Premeditated Murder In Edgar Allen Poe's 'The Tell-Tale Heart'

406 Words1 Page

In Edgar Allen Poe’s, “The Tell-Tale Heart,” we are left with the question, is the suspect guilty of premeditated murder, or is he just criminally insane? The suspect’s actions, have caused an innocent man to die, just because he had a blind eye. The suspect, claimed he was afraid of the old man’s pale blue, blind eye, with a thick hazy film over it. He also stated he wasn’t killing the man for his gold, but instead for his well being of not seeing the eye again. The opposition, claims, the suspect didn’t know how to deal with his fear of the eye, so he murdered him. Another reason to believe the suspect is guilty of premeditated murder is because, the suspect had a plan to kill the old man, which is the legal definition of premeditated murder. On the eighth night of creeping on the old man, the suspect claims; he made a noise, causing the man to sit up, so he suffocated him with a mattress, put him in a bathtub, dismembered him, then hid him under some floor boards. …show more content…

On the night of the murder, a neighbor called the police because they heard someone scream. Upon the arrival of the police, the suspect said he had had a nightmare, so he screamed, and when they asked to look around they claim he was a little too open to showing them around. Due to his actions of placing a chair above the dead body, and the police officers “mocking” him, he was overwhelmed with guilt, and confessed. Once again, his defendants say he didn’t know how to cope the guilt, therefore he was obliged to tell

Open Document