Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Ralph and Jack comparison
Ralph and Jack comparison
Ralph and leadership essay
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Ralph and Jack comparison
Ralph and Jack may seem like the most important members of society, as that’s how the others feel. Ralph is leader of the group, and Jack is the hunter, so the others praise them. But the real most important member is Piggy. Even though no one pays attention to him, he is important in so many ways. He is not chosen as leader, but he would have been the smartest choice for it. Piggy keeps everything in order, like keeping the littlluns safe. And keeps everyone from fighting each other. He usually settles the arguments between Jack and Ralph. Piggy is also very smart and has creative and useful ideas. He is wise, and patient. And these are important character traits a leader should have. He is also useful, as his specs came in handy and helped
built the fires. No one seems to think of him as important, but he is. Ralph was chosen as leader because of the conch, but he would have never found it if it wasn’t for Piggy. And the conch keeps everything in order, and keeps everything fair. Ralph and Jack seem to depend on Piggy, and feel like he is helpful because without him, they would not know how to keep the littlluns calm. He is not chosen as leader because he is not ‘popular’ or ‘attractive’. But these things are not important at all.
Every chapter, these three boys, have demonstrated they have great behaviour on the island in comparison to the rest of the group. But it was tiring to constantly have an acceptable attitude because the other boys would not be so pleasant towards them. First, Ralph represented democracy, from the time he crash landed upon the sand, strategies on how to be rescued flowed in his head. He was introduced to the conch and from that point he assigned daily tasks and rules that would be completed so the island would not go insane such as creating shelter, where to dispose waste and if the conch was in your hands, you were able to speak. Next, Piggy represented scientific facts.
Piggy is known for being the most intellectual and reasonable out of the boys. While the other boys are off fooling around and dreaming about their next adventure, Piggy is using reason to plan an organized method of survival on the island where everyone is satisfied. For example, while the other boys were exploring the island, Simon came up with an idea and said, “‘I’ve been thinking,” he said, “about a clock. We could make a sundial. We could put a stick in the sand, and then—’” (Golding 90). Although the boys can rule using any form of government on the island, Piggy attempts to create a civilized and orderly environment by advising Ralph to implement a democratic state. Despite his weak appearance, Piggy has a very strong moral compass and sense of self assurance, meaning, he’s very confident in the moral choices he makes. Since he bases his actions and way of thinking on reason and justice, he has a tendency to believe everyone should follow and share his methods because “rules are rules.” As seen when electing a leader, Piggy believed that because the conch and name system were his ideas, he should have been voted as leader, resulting in “Every hand outside the choir except Piggy’s was raised immediately. Then Piggy, too, raised his hand grudgingly into the air.” (Golding 29). Due to his strong confidence, Piggy is not afraid to act upon his beliefs and what is right, even if it may not be a popular
...red the most mature, and the most adult-like. His mature perspective on things, his rational approach on surviving, and how he acts like a conscientious father, proves how Piggy is the adult figure on the island. Without Piggy on the island, the boys probably would have turned to savagery much sooner, resulting in more deaths. In Lord of the Flies, his character plays a major
Piggy's literal function in this novel is to be the intellectual and logical thinker to counteract the emotional thinking of the other boys. From the beginning, Piggy viewed everything logically. He quickly came to the realization that the boys may be on the island for a long time, when he told Ralph "Nobody don't know we're here. Your dad don't know, nobody don't know" (9), contrary to Ralph's assumption that his father, who happened to be a naval officer, would simply come and rescue them. While Ralph became the natural leader based on his charisma, "what intelligence had been shown was traceable to Piggy" (18/19). However, it is unfortunate that this intelligence eventually led Piggy to his demise. Piggy's direct way of analyzing a situation and voicing his opinion tended to make him quite un...
It is hard to find a perfect match for Piggy. He is full of sensible, bright ideas, but because he is fat, a nerd and wears glasses, no one will listen to him except for Ralph. He was also kind of irritating. For example, he followed the rules too much. If something wasn’t done the way he knew was right, he would get all irate. Then, of course, when it went wrong, Piggy had no hesitation in telling people that he could’ve done it better.
Ralph was the most sensible to me and I related to him on so many levels one of his is main objective was to keep order in the group. Ralph quickly becomes the group's leader being described as tall for his age and handsome, he looks over the other boys with a sense of maturity. Although Ralph isn’t as smart as Piggy, he is calm and rational and has moral judgment. Ralph remains the most civilized character even after the deaths of Simon and Piggy. Ralph represents enlightened instinct.
( Golding, 87) When everyone else was afraid, he just thought that " if there's something wrong, there's someone to put it right". ( Golding 87) This shows that Piggy was levelheaded and he knew that the only thing to fear on the island were themselves. This is like he knew that the cause of breakdown in the society would be from themselves. While piggy and Ralph were able to keep order almost successfully, others would leave because they were in to not having rules and just having fun without actual work and effort being put in to help them along. Ralph says, "Piggy, are you the only one left? No there's Samn'Eric." This is later in the book and it shows how people are able to ignore the rules. Only the moral and honest people stayed with Ralph and Piggy To try and be saved. The rest were bloodthirsty savages and left with Jack to hunt and Kill. Piggy also really respected Ralph. When Ralph was upset with the "accident" that happened with Simon, Piggy knew that even though Ralph was doing wrong things, he would work things out. Piggy helps to show how unnecessary it is to dwell on these matters saying "What good're you doing talking like that". (Golding, 156) Piggy knew no one would listen to himself, so he
Out of all the boys Piggy is the most reasonable. From the start he already shows a higher sense of maturity than most of the other boys. Piggy says that “we might stay here till we die” the reader can tell that Piggy doesn’t have as much of a false sense of reality like the other boys. I say as much because just before this Piggy asks Ralph “when [his] dad will arrive. This shows that even though Piggy shows some level of maturity he is still young and that shows in his speech.
