Prompt 1:
A film and a book can be very similar when they’re based on the same story but there will always be slight differences due to the author’s perceptions. In the film “10 Things I Hate About You” there is a wealthy, fierce, witty teenager named Kat who steers men away at the blink of an eye; she has a strong aggression that scares people away. As the story proceeds her man-free life ends as she begins to be wooed by a guy named Patrick who is bribed to date her so that Kat’s sister, Bianca, is released from her dad’s control and therefore allowed to date. Visually, it is seen that Kat and Patrick get to know each other better over the course of the few dates Patrick worked so hard to get Kat to attend. Kat quickly falls in love and
…show more content…
tries to take their relationship a step further; Kat tries to kiss Patrick after a party but he denies her due to her rough mental state; she was drunk.
The rejection sets Kat overboard and her aggression spews out once again. In an attempt to regain Kat’s love, Patrick embarrasses himself by creating a grand singing scene in front of the whole school. By doing this big performance he lands himself detention in which Kat shows her forgiveness by diverging a distraction to help Patrick escape. Kats way of distraction was very out of character compared to her normal self; she flashed the detention teacher. After the following few days, another bump in the road occurs; At Prom Kat finds out that Patrick was being paid the whole time to go out with her. Once again, Patrick works hard to prove he truly has fallen in love with Kat. By way of apology, Patrick buys Kat her favorite guitar with all the money he has received from the beginning deal. This proof of love is enough for Kat and they date for good this time …show more content…
without problems. Compared to the film, in the book “Taming of the Shrew” by Shakespeare, Katherine the main female young adult is an heir to royalty with extreme rage and violence, as well as great wit. Katherine commonly strikes people, in turn, causing fright throughout all men, this leaves her suitor-less. As the story continues, a young adult from another village, names Petruchio, comes to the village in order to find wealth by way of marriage. Many suitors of Katherine’s sister, Bianca, are overjoyed to hear of Petruchio. Petruchio is the way to release Bianca from her father's rule which states, “I am firmly resolved not to let my youngest daughter marry before I have a husband for my elder daughter” (Shakespeare, 31). As soon as Petruchio hears of the wealthy mistress, a marriage is set up. The marriage is set up between Katherine’s father and Petruchio without Katherine’s knowledge. Soon after, Katherine and Petruchio meet and with every rude statement Katherine spits out, Petruchio follows back with a sweet remark. Katherine doesn’t fall for this wooing in front of the public eye but deep down she feels a slight attraction. Few days after the first meeting, the marriage takes place. Everything went seemingly well until the groom is late and dressed in what Katherine’s Father describes as, “shameful clothes; they are an eyesore to our public festival” (Shakespeare, 113). Not only is Petruchio dressed badly but as the wedding continues he becomes drunk with a wine during the ceremony and doesn’t attend the reception. Katherine had never had to deal with someone treating her like this before and tells Petruchio off by saying, “ I will not go today; no, nor tomorrow, not until I please myself. The door is open” (Shakespeare, 121). By saying this, Katherine is setting her place in the relationship. Petruchio, on the other hand, has different ideas. Katherine is forced to leave the reception in order to go on the honeymoon and once the couple arrives after the treacherous journey, she is not allowed to eat or sleep as one of Petruchio's ways to tame her. Katherine, on the other hand, is blinded of how bad things are for her because Petruchio makes everything seem as if it is done out of love. Eventually, Katherine and Petruchio journey back home for a grand feast but the only way for the journey to reach its destination is if Katherine agrees to everything Petruchio says; she does as he says and they arrive soundly. Later, Katherine’s obedience is put to the test when all the men at the feast make a bet to see whose wife is the best. In the end, Katherine wins the bet and yells at the other woman who didn’t listen to their husbands. Katherine says, “ your husband is your lord your life, your keeper ...” (Shakespeare, 207); she is proving that everything should be done by way of her husband which proves how much she has tamed as a person. Katherine and Petruchio end up working great together in their now loyal marriage. All in all, throughout the two different sources, the main storyline is consistent;there are a few slight changes. Prompt 2: In the story “Taming of the Shrew” by William Shakespeare, a relationship between a father and their child is greatly abused as well as the relationship between husband and wife.
