The Effect of Removing a Scene From Shakespeare's Hamlet

507 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Hamlet AND psychological

The Effect of Removing a Scene From Shakespeare's Hamlet

Hamlet is obsessed with revenging his fathers murder; destroying Claudius and it is evident in the play. This obsession initiates Hamlet's behavior. The reasons for Hamlet's obsession with exacting revenge against Claudius are fairly straightforward. The ghost of Hamlet informed him that Claudius killed Hamlet Sr., seized his throne and robbed him of his father. After the ghost informs Hamlet of Claudius' crime, Hamlet realizes that if he does not kill Claudius, he may forever be locked in the painfully stressful mental state in which his obsession puts him. If he attempts or succeeds in killing Claudius, he risks experiencing psychological estrangement so intense that it could destroy his sense of identity. Whether he does or does not kill Claudius, he faces enormous psychological pain.

The second to last decision that Hamlet makes with regard to Claudius is to not kill him, but to allow fate and divine forces to take over his responsibility. He makes this decision mainly as a means of escaping the intense madness under which he finds himself and, instead, entering a much more psychologically peaceful state; denial. Although this reason may seem illogical, Shakespeare clearly emphasizes the importance of such a motivation to escape pain in Hamlet's decision-making. He does so in the Player's scene, which emphasizes that Hamlet is obsessed with disproving Claudius' guilt. The advantage of disproving such guilt is that it resolves Hamlet's pain, showing that the motivation to escape the pain of his obsession is prominent in Hamlet's decision-making. Escaping in denial also seems to be Hamlet's best option at this point since, having previously confronted Gertrude with the premises of Claudius' crime, she failed to respond with recognition of them and disapproval of Claudius.

Ultimately, Hamlet does decide to kill Claudius. He does so for a variety of reasons. Most importantly, his mother; in drinking Claudius' drink and poisoning herself, she becomes conscious of Claudius' treachery and implies withdrawal of all support of Claudius. This eliminates the threat of motherly estrangement, virtually paving the way for Hamlet to kill Claudius. Also, however, Laertes informs Hamlet of his knowledge of Claudius' treachery in the very end, as well as his distaste for Claudius, thus removing the threat of friend estrangement. In addition, Claudius' treachery is itself immoral, justifying Hamlet to kill him on principle and since Hamlet was mortally wounded, he had nothing to lose.

Show More
Related

  • There is Something Rotten in Denmark in Hamlet by Sharkespeare

    953 Words  | 2 Pages

    Throughout the plot the playwright uses the desire for revenge for the death of the King. When speaking with his father he commands Hamlet to “[revenge] [my] foul and most unnatural murder” (1.5.25). Hamlet is now obliged to kill Claudius to avenge his father

    Read More

  • David And Hamlet

    1453 Words  | 3 Pages

    Whenever Hamlet denies his true nature, his actions are very harsh. During a heated discussion with his mother Gertrude, he accidentally slays Laertes’ father, Polonius, thinking it to be Claudius. Hamlet quickly brushes it aside. He also sends his friends , Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, to their deaths when he learns of Claudius’ plot to have him put to death when he arrived in England as a so called diplomat.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Fortinbras In Shakespeare's Hamlet

    966 Words  | 2 Pages

    Shakespeare’s Hamlet depicts an internal struggle in which Hamlet must battle his cowardice to do what is right for his father, his mother, and Denmark. The play shows Hamlet attempting to avenge his father’s, King Hamlet, death. The ghost of King Hamlet returns to speak with Hamlet regarding the matter. Unlike what the country has been told, his father informs Hamlet that he had in fact been murdered by Claudius, Hamlet’s uncle who had taken the throne. King Hamlet assigns his son with the task of killing Claudius and retaking the throne of Denmark. It is at this point in the play that Hamlet truly begins to display his cowardice. He does not act in many situations in which he is given the opportunity to kill Claudius. Rather than embarking upon a murderous rampage, Hamlet decides to act as though he has gone insane to fool the rest of the court, eventually with the result being the

    Read More

  • Is Hamlet Responsible For The Death Of His Father Analysis

    1134 Words  | 3 Pages

    While reading the play it is evident Hamlet wants to kill Claudius for murdering his father and he comes across a number of different times to do so however he never actually does so until the very end. Hamlet struggles within himself on why he

