President Roosevelt's Good Neighbor Policy

1021 Words3 Pages

People of Influence
In general, President Roosevelt preferred to make his own decisions regarding domestic and foreign policy, wanting “to be his own secretary of state,” but being only one person, he was forced to rely on others in his administration (Morgan 575). One of those was Secretary of State Cordell Hull, who, according to the Secretary himself, stated that “during his first term in office President Roosevelt was so immersed in an avalanche of domestic questions that he left me in almost full charge of foreign affairs” (Rosenau 231). With Roosevelt’s attention being dedicated to his New Deal policy in America, Hull was left with the responsibility of fulfilling the president’s promise of a good neighbor policy, though Roosevelt had …show more content…

With the help of the reference librarians at the Geisler Library I found a variety of professional texts specifically on Franklin Roosevelt ranging from biographies to public papers and speeches by him and important persons in his administration. The first hand accounts concerning the Good Neighbor Policy were most valuable, serving as a tool to compare the primary ideals of the policy to the implementation and results of the policy. Once I gathered enough information on each key player’s perspective, I researched specific examples of the policy in action and analyzed their significance. At first, I focused solely on Roosevelt’s speeches and actions, formulating an understanding of his intentions before researching Secretary of State, Cordell Hull, and Sumner Welles, who played various roles in the Good Neighbor Policy. I was then able to compare the different perspectives using primary sources from each of the three individuals and develop a more accurate description of the policy and how it worked and under whose order it operated as well as the relative successfulness of it. After all information on the Good Neighbor Policy and its contributors had been pieced together, I went back and researched what was occurring during the time period in which the policy was created, looking for an understanding of why it arose in 1933 as opposed to earlier. The purpose of leaving the historical …show more content…

The first was The Public Papers and Addresses of Franklin D. Roosevelt which provided me with a large number of Roosevelt’s speeches and addresses around the time of the Good Neighbor Policy. One disadvantage of this source was the lack of context for each speech. The only perspective offered in this book was the president’s, which aided in understanding his relationship with his advisors and what he believed he was accomplishing through his policies. It also revealed how little he was personally involved in the early year of his first term due to his focus on New Deal policy, but later volumes revealed his genuine care and interest in fulfilling his promise for friendly relations and nonintervention. The other two sources were Julius Pratt’s The American Secretaries of State and Their Diplomacy: Cordell Hull and Sumner Welles’s The Time for Decision. The latter offered a first hand account of Welles’s experiences and account of the Good Neighbor Policy and how he perceived it in the years since its adoption whereas the former provided detailed accounts of Hull’s involvement in the Good Neighbor Policy. Reading each of their perspectives along with Franklin Roosevelt’s I formed a picture about the policy that is not necessarily presented in the generic textbook, where the Good Neighbor Policy was not just a promise not to intervene, but it was a series of actions. All of the

Open Document