Simon Birch V.S. The Scarlet Ibis
Many people may say that the movie Simon Birch and the book The Scarlet Ibis are practically the same story. Both of the stories have many key point in common. And both stories have a similar lesson of how little actions can cause a big impact on someone's life. Some of the differences do give each story their own flair which in the end causes a different impact on the reader and viewer.
The Scarlet Ibis is a story about two brothers the older brother who is a “ normal” boy and his younger brother Doodle who was born with complication and wasn't expected to live. Doodle wasn't able to walk or do anything physical. His older brother was embarrassed by this and set out to teach him how to be like every other kid his age. While in the movie Simon Birch two young boys Joe had a bestfriend named Simon who was born small. Everything about Simon was tiny and he experienced physical issues because of this. Through
…show more content…
the story Joe Help Simon with the things he couldn't do himself. These two stories share many ideas.
Both of these stories have a disabled main character who are Simon and Doodle. And they both have a “normal” main characters who are doodle's older brother and Joe. Both of the normal characters pull around the disabled characters like when Joe rides Simon along in the bicycle sidecar and while Doodle gets pulled around in a go cart by his older brother these characters share a strong bond as brothers in The Scarlet Ibis or a best friends in Simon Birch. Joes and Doodles older brothers are both influenced emotionally by Simons and Doodles achievements. Doodles older brother is spirited about the fact that Doodle is not like the other boys. He tries his hardest to get him to be able to walk, run, jump, and swing like a normal kid. While Joe experiences the same emotions when most people saw Simon as weird, and different but Joe saw him how he truly is. Both Joe and Doodles older brother can see the potential in Simon and Doodle that parents, doctors, and everyone else
can't. One of the big differences between the two stories is that simon and Joe aren't related Joe had chosen to help Simon because that are such great friends While Doodles brother had helped because he didn't want to be embarrassed by his disabled younger brother. Even though Simon was small and his parents didn't support him he had big dreams and ambitions that he always lived up to. But Doodle on the other had had supportive parents and only did great things when his brother forced him to. Doodle didn't have faith that he could do things he was always saying “I can't”. While Simon always had the faith that “god planned for him to do great thing”, that he's destined to be a hero. In the end these two stories share many similarities in their main character's appearance and personalities. Both stories show how you shouldn't judge a book by it's cover. Joe and Doodles older brother both experienced the impact Simon and Doodle brought to the world even though they were physically disabled they brought hope and faith to others by differing there challenges. These stories have there own twist to them but over all they can be compared as the same story line.
There are few similarities between the book and the movie. Usually most movies are similar to
Another similarity in the book and movie is that the characters have to go against their morals in order to decide what to do in certain situations. An example of this in the book is when Skip realises he would have to trespass and steal in order for him to keep himself and his friends alive. Or in...
I believe that all lives are equal. I don’t think anybody is more important than anybody else in this world. It doesn’t matter if you're rich or poor, we are all still the same.
While the novel Of mice and men and the film What’s eating Gilbert Grape have different plots and settings, the themes of the two stories are very comparable. The stories depict how taking care of people with disabilities is very challenging and the problems they encounter in their day to day activities. Gilbert (What’s eating Gilbert Grape) has the task of taking care of Arnie his brother and George (Of mice and men) takes care of his childhood friend Lennie. Both of this characters Arnie and Lennie have mental disabilities and rely on their caregivers in life. The responsibility of taking care of Arnie and Lennie is frustrating but George and Gilbert still love them. This paper aims to compare and contrast the novel Of Mice
He also exhibits kindness and love toward Doodle during parts of the story. For instance when Doodle’s brother tires of carrying Doodle in a go-cart, he decides to teach Doodle how to walk. Although Doodle fails numerous times, his brother keeps trying and and encourages him after a particularly disheartening fail when he says “Yes you can Doodle. All you gotta do is try. Now come on,” (Hurst 558). In this quote Doodle struggles to walk by himself. However, his determined brother stays with him the entire time and encourages Doodle to make sure he never gives up and can learn how to walk by himself. The evidence shows that Doodle’s brother does care for Doodle and that he is not always mean and cruel. The quote exemplifies Doodle’s brother’s ambivalent attitude toward his brother. The author is trying to show that Doodle’s brother grows fonder of Doodle with each passing day. Doodle’s brother’s growing love for Doodle becomes more evident as the story progresses. After Doodle learns to walk well, he and his brother, “roamed off together, resting often, we never turned back until our destination had been reached” (Hurst 559). This quote shows that Doodle’s brother grows fonder of Doodle and the two become inseparable. They go everywhere together and Doodle’s brother takes care of Doodle when they go on their journey. Hence, Doodle’s brother becomes a kind, loving brother who takes care of Doodle and tries to make Doodle have a happy life.
