patial learning style, should have a cognitive predisposition for learning American Sign Language as a second language.
In the way our brains are formed highly depends on how and when we are taught to read. In a recent study, adults who had typical experiences in learning to read and adults who had handicapped experiences in learning to read were observed in their responses to specific stimuli. The researchers state how our brains are formed based upon what we are exposed to in the world which surrounds us, however when we learn to read this is contested. For those whom are not taught to read or do not pick up general ideas of reading before an early enough age, the brain begins to format differently. Therefore speaking, occipitotemporal gyrus,
…show more content…
or the link between the occipital lobe and the temporal lobe, of dyslexic and deaf students reacts differently to certain stimuli than typical reading students(Pegado et al., 2014). This in an important fact to recognize when accounting for which language classes students should take in their educational careers. If anything, it would suggest that dyslexic students need to be introduced to a visual language, like American Sign Language, for success in a foreign language. This difference in the students with dyslexia brain affects them in multiple ways. In addition to having a tangible reasoning for having a visual learning style, students with dyslexia also often have issues with syntax and pragmatics. Both syntax and pragmatics usually become problematic, however it does not equate to having a problem with prosody. Thus speaking, issues arise with the way sentences are structured and organizational strategies for students with a reading disorder(Marshall, Harcourt‐Brown, Ramus & van der Lely, 2009) As a structured language, sign language in general is lacking many features which may add as bonus to students with reading disabilities. As previously mentioned, there is no written or read systems in play. As a learning process, especially for students with dyslexia, this is a definitive advantage in regards to stress levels, and the expectation to read in a language they are not familiar with, especially when they lack the capabilities to read fluently in their native language. This ability is impacted by the fact that the students are experiencing no issues with prosodies of language, yet instead the specifics of the written system(p. 470). The dyslexic student has many issues within the reading system of the English language. The main parts of written and read language include, yet are not limited to: phonological awareness, phonemic awareness, word and letter recognition, memory, fine motor skills, audio discrimination and syntax structure. An interesting thing to note, as many of these components are not important aspects of American Sign Language. As a language without sound, American Sign Language uses a bevy of other methods for communication. This is furthermore proof that American Sign Language would be an ideal for our dyslexic students to learn. In addition, the syntax of American Sign Language is entirely different than the syntax of the English spoken language. American Sign Language uses a system of classifiers along with a combination of nouns, verbs and adjectives to communicate language. In American Sign Language, the speaker eliminates many words by using a specified motion to replace words. To express going down in an elevator, the user would show the sign for elevator, and then follow with a downward motion. For a student with dyslexia, these movements replace many words which, for students with a language impairment in comorbidity with their reading disability, this may come as a relief. Also, for sign language to minimize the amount of words, such as the example with sign language syntax, this may introduce a simpler method of communication for our students. The fact that American Sign language uses less words in all, furthermore suggests a predisposition for students with reading disabilities to have a successful attempt at language learning. Phonemic awareness also affects the dyslexic reader. Phonemic awareness includes understanding phonemes and syllables in words, comprehending rhyme schemes. The lack of phonemic awareness is a major indicator of the dyslexic student. In addition, phonemic awareness poses equally as an issue within the deaf community. In general, native non-hearing signers do not perform well on a phonemic awareness assessment. This is despite if they are proficient readers or not(Koo, Crain, LaSasso & Eden, 2008). This is another indicator that sign language had linguistic elements which appeal specifically to the brains of the dyslexic reader. Due to the fact that native signers, despite their reading skills have the same issues of dyslexic readers, it would suggest that students who have a similar predisposition to understanding phonemic awareness would benefit in the acquisition of a language where phonemic awareness is not stressed or needed for comprehension. In correlation to phonemic awareness, phonological awareness also is problematic within dyslexic students. Phonological awareness is the ability to identify and utilize the sounds of language. in both words and non words, and the ability to delete segments in words. Also, phonological awareness is a precursor for students to not recognize the relationships between letter sounds and words, which later translates to reading skills. Students with issues with phonemic awareness issues could have difficulties with these tasks if presented in a setting where reading skills are a necessity(Bruck, 1992). Similarly to phonemic awareness, when native, deaf signers are assessed on their phonological awareness skills they perform much lower than their English speaker peers. Again, this is another identifier that American Sign Language is a language that would benefit the specific learning styles of the dyslexic student. Many dyslexic students also have problems with audio discrimination. Audio discriminate is the ability to differentiate sounds. Within American Sign Language, as there are no sounds associated with the language, this is another aspect in which American Sign Language is the ideal language to introduce to a dyslexic student. Students do not need any audio discriminatory skills to learn American Sign Language. Word and letter recognition are also a large part in reading.