Piggy is mentally resilient; he has the ability to think things through with the clear mind even during times of crisis. He is the true voice of reason. “‘I got the conch! Just you listen! The first thing we ought to have made was the shelters down there by the beach…But the first time Ralph says ‘fire’ you goes howling and screaming up this mountain. Like a pack of kids!’” (Golding 45). Piggy has the capability to let his voice of reason run unbridled because he tends to think before he leaps. Because of this, he is able to vocalize his morals proudly and never stray from his own beliefs.
After Ralph carelessly reveal the nickname “Piggy” to the others it triggered all the boys, "even the tiniest," to laugh which sets up Piggy to be the brunt of jokes and bullying. As the story develops, Piggy demonstrates time after time that he is able to contribute to the group mentally. For an example, Piggy suggested that they should construct the signal fire on the beach instead of the top of the mountain after Jack formed his own tribe. Piggy’s wisdom and intelligence begins to become obvious to Ralph but to the rest of the group, Piggy is still thought as weak and useless; it seems that the only time anyone speaks to piggy it involves an insult of some sort.
Piggy’s leadership in the novel is portrayed as knowledgeable but lacks confidence from time to time. Piggy is shown to be a potential leader because of his wisdom. He portrays knowledge from time to time, for example, “We can use this to call the others. Have a meeting. They’ll come when they hear us-” (12). This exhibits his knowledge of the art of survival. Even though in the novel, Piggy is shown as the weak link, his wisdom out powers his flaws. Although Piggy has lots of wisdom which makes him a potential leader, he lacks confidence. “Piggy opened his mouth to speak, caught Jack’s eye and shut it again.” (42) This proves that Piggy lacks confidence because he is afraid to express his thoughts. He would rather not contribute to a conversation than be laughed at his ideas. However Piggy does see the importance of having priorities. Specifically, when he says, “How can you expect to be rescued if you don’t put first things first and act proper.” (45) The quote proves that Piggy prioritizes the needs of his pee...
At the beginning, clearly Ralph feels that Jack is an ally, a companion; not a rival for leadership, "Ralph found himself alone on a limb with Jack and they grinned at each other ... that strange invisible light of friendship". The chosen leader of the group, Ralph tried to lead the stranded boys into some kind of order. The authority of Jack and the sensibility of Piggy easily sway him. When Ralph first meets Piggy, he sees him as a lower person who should be ridiculed. He starts off by asking for his name and he is told that people used to make fun of
Ralph first takes on the position as leader at the beginning of the story, when the rest of the boys vote him in as chief. He carries this position until Jack and his fellow hunters break away from the group. Ralph makes it his job to set out the rules to organize a society. Ralph always thinks of what is best for everyone and how they will all benefit from his decisions. Rules and standards are set when Ralph is the chief. He orders the group to build the basic necessities of civilization, shelters, and most importantly to keep the fire going, in hope that they will be rescued and return to humanity. "But I tell you that smoke is more important than the pig, however often you kill one" (Golding 75). Jack, on the other hand, takes on the idea of every man for himself. He does not care about making homes, only about hunting. When Jack is the leader, evil takes over and all good is destroyed. Under Jack's power both Simon and Piggy are killed.
He is shown to idolize the conch, but also the way it can transform him into someone of importance and make people listen. Being such an awkward introvert that he is, it is easily seen that he would want the conch to have importance in order to keep a structure between communication of the boys on the island. Piggy feels more powerful while having the conch and this is seen in the book, “Piggy lost his temper ‘I got the conch! Just you listen! The first thing we ought to have made…’ He took off his glasses and made as if to put down the conch; but the sudden motion toward it of most of the older boys changed his mind” (Golding 45). This quote represents the beginning of Piggy’s understanding of how much power he could obtain from the boys. Near the end of the book, before his death, Piggy is almost ready to confront his fear of Jack and his power using the conch. “‘I’m going to him with the conch in my hands. I’m going to hold it out’... Her pushed the conch quickly into Ralph’s hands as though in a hurry to be rid of it.”
Piggy’s courage at the beginning of the book was horrible, and he didn’t know how to stand up for himself. At the end of the book Piggy had more confidence and could stand up to the other boys, and didn’t let the other boys walk all over him. There are a ton of examples on how Piggy stands up for himself, and shows how confident that he is. Ralph had great courage at the beginning of the book, and at the end he started being mean and the other boys stopped talking to him. Ralph took on the responsibility of being the adult, and being a leader so he had to show courage. Ralph started losing courage because all of his tribe joined Jack left him behind. Jack could offer the tribal meat to eat, so the wanted to join him. Ralph also got food for them but it was just berries, and fruit. Ralph was confident that when Jack left he would come back, and try to make things right again. That’s when the boys started to leave one by one to join Jack’s tribe. In conclusion to this story it just shows that you never know when you will need certain things to survive. Piggy and Ralph are alike and different in so many ways. By seeing how different the two characters are make me realize how different people can really be. In the Lord of the Flies it shows dedication, courage, and strength. It also shows how they can work together and get things taken care of even when times are tough. Ralph and Piggy display a variety of similarities and