The Giving Tree Shel Silverstein Analysis

996 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Cultural criticism of the giving tree by shel silverstein

have you ever wondered how you can teach your children about how giving is better than receiving? the book, the giving tree written by shel silverstein, he shows how giving is better than receiving. this book is really good for people of all ages. for those people who are greedy, this book is a great way to show them that its better to give. this book is a very good read. it will help you learn its better to give that receive. the tree and the boy have a special connection, they love being around each other. theres so many things that indicates that they love each other and are happy when around each other. “and every day the boy would come and he would gather her leaves and make them a crown and play king of the forest” is one way of saying they enjoy the company. “and when he was tired, he would sleep in her shade.” is another example. the two sentences are saying that when the tree is giving something to the boy and in return the tree is getting …show more content…

the tree will always love the boy but the trees still lonely. “I want a house to keep me warm, he said. i want a wife and i want children, and so i need a house. can you give me a house?”, “I am too old and sad to play, said the boy. I want a boat that will take me far away from here. can you give me a boat?”. these sentences from the book shows that the boy has grown up and has returned to the tree, but he only returned to get something from him, and that seems a little selfish. “I have no house,” said the tree. The forest is my house, but you may cut off my branches and build a house. then you will be happy. cut down my trunk and make a boat, said the tree. than you can sail way… and be happy.” this part is showing that all the tree wants is for the boy to be happy, by doing that the tree sacrifices things for the boy to be happy. the boy will soon return to the tree for something more, but the question is when will he return and what will he ask for

Show More
Related

  • Loss of Innocence

    1336 Words  | 3 Pages

    Knowles foreshadows the boys’ loss of innocence through the war, and their constant jumps from the tree. While getting ready for the war the boys practice and show off their skills on the tree by the Devon River. These jumps are done for fun yet the boys see them as a routine, something that has to be done. Knowles brings the theme of the loss of innocence in the novel for the first time by portraying Finny as the defender who gets the boys out of trouble by saying they had to jump out of the tree (22). This foreshadows how the innocence of the boys will be banished from themselves and their world. The tree also symbolizes the Forbidden Tree of Knowledge. Just like it is forbidden to eat the fruit, jumping from the tree was not allowed as well. By jumping from the tree the boys symbolically accept their loss of innocence, just like Adam and Eve accepted theirs.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of All That Time By May Swenson

    1068 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the second stanza the poet describes the tree as thin, dry and insecure. Insecurity is a human nature that has been used to describe a

    Read More

  • Diction In Blackberry-Picking

    438 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the second and last stanza of the poem we are reminded that he was but a child. The thought of losing the berries “always made him feel like crying” the thought of all that beauty gone so sour in the aftermath of lust. The lack of wisdom in younger years is emphasized by the common childish retort of “It wasn’t fair.” He kept up the childish hope that this time would be different, that this time the berries would keep and that the lust, work, and pain might not have been in vain, that others would not “glut” upon what he desired.

    Read More

  • Red Symbolism In Beloved

    992 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Christianity, trees were viewed as a primary source of life and knowledge, exhibited in the Garden of Eden (Genesis 2:9). Denver used trees as a safe haven for her; a safe place where she can hide from her mother after the trauma that transpired the night that crawling already? was killed. “Veiled and protected by the live green walls, she felt ripe and clear, and salvation was as easy as a wish,”(Morrison, 29). Contrasting with the safety of the trees for Denver, Sethe’s idea of trees has much darker connotations. As a child, she saw “Boys hangin’ from the most beautiful sycamores in the world. It shamed her-remembering the wonderful soughing trees rather than the boys,” (Morrison 6). For Sethe, the symbolism of trees has been twisted into viewing trees not as hope, but as death, and the pain from her past. As Amy had observed, the scars on Sethe only served as reminders of her painful time at Sweet Home, where she had very little hope for the future. A lesson that should be derived from this book is that the perspective from which you look at the past could help it become less painful. Sethe is too focused on the pain of her past, so therefore she is unable to see trees as they were meant to be seen, while Paul D views them as a pathway to second chances. He views trees as “inviting; things you could trust and be ear; talk to if you wanted to as he frequently did since way back when he took the midday meal in the fields of Sweet Home,” (Morrison,

    Read More

  • Theme Of A Tree Grows In Brooklyn

    1046 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Tree of Heaven is crucial to the novel as it represents the lives of poor people and it also suggests that Francie will grow up to become much stronger despite her struggles surrounding her impoverished family. There are multiple references to trees in the first third of the story. Multiple character refer to the tree in order to talk about strength and the hardships of growing up. The setting of the story is also very important in shaping Francie as a character because it allows the audience to see Williamsburg through Francie’s eyes and create more of an understanding of her situation and feelings. In the beginning of the novel, it is also evident that Francie takes great pleasure in books and reading which displays her childlike wonder. The idea of imagination and childlike wonder is very important to Francie as a character because it shows the reader that even though she is in this very difficult situation, she is still a young child having to deal with people in her community shaming her family. Mary Rommely, Katie’s mother, also discusses the importance of imagination with her just after Francie is born. She tells her “the child must have a valuable thing which is called imagination. The child must have a secret world in which live things that never were. It is necessary that she believe.” The theme of gender difference is also an important part of the story. Normally in a household, the man would be in charge of the house and finances, but because of Johnny’s alcohol problem, Katie must become much stronger and take control in the house. After Francie is born and Katie is having her discussion with her mother, Mary grows upset because she believes being born a woman leads to a life of