This is another positive factor in introducing sign language to the dyslexic reader. In sign language, there are no words or letters for the student to recognize. Instead, the learners of sign language have to physically create the signs. This ends up creating a more powerful device for the students to memorize. Instead of relying on visuals to memorize words and letters, the learners of sign language create the signs. Sign language also does not need fine motor skills, which are often found affected in the dyslexic reader. Without the usage of these fine motor skills, or somewhat abstract letters and words, the dyslexic learner of American Sign Language is fully entrenched into the world of sign language by creating the signs with the learners own body and no other foreign tools such as pencils and paper. Also, American Sign Language, although not entirely, features many idiosyncrasies. This is not the basis of American Sign Language, however with the signs that do correlate to English spoken word, this also makes it more relatable for dyslexic students. (Wrap up this …show more content…
sentence) Schools and institutes for the study of learning disabilities are also employing the ideology of teaching American Sign Language to students with dyslexia. One institute in particular is the Yale Center for Dyslexia and Creativity. The Yale Center for Dyslexia and Creativity is, defined by the center’s website: “[A] nexus for research on dyslexia, and is as well a leading source of advocacy and information to better the lives of people with dyslexia” (Dyslexia.yale.edu). In addition, the center is a subsidiary of the Yale School of Medicine and focuses on what benefits students with a reading disability. The center’s website features a testimonial from a dyslexic student who successfully substituted American Sign Language for his foreign language requirement in high school. This particular student tried learning Spanish, yet experience similar difficulties in learning to speak and read English. The student, who’s referred as CJ, mentions that “ASL is definitely worth taking…It is more hands-on and visual and that makes it easier to learn, much easier than I anticipated.” The article also mentions that CJ is currently receiving an A in his sign language class and keeping up with the pace of his sign language class. This serves as proof that the language of American Sign furthermore, is a perfect language to introduce to dyslexic students as a whole. There is much more to be implored on the topic of dyslexic students and learning American Sign Language.
One component which was not fully expressed in this paper would
be the social emotional aspect of learning American Sign Language. For further reading, the
social emotional aspect of learning a language such as American Sign Language for the
dyslexic reading should be explored. Due to the fact that American Sign Language is a
language cerebrally tailored for the dyslexic student, it could be an interesting topic to see the
positive psychologic affect upon students learning in which there is tangible evidence in
which they should succeed. Looking at CJ in the article from Yale’s Center for Dyslexia and
Creativity, readers can take CJ for an example of the positive benefits students have by
taking American Sign Language as a foreign language.
In all, it is important for students of all abilities to learn a foreign language. Not only
does it give students an insight to languages and cultures that are not their own, yet it also
provides students a new vocabulary and it challenges the way their brains work. Dyslexic
students have challenges learning most things language related, including foreign language.
However, we should not disqualify them from an amazing experience such as learning
a foreign language. Thankfully, American Sign Language is a language which specifically caters to the specific learning style of the dyslexic student. American Sign Language is a visual language, which with dyslexic students this is a huge benefit. In addition, American Sign Language lacks many linguistic components which traditionally affect dyslexic students in both reading and spoken word. The overall positive effects of dyslexic students taking American Sign Language as a foreign language and successfully succeeding is evidence that dyslexic students should take American Sign Language as a foreign language. If school systems overall effect the confidence of dyslexic students, by giving them an option where they will definitely succeed is definitive evidence that dyslexic students should take American Sign Language over any other foreign language available in schools.
Eide explain that there are four distinctions regarding a dyslexic brain. The first is the phonological deficit. Much of the challenge here is directed to the amount of processing power that is devoted to understanding language. The dyslexic brain commits an enormous amount of effort and energy to this activity which tends to overload the working memory and cause problems with executive function and lead to attention deficits as the brain tries to decipher language. Drs. Eide don’t believe this is the limit to the dyslexic’s challenges or potential advantages. Yet this uniqueness leads us to an understanding of how the brain approaches problems and their related
Robert Buck once said, “If children can’t learn the way we teach, then we have to teach the way they learn.” The Wilson Language Program has become disclosed to amplify this mentality. Dyslexia is a common disease among ten to fifteen percent of the United States, where a human being has trouble in learning to read or interpret words, letters, and other symbols. Programs are reaching out to try to terminate as much distress of dyslexia as possible. Up and coming programs, The Wilson Language Program for example, are making their best efforts to start working with children from a young age with the slight signs of this common problem. Catching dyslexia earlier in life brings more assurance that the child’s future will have little to no setbacks or disadvantages for success. In order to enhance the regressive literacy of dyslexic individuals, the Wilson Language Program is progressively being implemented into regular schooling to ensure that reading standards are met, through structure, hours of research, copious practice, and strong evidence.