These types of relationships were very common back in the 1590’s. One main piece of evidence that Shakespeare uses to show the overuse of power by father toward their children is when Baptist states, “For I am firmly resolved not to et my youngest daughter marry before I have a husband for the elder daughter, If either of you love Katherine, because I know you well and love you well, you shall have my permission to court her at your pleasure” (Shakespeare, 31). Baptista is putting control in place over his daughters so that they can’t easily marry and move out. The main reasoning Baptista uses these specific words to ward off suitors is because it is very unlikely the eldest daughter will marry and even if she finds someone, her dad must approve first. Similarly, in a husband-wife relationship, the man is also seen to overuse his power. The most prominent husband shown in the story, Petruchio, is very controlling over his wife. Petruchio tells Katherine, his wife, “Pay attention to what I speak, or do, or think to do” (Shakespeare, 165). By telling Katherine this he is basically warning her that she must do and listen to everything he says. As well, the control over a man's wife is shown when Katherine states, “your husband is your lord, your life, your keeper, your head, your ruler, one that cares
for you, and for your maintenance” (Shakespeare, 205). When Katherine states this she is telling the other woman how they should do everything for their husband because that is their role in life. In the 1590’s relationships were very different and power was commonly abused as shown throughout Shakespearean literature. Prompt 3: Relationships can vary greatly from person to person based on each partner of the relationships personality. In the book, “Taming of the Shrew” by William Shakespeare, there are two very different relationships that are exposed. One of the main relationships that take place is between a girl called, “Katherine the cursed” ( Shakespeare, 55) and a man “more crossed than she is” (Shakespeare, 117). Their marriage is very unmannerly; Katherine argues with Petruchio every chance she gets and Petruchio, in turn, starves her and rids her of sleep, all in order to teach her a lesson. The brutalness of this marriage is very different when compared to Lucentio and Bianca’s relationship that consists of nothing but sweet love and flirtation which is acquired through Lucentio’s teaching which he calls “‘The Art to Love’” and Bianca swoons at saying that he “may prove to be master of your art” (Shakespeare, 143). Somehow throughout the two very different relationships, love is reared through the basic techniques of wooing and making all things seem out of infatuation for the women. As well, much of the relationship building was based on being the best male with the greatest prospects out of all other males. Throughout all the hard work and different ways in which each couple thrives, both of the couples perform well together. Many years since the writing of “Taming of the Shrew” has taken place, the aspects to how relationships function are somewhat different. Every relationship is still quite different from one another but some basics have changed. As time and technology advance so do the basics of relationship building. For example, in the film, Shakespeare Retold, the relationship between Katherine and Petruchio are still very unmannerly with the same aggression toward each other as in the book, but instead of just starvation and lack of sleep, the factors of lost luggage and the inability to drive out to town to get anything, are Petruchio's responses to Katherine's unwieldy behavior. As well, in modern society wooing like in Lucentio and Bianca's relationship takes place in a less sophisticated form; people flirt by usage of emojis and texts instead of practicing a flirtatious language like Lucentio did. In addition, even though there is slight competition between males for a females love, men do not try to change and better themselves in order to gain this love. Even further, societal norms are currently changing in which many females pursue men instead of the contrary. All in all, relationships bloom similarly even when they are faced with the effects of different time periods and different personality traits of each partner.
Stark contrasts exist between the description of the characters and emotional content between the book and the movie. This may be mainly due to the limited length of the movie. In the movie, Rat Kiley who is telling the story seems gentler. In the book they make it seem like everything Rat says is exaggerated, but the movie does not stress that fact. “Among the men in Alpha Company, Rat had a reputation for exaggeration and overstatement, a compulsion to rev up the facts, and for most of us it was normal procedure to discount sixty or seventy percent of anything he had to say” (O’Brien 89). Also, the movie emphasizes the fact that Rat Kiley fell in love with Mary Anne Bell. He himself says he loved her towards the end of the movie. A character that people may tend to have sympathy for is Mark Fossie. In the book, one may not feel for Fossie. The movie shows the character having more feeling especially after he couldn’t find Mary Anne. A third character that is portrayed differently in the movie than in the book is Mary Anne, who is the main female character of the chapter. The movie stressed the fact that Mary Anne wanted to learn more about the Vietnamese way of life. There was a scene in the movie where Mary Anne spent time with the Vietnamese soldiers learning their language and how to cook their food. They also show her going ...
