The Puritan Dilemma is the story of John Winthrop growing up in the Puritan colonization of America. This book tells the reader of the events that Puritans had to go through during that time period. The book also talks about the attempts, both by John Winthrop and the Puritans, to establish a new type of society in the New World, something they couldn’t do in England. This story is told by the theology of the Puritan ideas, and focuses a lot on how their beliefs intervene in their daily lives, churches, and political ideologies. Puritanism was the belief that the Church of England should remove traditions that inherited from the Catholic Church, and make the Church of England more pure in Christ.
The book starts by stating that Henry VIII
…show more content…
turned his back to the Pope, and doing this back in those days was not a good idea, because the Pope was viewed a supreme leader, and for Catholics the Pope was Second after God. “That was in 1544. Forty-four years later… John Winthrop was born, grandson to Adam” (P.1). The chapter gives an insight of John’s beginnings and the way his father was successful with in business. The chapter states how John’s father, Adam, is good gentlemen, and carried the fortune of his family from good to better, and it’s up to John to keep the family fortune, “John’s father, the second one Adam Winthrop of Groton, was one of the good ones. He had been trained in the law, but after coming into possession of the manor he devoted himself entirely to the difficult business of making it a success.” (P.2). Something that surprised me was that back in the Puritans times, parents were the ones arranging marriages for their young adult son’s and daughter’s. According to the book John’s opportunity to get married came at a fairly young age, “March 28, 1605, the couple were contracted, a ceremony corresponding to our engagement. Within three weeks they were married, John having then attained the age of seventeen.” (P.4). John married the daughter of Mr. John Forth of Great Stambridge, her name was Mary. Mary conceived six children in ten years, and unfortunately died in 1615, and like any other man he had to remarry, in six-months he married Thomasine Clopton, “…a godly young woman of an old and respected Suffolk family.” (P.10). But the dark cloud struck John again, and on the first anniversary of their wedding she died, but at the age of thirty he married again to Margaret Tyndal, the daughter of Sir John Tyndal, and he found a woman he could love. All of this made John become familiar with himself, he knew that this was all part of the walk with God, and that the path was full of temptation from the devil, but he will resist because God will reward him for being faithful. The book then shifts to the wickedness and evil times of society, and the Puritans believed that the wrath of God would come if bad continued to expand.
Puritans believed that every individual or kingdom was placed by the Almighty, and if the individuals were faithful to the Almighty, He would reward them. Whenever bad situations arose, anything from drought to scarcity, they accepted it, because they believed it was a punishment for disobedience, “Preachers sounded the alarm again and again, calling up the memory of Sodom and Gomorrah” (P.17). Sodom and Gomorrah are the cities that were destroyed by the wrath of God, according to the Old Testament in the Bible. John believed that the English government was “under the shadow God’s wrath” (P.18), Charles I became king in 1625, and demanded the loyalty of the Parliament, King Charles I accepted Arminianism, which is the belief that attempts to explain the relationship between God’s sovereignty and individual free will. The book states that Puritans had three options: overthrow Charles, separate from the Church of England and make their own, or leave England together as a group. John decided to head to Massachusetts, since this was the opportunity God has given him to be prosperous, by using his talents and practicing true Puritanism,” The colony was to be a refuge for truth, a religious rather than a commercial …show more content…
enterprise”(P.39). John becomes the governor of the colony, and the general court of the company would be the legislative body.
John persuaded and got the Puritans to join the expedition to the New World, and the main reason for the persuasion was because of their faith, where in the New World they could practice it, and with God’s favor by their side. John prepared for the expedition to the New World, but although he prepared, the first 1,000 settlers were unprepared for what they encountered in Massachusetts. Cold winters killed men, and most of them were not prepared for the new things that were in the New England. They finally settled in Charlestown. “He returned with the conclusion that the bay was the place to settle: there was plenty of champion land on its rivers and peninsulas…” (P.54), it offered them protection and security. John was a leader to the Puritan community, and stated that they had a special calling from God, much like the way Israel in ancient times, and just like Israel followed Moises, and the Puritans followed John’s commands. Dangers of separatism came across the minds of the Puritans, and was an issue that John had to deal with it. Puritans wanted an establishment of a church in which God commanded it to be, they wanted an end for bishops, and archbishops, “…an end to the idolatrous ritual and trappings that exalted the clergy instead of God in the divine service…” (P.70). Two groups immerged because of this, the Congregationalists which believe there should be no
central church organization and each congregation should be independent, and the Presbyterians believe there should be a central church organization. As Puritanism grew in the New World, a form of government had to be established, there had to be rules, and there had to be organization. The leaders of the Puritan community ensured that the government had Puritan values by limiting the right to vote to people who have become members of the Puritan Church, and non-puritans were humiliated and executed. John, just like any other leader according to the book had his weakness and strength. Winthrop was skilled in law and business, and he treated puritans like they were his own children. Often time’s things would get out of control and a lot of people would die under lack of supplies, however he would get money from his own fund to help out the situations in the Puritan community. On September 18, 1634 two individuals disembarked, one by the name of William Hutchinson, and his wife Anne Hutchinson, according to Winthrop, “described Hutchinson as a man of very mild temper and weak parts, and wholly guided by his wife”(P.125), and according to the writer “She was not, by intention at least, a Separatist…”(P.126). Anne Hutchinson views Antinomianism as a form of nihilism, which means life is viewed without a specific purpose, or value, and it goes along with how there is no such thing as predestination and goes against Calvinism that states that God created everything. Unfortunately in 1640 John had personal matters that troubled his life, John Winthrop came close to becoming bankrupt, and he was helped by congress and was given land. His health diminished, and unfortunately in 1649 he died in his sleep. John Winthrop contributed a lot to the Puritans in the New World, from their success to their failures. John had been so successful in keeping Massachusetts true to her commission, and the world wanted to follow. Thanks to John, Massachusetts Bay had a strong belief to continue its faith, and became successful because of the foundations it was founded upon.