    Read More

  • Hamlets Obsession with Death

    1081 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Hamlet, William Shakespeare presents the main character Hamlet as a man who is fixated on death. Shakespeare uses this obsession to explore both Hamlet's desire for revenge and his need for assurance. In the process, Shakespeare directs Hamlet to reflect on basic principles such as justice and truth by offering many examples of Hamlet's compulsive behavior; as thoughts of death are never far from his mind. It is apparent that Hamlet is haunted by his father's death. When Hamlet encounters the ghost of his father, their conversation raises all kinds of unthinkable questions, for example murder by a brother, unfaithful mother, that triggers Hamlet's obsession. He feels compelled to determine the reliability of the ghost's statements so that he can determine how he must act. Ultimately, it is his obsession with death that leads to Hamlet avenging the death of his father by killing Claudius.

    Read More

  • The Thought Of Revenge In Shakespeare's Hamlet

    1586 Words  | 4 Pages

    Revenge consumes Hamlet 's every move throughout the entire play. This all starts from the moment his father 's ghost tells him that his horrific death was not accidental. He was murdererd; poisoned by the new King, Claudius, also known as Hamlet 's uncle. Hamlet pretends to be insane to hide his true feelings of hate for the new King. He seeks the truth by reading the King 's body language when presented with a reenactment of Hamlet 's father 's death. Then the King acts in a

    Read More

  • Free Hamlet Essays: An Eye for an Eye

    569 Words  | 2 Pages

    Hamlet was told by the ghost of king hamlet to get back at Claudius for his death, or his soul will travel on earth forever. Even before hamlet knew about Claudius killing his father he had problems. It made hamlet mad that his mother would marry so fast and with his uncle. What Claudius did was an outrageous, back stabbing, and unbelievable thing. It was clearly an act of jealousy for his brother's throne and the wife. Claudius did pay back for his actions. Claudius lost his wife, his messenger, and died and even after his death kept loosing because he lost his castle to Fortinbras.

    Read More

  • Hamlet's Hesitation Analysis

    958 Words  | 2 Pages

    Hamlet’s fatal flaw of hesitation is the reason why he did not carry out a plan to seek revenge for his father’s death, but the love that he felt for his mother enabled him to act when she died. Throughout the five acts of the play, Hamlet made several excuses as to why he could not kill Claudius. One of those many excuses was that he could not kill Claudius at the end of Act 3, Scene 3, when he was praying, as he would be sent to heaven:” Now might I do it pat. Now he is a-praying. And now I’ll do ’t. And so he goes to heaven. And so am I revenged.—That would be scanned. A villain kills my father, and, for that, I, his sole son, do this same villain send to heaven.” Hamlet’s hesitation, therefore, demonstrates that he did not love his father as he could have enacted his revenge, but chose to wait until his mother was in danger, proving that his revenge was solely in defense of her. In addition to this, Hamlet overthinks everything, which is another one of his downfalls. Yet, when Gertrude is poisoned, he throws caution to the wind and acts without thinking. After she collapses and he realizes that she has been poisoned by Claudius, he forces him to drink, which then kills him. Hamlet’s immediate action in defense of Gertrude attests to the fact that his revenge was purely in defense of his

    Read More

  • Hamlet's Fatal Flaw

    783 Words  | 2 Pages

    Hamlet's character lends itself to a possible motivation for his unwillingness to kill Claudius. He is a scholar, and a student of theology. It is a moral dilemma for Hamlet to kill without a just cause, or kill at all. He wants proof of the part his uncle and his mother played in his father's death. His royal birth leads him to consider his responsibilities to his country, which is Hamlet's internal conflict throughout the play.

    Read More

  • To Be or Not to Be: Hamlet

    833 Words  | 2 Pages

    Claudius is one of the main characters responsible for his own death in the play because he portrays himself to be untouchable; not thinking clearly of the consequences to his actions. He starts off by killing his own brother and marrying his queen, Gertrude, only because he lust power and sex. His cold-hearted actions make him the antagonist of Hamlet and most deserving of death. Through all of his malicious actions, he plans a duel between Laertes and Hamlet assuring Hamlet’s death as well by poisoning a drink and the end of Laertes’ sword. He definitely got a taste of his own medicine because he died a rightful death by the sa...