The movie also switches stuff up, because in the book the first sense or diary they got chase after they got off the bus from school, which in the movie they got chased walking on their way to school. Hilary Swank play Erin like if she was actually her, like if she knew her life story and what she had been through. In the movie she lost her husband for wanting to let go of the kids, and in the book it never states she has a
For example Norman and Jesse are married way before Norman meets Neal (Jesse’s brother). In the movie Norman meets Neal while is he still courting Jesse. This brings forth another difference Norman doesn’t date Jesse in the book. When Jesse is first introduced, she is already married to Norman. A viewer of the movie who has read the book might also notice that when Norman is never offered a job to teach at Chicago University in the novel. Another big difference between the movie and the novel is the role that Norman’s mother plays, she is a very lively, dynamic character in the book, but in the film she is depicted to a flat character. Paul and Norman have equal fly-fishing skills, but in the movie Norman is just a mere amateur compared to Paul. Rev. Maclean expresses displeasure with Paul's decision to change the spelling of the family name in both version of the story. Someone who might have read the book may believe that the movie didn’t do the book justice when showing Paul’s struggle with his alcohol and gambling addictions. Norman offers to help Paul out with is personal struggles when he is driving Paul and his girlfriend home after a long night of drinking. The offer to help in the novel is done when Paul and Norman go fishing. Some other differences are Rev. Maclean’s personally is almost completely lost in the movie and his most important line “you can love completely without complete understanding” (a
Baptista is looking for suitors to marry his daughters and views the marriage as a monetary transaction: "After my death the one half of my lands, and in possession twenty thousand crowns." (2.1 122-123). In this quote, Shakespeare is using the characterization of Baptista to demonstrate how women were viewed as nothing more than objects that could be sold. Baptista told this to Petruchio when he asked how much Kate was worth. In addition, Baptista was attempting to appeal to suitors: "Proceed in practise with my younger daughter; she 's apt to learn and thankful for good turns. Signior Petruchio, will you go with us, or shall I send my daughter Kate to you?" (2.1 165-168). Shakespeare uses Baptista to demonstrate how poorly women were viewed. Baptista is practically selling his daughters and attempting to make them more appealing to suitors, so much as offering to bring Kate to Petruchio. Throughout most of the play, Baptista is looking to marry off his daughters. "Faith, gentlemen, now I play a merchant 's part, and venture madly on a desperate mart." (2.1 345-346). Shakespeare uses Baptista to demonstrate once again the little value women have and how they are viewed as objects. Baptista is acting as a "merchant" when he is selling his
The difference in the film and the novel alter the depiction of the love affair between Tristan and Iseult and Patrice and Natalie. While the novel portrays Tristan and Iseult as causing the suffering they endure because of their love, the film makes Patrice and Natalie the victims of faith and love.
In the novel Othello, written by William Shakespeare, there are a variety of ways in which women are portrayed. There are strong willed women such as Emilia, who stands up to the men, especially to her husband. If he is wrong she would openly admit that he is incorrect. There are also women who are thought to be a possession as well as extremely submissive to their husbands such as Desdemona. She is the type of woman that will obey her husband to the day she dies. Desdemona believes that her husband is always right and he will never do anything that will lead her into the wrong direction. Many of the women in this time thought the same way. They are viewed as house workers, cooks, and teachers to the children. In addition to those qualities women obtain, having no authority in marriages is also added to the list. In this novel, there is judgment against women because they are “unequal” to men. They are not allowed to do the same as men for the reason that they do not possess the same qualities as men. Men were considered to be superior to women. Women were treated as their “slaves.” In contrast, today’s time women now have power. They have the right to vote, run for office, and even work outside their homes. Women now play the part as the male and female figure in the households. They are considered independent women, not relying on a male figure. Even if they are married now, they do not listen to everything that their husbands tell them to do. It states in the Bible that a male figure is the head of the households; however women today have strayed away from that view that they had back then. They want to be the dominate figure. Times have really changed from the past to the present. W...
The one who truly loved her, is the one who sacrifices everything. One of them left her loved one; one of them got thrown in the jail; one of them lost her husband and moved out of that community, and one of them died. All this, is because of Patrick’s decision.