In the 1700’s the Puritans left England for the fear of being persecuted. They moved to America for religious freedom. The Puritans lived from God’s laws. They did not depend as much on material things, and they had a simpler and conservative life. More than a hundred years later, the Puritan’s belief toward their church started to fade away. Some Puritans were not able to recognize their religion any longer, they felt that their congregations had grown too self-satisfied. They left their congregations, and their devotion to God gradually faded away. To rekindle the fervor that the early Puritans had, Jonathan Edwards and other Puritan ministers led a religious revival through New England. Edwards preached intense sermons that awakened his congregation to an awareness of their sins. With Edwards’ sermon, “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” he persuades the Puritans to convert back to Puritanism, by utilizing rhetorical strategies such as, imagery, loaded diction, and a threatening and fearful tone.
Puritans fleeing religious persecution in England settled New England. They were a highly religious people. Document A, John Winthrop’s “ City on a hill” speech, shows how they lived according to God’s will and were very community oriented. Their towns were very planned out with a town/ church meetinghouse in the centre, and land plots for everyone in the community. This is shown in Document D, Articles of Agreement in Springfield Massachusetts 1636. Family was also very important. Since they were very religious and family is highly regarded in the Bible, marriage was advocated and adultery was a huge crime. Adulterers were made to wear the letter A on their clothing. Since they were a very close-knit people, they travelled as big families and sometimes as communities. This mass travel is depicted in document B that is a ship’s list of emigrants bound for New Engla...
Miller Edwards,Hawthorne and korning each show how religion was a sin in puritan cultures and affected many people’s lives that punishment will come when you have disgraced your religion that good is against the devil there is a strict form of puritan. Puritans were dedicated to work to save themselves from the sins in the world. Guilt was a great force in the puritans belief. The people in the story are Puritans a religion often depicted because of its rules and severe punishments to those who sin. The puritans left england to avoid religious persecution they established a society in America founded upon religion intolerance, Up surprising result the church dominates the Puritan culture.
The colonists had different reasons for settling in these two distinct regions. The New England region was a more religiously strict yet diverse area compared to that of the Chesapeake Bay. The development of religion in the two regions came from separate roots. After Henry VIII and the Roman Catholic Church broke away from each other, a new group of English reformers was created called the Puritans. The Puritans came from protestant backgrounds, after being influenced by Calvinistic ideas. When their reforms were thwarted by King James I of England, they fled to the New World in what is now known as the "Great Migration". The Puritans were then joined by Quakers, Protestants, and Catholics in the religiously diverse New England area. These diverse religious factions were allowed to live freely but under the laws of New England. It was due to this religious freedom that these people came to escape religious persecution back home. The New Englanders had a religion-based society and religion was based on family. As the Bible highly regarded family, it condemned adultery. Adultery was considered a punishable crime. Adulterers were marked as impure by a letter "A" stitched on their clothing, as in the book "The Scarlet Letter" by Nathaniel Hawthorne. As religion was a very high priority in New England, it was very much less severe in the Chesapeake Bay region. The one established church in the region, the Anglican Church of Jesus Christ, was only then established in 1692, more than 70 years after the Pilgrims landed at Plymouth Rock.
Edmund S. Morgan's book, "The Puritan Dilemma", is an account of the events encountered by John Winthrop's mission of creating a city on a hill. Winthrop leads and directs the Massachusetts Bay Company, to the new world, while trying to find a solution to the Puritan dilemma, which was how they were going to live in the world while trying to live up to the ideals in the Bible. These ideals lead John Winthrop to propose the creation of a “city on a hill”. His proposition involves reforming the Church of England, in the new world, by purifying the church of all its flaws. It would create a citadel of God’s chosen people, the kind of society that God demanded of all His servants. According to Winthrop, "They should be purified of their unregenerate members, their heretical clergymen, their unwarranted ceremonies, their bishops, and archbishops, but they were nevertheless churches and must be embraced as churches". (Morgan, 27) Winthrop continues to emphasize that they have been selected by God, like Israel of old, to serve as a model society to others; they would be a “city on a hill” for everyone to see and observe.