    Read More

  • What Does The Juniper Tree Mean

    1089 Words  | 3 Pages

    During the story, the actual Juniper Tree that is mentioned, is shown to repeatedly have a calming effect onto whomever was sad beneath the tree. In the beginning of the fairy tale, the boy’s birth mother is depicted as being sad under the tree until she wished for a child and then “she was happy; [and] she had a feeling something

    Read More

  • Planting A Sequeia By Dana Gioia Summary

    722 Words  | 2 Pages

    The entire poem is driven by juxtaposed ideas like life and death or the brevity of life versus the eternal lifetime of a sequoia tree. The idea of planting a tree for a child originally comes from a Sicilian tradition that symbolizes birth and celebration instead of pain and loss, like Gioia represents it in his poem. But the tree does not solely represent the Gioia’s son’s memory, but it also symbolizes the brevity of life. The tree will grow into a native giant and even when Gioia dies and all of his unborn children will have passed, the sequoia tree will live and grow. A human lifetime to the tree will seem like a cherry blossom to man, brief and

    Read More

  • Sweet Whispers, Brother Rush

    854 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...rly revealing scene is when she hands Miss Pricherd the list of chores. We see Tree’s struggle to demonstrate her maturity and her power. It is thus fitting that we see her world through her eyes, as her emotional growth is the focus of this novel.

    Read More

  • The Symbolism of the Forest in The Scarlet Letter

    923 Words  | 2 Pages

    The forest additionally symbolizes the relationship in which native serves as a place of empowerment for individuals. This also adds to those the themes. The forest is a symbol of Prynne and Dimmesdale’s empowerment in the truth, hope and love. Upon their meeting in the forest, both feel positively changed as qu...

    Read More

  • Irving Textual Analysis of "The Legend Of Sllepy Hollow"

    1707 Words  | 4 Pages

    The tree is almost created into somewhat of a creature.  With the limbs twisting out and rising into the air.  Irving takes ordinary earthlike objects and changes the perspective of them into imaginary matter.

    Read More

  • An Analysis of Frost's Tree at my Window

    839 Words  | 2 Pages

    The narrator begins the second stanza mentioning a dream that is unclear. He then stops short and continues, seemingly describing the appearance of the tree. Referring to "head lifted out of the ground, / Not all your light tonuges taliking aloud / could be profound." Perhaps the speaker could be describing the vastness of the tree's height and width along with the magnitude of leaves. Comparing tongues to leaves is a possibility because, as the wind rushes through them, it causes a distinct sound. The speaker may even believe that the tree has insight to his feelings (Webster ...

    Read More

  • Use of Symbols in Ibsen's Play, A Doll's House

    860 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Christmas tree, a festive object meant to serve a decorative purpose, symbolizes Nora’s position in her household as a plaything who is pleasing to look at. Ibsen’s use of the Christmas tree is portrayed throughout the play. The Christmas tree symbolized Nora’s feelings. In the First act there is a festive tree with “pretty red flowers” and Nora comes in the house carelessly. Nora’s mood is festive and tree gives a merry glow to the reader. At the end of act 1, Nora has been threatened by krogstad that if she doesn’t help him keep the job, he will tell Torvald about the illegal loan. Torvald on the other hand believes that Krogstad “forged someone name” and will be fired. So in act II, the tree is striped of his ornaments. In the act the tree is dropping along with Nora’s Hope and Happiness. The tree helps the reader fell the anxiety of Nora’s feelings. A Christmas tree itself is a symbol for joy so that is why it is used. Through all times and even in the bible trees and flowers have been a subject of wonderment; a symbol of life, that is why Ibsen uses this as a symbol of Nora’s feelings.

    Read More

  • Selfishness In Shel Silverstein's 'The Giving Tree'

    452 Words  | 1 Pages

    Do you think that some people are selfish enough to take everything? In the book it seems that some people in the world are selfish and others are very giving or selfless. In the Giving Tree the boy keeps coming back for more and more, and the tree would give and give. Last, when the boy got supplies he wouldn't stay to make the tree happy. In The Giving Tree, Shel Silverstein uses selfishness and givingness to explain the tree’s relationship with the boy.

    Read More

  • “Birches”; the comparisons to imagination and reality.

    1088 Words  | 3 Pages

    As Frost initially interacts with the woods, the Birch trees, he is reminded of his memories of childhood, how he associates the trees with his own youthful activities. Frost reflects on the trees immediately in the poem, referring to how he would prefer that the Birch trees were bent over by boys at play. “When I see birches bent to left and right Across the lines of straighter darker trees, I like to think some boy’s been swinging them” (1-3). In this passage Frost begins the poem with the opinion that, as he sees the bent Birch tree, he would rather have the Birches bent over by boys. In this instance Frost displays a preference to the innocent, almost destructiveness, of children as opposed to nature having subdued the trees. Because the children who bent the Birch trees over had perceiva...

    Read More

  • The Value of Trees

    779 Words  | 2 Pages

    Trees are usually considered as bland, unusual objects that are usually taken for granted; however, I believe there is more to a tree that meets the eye. They supply oxygen and shade. During the holidays, trees are able to spread holiday cheer by wearing holiday decorations. Through providing, they are always beneficial to the needs of others. Rather than having striking beauty like a flower, trees have are grounded and possess a gentle beauty; they are adapted wildflowers to their environment. In fact, if I had to compare myself to an inanimate object, I would choose a tree. A tree has many characteristics in common with me. Characteristics like relying on our roots, strength and observation, and helping others and leaving behind a powerful legacy are a few of the traits we share. All of which I believe are admirable qualities to possess.

    Read More

More about The Giving Tree Shel Silverstein Analysis

Open Document