McCourt claims the movie “the perfect realization of my book on film”, but there are many key differences. In the movie there are many noticeable differences from the book portrayed along the lines of Angela’s character. An example
Katrina Stratford and Patrick Verona are two of the main characters in the movie. They are both individual and are seen as social outcasts. An example that leads to shows their individuality is when in a science class, Patrick lights a cigarette over a Bunsen burner and later drills a hole in Cameron’s book when he tried to approach Patrick. This shows how Patrick has an I-don’t-care attitude but is also seen by others as “cool” and “scary”. But this is only by reputation, after he meets Kat; he is able to his true self because he knows he isn’t going to be judged
Difference one is Charlie asked Miss kinnian to his apartment. Ms. Kennan came to Charlie's house and he did not want to talk and she paid his rent for 2 months. In the movie Charlie asked Miss kinnian to his apartment when she dropped him off after the surgery. To show when Charlie started to like Miss Kinnian .The second difference is There relationship In the book he likes Miss. Kinnian and we do not know if she likes him He liked her and she liked him and they started to date. This affects the people who new that charlie was getting smart and was smart. Difference 2: There relationship In the book he likes Miss. Kinnian and we do not know if she likes him He liked her and she liked him and they started to date. This affects the people who new that charlie was getting smart and was
Hatred. A feeling that can destroy what we have and take what we love. We all are victims of Hatred’s sinister claws and razor sharp teeth, pulling us into its depths of decay. With all of the bias and effects that Hatred brings to us, sometimes we cannot help but give back what we have gotten. King’s novel, “Carrie,” and xxxDejixxx’s poem, “Treat others the way you want to be treated,” indicate that you reap what you sow.
She is wearing light colored clothing, her hair is down, and she is also kissing Patrick in the middle of the campus. This shows a huge change in Kat’s character. The light clothing shows the difference in the “darkness” of her personality before and her personality at the end of the movie. This scene shows that she is now more laid back, and less uptight than before. Having her hair down shows a permanent change in her personality, as it is continuous through two different scenes. Finally, kissing Patrick in the middle of campus is crucial. She is now in the middle of campus, acting as a “normal” student at the high school, not as an outcast as she had been at the beginning of the
During both periods, the men were the leaders and the females were their inferiors. Prospero and Miranda, the father and daughter in William Shakespeare’s play The Tempest, are an example of a relationship between a father and daughter in Elizabethan England, however they were slightly different from the norm of their period. Prospero had to do everything for Miranda since she had no known mother and they were on a deserted island, she was unable to go to a household of a relative, which was a commonplace during this time. Prospero is in complete control of Miranda. He raises her in his image and as nearly all fathers of his day demand respect.
These examples were the un-wed daughters, Katherine and Bianca, of Baptista Minola, a wealthy man living in Padua wishing to marry them to eligible bachelors. Interestingly, by using two sisters close enough in age to both be married, he shows these two different sides of femininity while introducing other aspects such as jealousy and competition to his construction. To display the double edge sword that is femininity in the “Taming of The Shrew” the use of Katherine and Bianca is interesting because between sisters there is oftentimes competition and jealousy that stems from childhood. This element of competition makes the differences between the two young women even more apparent. The contrast between the two sisters is made clear as soon as they are introduced in the first act when Gremio says “To cart her rather! She’s too rough for me. There, there, Hortensio, will you any wife” ( 1.1.55) This quote comes after Baptista offers up his eldest daughter, Katherine, for marriage. Katherine is strong willed, she has a very sharp tongue and has no problem with letting anyone know what she thinks. This is a problem for a lot of men which can be seen in Gremio’s
King Lear follows the story of King Lear and his three daughters, Cordelia, Goneril and Regan. King Lear decides to resign from the throne and distribute his kingdom amongst his daughters but their amount is decided based on how they answer his question; “Tell me, my daughters (since now we will divest us both of rule, interest of territory, cares of state), which of you shall we say doth love us most, that we our largest bounty may extend.” When construed from a feministic evaluation, it is apparent that Shakespeare’s King Lear encompasses misogynistic implications. Goneril and Regan both answer him with flattery and excessive devotion but Cordelia answers with