invitation to stay at Hill House from Dr. Montague, a stranger to Eleanor and the rest of the invited guests, she made the carefree decision to accept the invitation to the comfortable country home (2). She felt as though Hill House was her calling, even though she had never laid eyes on the property and had no knowledge of what to expect. There was no way to know if the doctor could have been a psychopath that wanted Eleanor for some crazed morbid “experiment,” yet she had …show more content…

Consequently, she became paranoid and started to grow very hostile in her own thoughts. She does not directly express her hostile and negative feelings to the others. One of Eleanor’s dark thoughts was how “[She] would like to watch her dying,” referring to Theodora, as she smiled back to her saying “Don’t be silly.” Eleanor constantly battled herself mentally and what she portrayed as reality. She was constantly questioning herself and how she might look. “Is she laughing at me? Eleanor wondered; has she decided that I am not fit to stay?” A self-doubt thought, that Eleanor had when Theodora was painting her toenails. “Why me, she wondered, why me? Am I the public conscience? Expected always to say in cold words, what the rest of them are too arrogant to recognize? Am I supposed to be the weakest, weaker than Theodora? (86,103,117). The feelings and thoughts that Eleanor experiences are not that of a rational adult, rather, they stemmed from an unhealthy state of …show more content…

Speaking from personal experience in dealing with a mentally unhealthy adult that is bipolar, that is unable to think rationally and that lives in a fantasy world made up of lies and paranoia, Eleanor showed all the same traits. Certain events that may have taken place in her life might have kicked her mind into a different unhealthy state, such as isolation from the world due to taking care of her ill mother or even the death of her father when she was a small child. There could be a multitude of things that could have set her mind into the very different and unhealthy state of mind that she was in, therefore, causing her to take her own

Open Document