The Puritans didn't have all the luxuries we have today. They were told many things by preachers such as Jonathon Edwards, who lit a candle of fear in their minds. If I was alive to hear Edwards preach, I'd certainly have to question myself. He preached that God holds us in his hands and he can make or break us. If God decides it so, he will let us go and we will fall from his hands to nothing but Hell. Certainly no one wants to go to Hell. So, the Puritans tried to better their lives, and go by rules or "resolutions." They believed if they followed these resolutions, even though their fate was predetermined by God, they could live a life of good and maybe prove they are meant to go to Heaven.
Though there were religious concerns that contributed to the settling of British North America, the economic concerns outweighed the notable religious concerns. A religious concern that played a role in British colonization was that the British wanted to have the Indians of North America converted to Protestant Christianity (Boorstin et al. 34). In addition, specific groups that were seeking religious freedom used the British colonizing as a venue to achieve this objective. Such groups included the Puritan separatists who had begun to lose their freedoms in England, and thus they became colonists in New England.
In distinction to the early eighteenth century, the small groups of integral Puritans families dominated the economic, military, and political leadership of New England. The Puritans agreed that the church composed many families and wasn’t isolated people. The Puritan family was the major unit of production in the economic system each family member expected an economically useful benefit and the older children worked in some family industries, trending gardens, forcing animals, rotating wool, and protecting their younger brothers and sisters. Wives needed to supervise servants and apprentices to keep their financial accounts, enlightened crops, and to display goods. The Puritans had faith in the larger community that had a compelling duty to secure the families and to see their functions.
Religion was the foundation of the early Colonial American Puritan writings. Many of the early settlements were comprised of men and women who fled Europe in the face of persecution to come to a new land and worship according to their own will. Their beliefs were stalwartly rooted in the fact that God should be involved with all facets of their lives and constantly worshiped. These Puritans writings focused on their religious foundations related to their exodus from Europe and religions role in their life on the new continent. Their literature helped to proselytize the message of God and focused on hard work and strict adherence to religious principles, thus avoiding eternal damnation. These main themes are evident in the writings of Jonathan Edwards, Cotton Mathers, and John Winthrop. This paper will explore the writings of these three men and how their religious views shaped their literary works, styles, and their historical and political views.
The church and Christian beliefs had a very large impact on the Puritan religion and lifestyle. According to discovery education, “Church was the cornerstone of the mainly Puritan society of the 17th century.”( Douglas 4). Puritan laws were intensively rigid and people in society were expected to follow a moral strict code. And because of Puritans and their strict moral codes, any act that was considered to go against this code was considered a sin and deserved to be punished. In Puritan theology, God h...
In 1534, King Henry VIII formally instigated the English Reformation. He therefore passed the Act of Supremacy, which outlawed the Catholic Church and made him “the only supreme head on earth of the Church of England” (Roark, 68). Puritans were looking for a more Protestant church and received what they wanted. Along with it, came the King’s total control over the Church. This is what the Puritans didn’t want. Puritans believed that ordinary Christians, not a church hierarchy, should control religious life. They wanted a distinct line between government and the Church of England. Puritans also wanted to eliminate the customs of Catholic worship and instead focus on an individual’s relationship with God developed through Bible study, prayer, and introspection (Roark, 68).
The Puritans were Englishmen who chose to separate from the Church of England. Puritans believed that the Anglican Church or Church of England resembled the Roman Catholic Church too closely and was in dire need of reform. Furthermore, they were not free to follow their own religious beliefs without punishment. In the sixteenth century the Puritans settled in the New England area with the idea of regaining their principles of the Christi...
Winthrop had decided to leave England to found a godly community in the new world. Like most Puritans, Winthrop was extremely religious and subscribed fervently to the Puritan belief that the Anglican Church had to be cleansed of Catholic ritual. Winthrop was convinced that God was going to punish the English Puritans for its heresy against God. As the leader of the party heading for the new world he believed in creating a society based on a moral code that was rooted in the bible. Winthrop and the other Puritans hoped to establish in the new world a pure church that would offer a model for the churches in England, thus purifying the Anglican Church from within. "They sought homogeneity, not diversity, and believed that the good of the community outweighed protecting the rights of its individual members".
Puritanism as a religion declined, both by diluting its core beliefs and by losing its members. This phenomenon was at work even in colonial days, at the religion’s height, because it contained destructive characteristics. It devolved into something barely recognizable in the course of a few generations. We can observe that the decline of Puritanism occurred because it bore within itself the seeds of its own destruction.
When Puritans were aware of Archbishop William Laud’s dedication was to wipe out Puritanism they immediately secured a royal charter that allowed them to establish the Massachusetts Bay Colony. Thousands of Puritans left England and came to New England. Many intellectuals landed in the Bay Colony, including John Winthrop. He was offered the position of being the colony’s first governor which he proudly accepted saying he had a “calling” from God to do so. A governor was elected annually as well as a representative assembly. Puritans claimed that the sole purpose of the government was to enforce God’s laws. The Enlarged Salem Covenant of 1636 says, “we bind our selves to study the gospel in all truth and peace; both in regard of those that are within or without [church membership] … not laying a stumbling block before any, no, not the Indians, whose good we desire to promote…” (Doc C). They believed in the importance of religion and...