    Read More

  • Why Is Claudius A Villain

    1447 Words  | 3 Pages

    Claudius, using his wits, convinced Laertes that Hamlet should be killed, “To show yourself your father’s son in deed/ More than in words? / To cut his throat I’ the church!” (Hamlet 4.7 125-127). Claudius learns that Hamlet is still alive he thought of a master plan to use Laertes to kill Hamlet. Claudius has already turned Laertes against Hamlet by saying that he murdered his father in cold blood and has gone unpunished because the queen and all the kingdom is in love with him. Laertes who is fueled by misguided anger is prepared to do whatever it takes to get his revenge against Hamlet. Laertes simply suggests that he kill Hamlet in cold blood, but Claudius uses his superior intelligence to come up with a truly dark and evil plan to kill Hamlet. Intelligence is mostly thought of as an admirable quality but a select few choose to use it for the wrong reasons. It can sometimes lead people to think they are above the law and can simply get away with whatever terrible crime the commit (Nyborg 344-345). This was the case with Claudius he thought that he had planned the murder carefully and meticulously enough that no one would ever ask questions. Even once Hamlet knew his evil secret Claudius did not give up he came up with plan after plan to kill Hamlet. Claudius, in his mind, had thought that he had earned everything he had acquired. He may have

    Read More

  • Revenge In Hamlet

    1103 Words  | 3 Pages

    Hamlets first opportunity to kill Claudius that he actually considers is when Claudius is confessing to god. Hamlet decides not to kill him at this point because he does not want to kill him while he is praying because he will go to heaven. This is the farthest that Hamlet has come to killing Claudius so far as his sword was drawn and ready to be used until he thinks logically and realizes that Claudius will be free from sin at the time of his death. This was a luxury that his father did not even have so why should he allow Claudius to have it.

    Read More

  • Hamlet Literary Analysis

    1883 Words  | 4 Pages

    Throughout the whole play, Hamlet wrestles with an inner conflict that ultimately costs not only Claudius’ life, but also many others, including his own. He even feels that playing one role can transform his inner feelings as well. While one moment Hamlet is committed to revenge, the next moment he is not sure if Claudius was the killer. In one scene Hamlet praises acting and realizes his role, but in the next he decides to put off his deeds. If Hamlet had followed through with his actions, and had not debated so often, there would have been fewer deaths. Hamlet’s inability to act lead to everyone’s demise.

    Read More

  • The Evil Character In Shakespeare's Hamlet And Othello

    2328 Words  | 5 Pages

    The findings in Sarah Casimong in “Does Love Make You Do Stupid Things?” can also be applied to Hamlet. He also had impaired judgement due to his love for his father. Hamlet seemed to think very highly of his father and he sincerely loved him. Hamlet refers to his father at the beginning of the play as “Hercules” and “excellent king”. He also says “He was a man, take him for allin all, I shall not look upon his like again." (I.ii.139-188). This shows how much his father meant to him. So when the ghost of his father tells him that Claudius murdered him; Hamlet felt the need to gain revenge for him. Claudius being the man, who killed his father and then took the throne by marrying Queen Gertrude, makes it logical that Hamlet would have a vendetta towards him. Hamlet began to be consumed with the need to revenge his father and it started to control his life. Ashley Fern wrote, “When people seek out revenge, it tends to consume them entirely. Some people take it way too far and it is hard to control yourself once you get going.” (Fern, Ashley). Hamlet’s life was driven by a need for revenge and his actions couldn’t be controlled because of this. Hamlet’s life was in shambles at this point because what he thought was true was shown to be false. Claudius acted as though he grieved for his father when in actuality he was the one responsible for it. He says, “Though yet of Hamlet

    Read More

  • Fate And Free Will In Hamlet Analysis

    1204 Words  | 3 Pages

    ... the murderer accountable for death of his father. Had Hamlet killed Claudius at an earlier time, providing he was not caught, he may have spared the lives of many others in the effect of his indecisive conscience, including his own. Hamlet’s internal contemplation and emotions drive the more physical stages of conflict and it is purely the internal conflicts that ultimately inflame the reckless display of violence. Using his God-given free will, Hamlet made decisions throughout the play that directly caused many deaths: Polonius, Rosencrantz, Guildenstern, Ophelia, Laertes, Claudius, and himself. These losses are not the result of self-defence or of fate. In any case, Hamlet’s decisions help create his own revenge tragedy, as his choices directly and ultimately destroy him.

    Read More

More about The Effect of Removing a Scene From Shakespeare's Hamlet

Open Document