This is a subject and disorder near and dear to my heart. My personal experience with dyslexia, with myself and my daughter, has given me great insight into what dyslexia is, what the signs are, and how soon you can detect the potential for problems. It is not always the case that dyslexia is the sole source of reading and reading comprehension difficulties, there are other disorders that can exist at the same time, and this is important to know in order to help students improve their reading abilities. But, dyslexia will not only affect reading abilities and reading comprehension. It can affect writing, spelling, math, memory, listing comprehension, self-esteem, social skills, the ability to understand sarcasm, understanding spatial concepts,
Acquiring a Language: American Sign Language vs. English In the Unites States and Canada, an estimated range of 500,00 to 2 million people speak/use American Sign Language. According to the Census Bureau, ASL is the leading minority language after Spanish, Italian German and French. ASL is the focal point of Deaf Culture and nothing is dearer to the Deaf people’s hearts because it is a store of cultural knowledge and also a symbol of social identity, and social interactions. It is a fully complete, autonomous and natural language with complex grammar not derived and independent of English.
Too frequently dyslexia, dyscalculia, and dysgraphia are clumped together and thought to be the same problem. In reality, the three issues are similar but also constitute many of their own distinct complications. Dyslexia is manifested not only in seeing letters backwards and upside down but is the inability to decipher sounds and letters or shapes. “Dyslexia reflects a deficiency in the processing of the distinctive linguistic units, called phonemes, that make up all spoken and written words.” (Shaywitz pg98) This makes it difficult for the child to sound out words phonetically to read fluently; they might also struggle with remembering
5)Nature.com, Article discussing the two most prevalent theories of dyslexia; the magnocellular and phonological theories.
American Sign Language is considered a foreign language by 40 states around the United States. American Sign Language is not considered a foreign language, because a foreign language is defined by “any language used in a country other than one’s own; a language that is studied mostly for cultural insight”. By definition American Sign Language does not fit that description because, it is only used in America. American Sign Language is also not qualified as a foreign language because people say that a language must have literature for proper study when American Sign Language does not, also people have argued that American Sign Language lacks the same element of culture as other foreign language courses. But in other cases American Sign Language can be considered a foreign language in many ways just as it cannot be considered a foreign language. Some of the reasons that American Sign Language can be considered a foreign language are, American Sign Language is no less a foreign language than Navajo, which is also indigenous to the United States. One huge step towards the thought of American Sign Language being considered a foreign language is that the whole idea of language being foreign is disappearing. I believe that American Sign Language is a foreign language and should be accepted in more states and more schools around the country.
It “is an important part of the social, cultural, and educational context of the hearing-impaired child’s development” (Stahlman, 349). If a person cannot communicate effectly then they may not thrive and develop while having a hearing or speech impairment. In both American Sign Language and Pidgin Signed English, a person who is hearing-impaired must learn to communicate with the world using only his hands and facial expressions. American Sign Language and Pidgin Signed English is a way for the unable to communicate. Both ASL and PSE can be taught in many different ways however, ASL is normally taught in school while PSE is normally self-taught but either way they are both a unique method of communication and can be used all over the world and can be translated and spoken just like any other language can
... made in regard to differences and similarities between LD and language acquisition. When teachers and professionals form a base of knowledge about the second language acquisition process and they develop understanding of the characteristics associated with learning disabilities, it increases the likelihood that effective interventions are employed for ELL students with or without LD.
Dyslexia is one of the most common neurobehavioral disorders that haunt adolescents throughout their childhood. Commonly known as a reading disability (RD), dyslexia is a hereditary complex trait that occurs in five to seventeen percent of people. Neuroimaging studies show that dyslexic individuals display abnormal brain function compared to fluent readers when challenged with reading assignments (7). The exact genes that code for dyslexia are not certain, however substantial studies have potentially linked dyslexia to the KIAA0319 gene, the DCDC2 gene, and the DYX1 gene. The severity of each case is largely determined by environmental factors such exposure to reading and professional intervention. Significantly, the interplay between these external influences and innate genetic characteristics ultimately determine the performance of the dyslexic individual.
Goldish, Meish. Everything You Need to Know About Dyslexia. New York: The Rosen Publishing Group, Inc., 1998.
Multiple cases show dyslexics having exceptional talent in drawing, painting, and music. The appropriate way to describe dyslexia is not calling it a disability but as a learning difference. Despite the fact that the obstacles flourish, treatment, educational techniques, positives can provide wellbeing and overpowers the weaknesses.
Witton, C., Talcott, J., Hansen, P., Richardson, A., Griffiths, T., Rees, A., Stein, J. and Green, G. (1998) Sensitivity to dynamic auditory and visual stimuli predicts nonword reading ability in both dyslexic and normal readers, Current Biology, 8, pp.791-797
Everyday children all over suffer with dyslexia, and this is slowly but surely becoming an epidemic in the world. One solution to this is the teaching and learning of cursive writing. The style and complexity of cursive writing helps students get over their dyslexia because of the simple fact that in the cursive alphabet you are not able to find letters
Students should learn a foreign language in middle school because it gives them a different opinion for different cultures and gives them a different