These two stories, although written by two different authors present similarities in the characteristics of the main character. Sammy and Tommy are presented with adversity they had previously never faced. Sammy has to decide should he stand up for the girls by quitting and be the hero or should he mind his own business and keep his job. Sammy is forced to quickly make a decision which his boss Lengel feels he made to rashly. “’I don’t think you know what you’re saying,’ Lengel said” (Updike, pg. 146). For Sammy his decision is what he feels he needs to do and he never regrets his choice. Tommy is faced with adversity of a different kind, he has to decide should he believe the teacher and listen to what she is saying or should he, like the other children, think she is strange and a liar. When she loses her job Tommy is forced to make a decision, confront the child who got her fired, or stay quiet and let the matter slide as it is not his problem. For both the boys their actions could be beneficial to them or it could cause them future problems. An example, if Sammy...
...remely complex and impregnated by love and hate is the main similarity between the two texts. Sonny, through his music, is successful in changing his brother’s idea of what he is supposed to do with his life. Unfortunately for Donald, Pete is not and might never be ready to accept him as the human being he wants to be. Drugs are the biggest factor in Sonny’s failure to live and to become a good brother and a true artist. On the other hand, for Donald, the fact of him being unwilling to change who he is and the fact that his brother is always there to save him impedes him from being the brother Peter wants him to be. With or without understanding each other, the love that these brothers share for one another keeps them from completely disappearing from each other’s life regardless of their differences and the obstacles that characterize their complex relationship.
Author James Hurst once quoted, “I did not know then that pride is a wonderful, terrible thing, a seed that bears two vines, life and death.” Why does life end out the way it does when pride infects it with its poison? In “The Scarlet Ibis” by James Hurst, pride proves to be more wonderful than terrible for the characters.
Two people with two completely different characteristics have something alike. Both Dally and Johnny are mentally tough because of their parents. Johnny and Dally’s parents both do not care for them and could care less about them. For example, during Dally’s childhood he went to jail, been in a gang, and has been in many fights and his dad still would not care for him even if he won the lottery. Dally also talks about his dad's disgrace towards him in the car with Johnny and Ponyboy, “‘ Shoot, my dad don’t give a hang whether I’m in jail or dead in a car wreck or drunk in a gutter...’”(88). Dally could easily live without his dad and he does for the most part. Dally just hangs around with his friends and stays at their place. Similarly, Johnny's parents use him like a rag doll to blow off steam, “his father always beating him up”(14). The gang knows what happenes in Johnny’s house. Once Ponyboy was witnessing, “Johnny take a whipping with a two-by-four from his old man”(33). Ponyboy talks about how loud and mean Johnny's mom is and,“you can...
In conclusion, Brother shows his self-interest in how he treats his younger brother. He treats his younger brother, Doodle, as something to ‘fix’ and he cannot accept his brother as he is. When Doodle finally learns to walk, Brother’s selfish need for a more ‘ideal’ little brother is not satisfied for long. Soon he demands a little brother who can run, jump, climb, swim, swing on vines, and row a boat. When he gives Doodle lessons for these activities, he does not do so for concern about Doodle wanting to be able to do them, but because he wants Doodle to be able to be a ‘normal’ brother.
...development of your identity. Gregor, the family man, tried as hard as he can to be there for his family. His family is everything he has got and this is his identity. While Sonny, the trouble kid turned musician, abandoned his family’s suggestions and went his own way by keeping true to himself and being dedicative to a specific goal. Both of these characters are polar opposites in a sense that one follows his family and the other does not. But, both characters were forced into difficult situations and both have experienced some sort of sacrifice.
In the story Of Mice and Men there were many handicaps that Steinbeck decided to speak upon. One was the fact that Crooks was a crippled stable man, Lennie who was mentally disabled, and Candy who lost his hand in an accident and is always worried about keeping his job (Attel). All three of these characters were left behind for reasons. All three had handicaps that prevented them from getting along normally in society. All three of these characters had handicaps, b...
In both stories, the main characters are both girls. They both have mothers. They got discouraged at times because there were things that happened to them that brought them down. Cynthia wanted to talk to the boy at the grocery store but never did, and that made her discouraged. Adoja was being brought down by her Nana because her Nana thought she had too thin of legs, so that discouraged her too. But in the
James Hurst is the author of the heart breaking short story entitled “The Scarlet Ibis”. “The Scarlet Ibis” is a short story about two brothers; one brother is healthy, while the other is physically handicapped. The short story is centered on the idea that the older, healthier brother’s selfishness and pride ultimately led to the death of his younger brother, Doodle. Numerous quotes throughout the story demonstrate Hurst’s use of symbolism and foreshadowing to portray and predict Doodle’s untimely and heartbreaking death.
Even though these two books may seem very different, they also share many similarities. Though they are not related through their plots, they definitely share some very important themes and resemblance of characters. Through these similarities, two different stories in completely different time frames and locations can be brought together in many instances.