In John Steinbeck’s novella, Of Mice and Men, George’s decision to kill Lennie was not justified. George and Lennie are best friends even though Lennie has a mental illness. At the start of the book, Lennie holds on to a lady’s dress not thinking much of it, but the lady thought he was trying to rape her. George and Lennie had to leave town and get new jobs so they show up for work at a ranch. Towards the end of the book, Lennie grabs a lady’s hair whose husband works on the farm. She screams and cries and Lennie, who doesn’t know how strong he is, holds his hands over her mouth and accidentally breaks her neck killing her. He runs away to some brush that George told him to go to if he did something bad and the farmworkers went after him. …show more content…
They wanted to lynch him and shoot him with a shotgun in the gut but George finds him first and shoots him in the back of the head. George ultimately did the wrong thing. He made the decision to end another human being's life on his own even though Lennie never intentionally harmed anyone. Some people may say Lennie wouldn’t be able to live on his own but that is wrong because there were more options for George than to just shoot Lennie. George’s actions at the end of the book to kill Lennie were not acceptable.
One reason why George was wrong was because Lennie didn’t harm anyone on purpose. He had a mental illness and didn’t know how strong he was. At the end of the book, he killed Curley's wife by shaking her not knowing she would die. As said on pages 117-118 “Candy said, “He’s such a nice fella. I didn’ think he’d do nothing like this.” George still stared at Curley’s wife. “Lennie never done it in meanness,” he said. “All the time he done bad things, but he never done one of ‘em mean.”” Lennie is a nice person and didn’t try to kill her because he was mean, he did it accidentally. His close friends and the people that surrounded him knew that he had a good heart and good intentions. He was just incapable of understanding his limits and the dangers he posed to other people. Another reason why George shouldn’t have killed Lennie is because it was Lennie's life and George should not have made this decision for him. Lennie trusted George and went to the brush where he thought he would be safe with him. George found him because that is where he told Lennie to go. Before George killed him, he made Lennie believe they were going to live a nice life together and he would get to tend the rabbits. He led him on and made him think that everything would be okay. Then, he shot him. Lennie could’ve lived to his fullest potential if he had the opportunity to, but George took that away from him. …show more content…
George had many options but chose the wrong one. George killing Lennie can relate to Mr.
Wise from “Ohio Man’s Shooting of Ailing Wife Raises Questions About Mercy Killings” killing his sick wife. One day, Mr. Wise came home to see his wife choking and vomiting in the bathroom and was suffering from a triple aneurysm. Mr. Wise shot his wife in the head while she was in the hospital to end her suffering but this was not justified. Mr. Wise made the decision himself to kill his wife and that is not acceptable. As said on the first page of the article “He put a gun to her left temple and pulled the trigger.” He took the life away from another human being whether she was suffering or not. Another reason why Mr. Wise’s decision was unjust is because he made his wife suffer even more. He shot her on the side of her head but she did it die until the next morning. Page 3 of the article states “Mr. Wise tried frantically to unjam his gun, especially after he learned that his wife was still alive. (She died the next day.)” He tried to end his wife’s suffering but made it even worse. The “Ohio Man” should not have killed his wife just like how George should not have killed
Lennie. One common counterclaim may be if George didn’t kill him, he wouldn’t be able to live on his own. This statement is true because Lennie is mentally disabled but there were more options than to just kill Lennie. They could have ran away again like they did in Weed. People may say that it would just be a never ending cycle of Lennie doing bad things. This is wrong because people change and if George could get Lennie the help he needs, they could live the rest of their life together without worrying about Lennie doing something bad. In conclusion, George did the wrong thing. He took the life away of another human being on his own terms and had more options than to just kill Lennie but he didn’t use them.
Would you be able to kill your lifelong companion? George Milton had to make that choice in John Steinbeck’s novella, Of Mice and Men. After a whole bunch of misadventures with his mentally handicapped giant, Lennie Small. Lennie accidently murdered a woman out of innocence. While the ranch men search for Lennie, George made the decision to give Lennie a merciful death. I believe that George should have killed Lennie because he would have been put in an institution, Curley would have been cruel to him, and George had to give him a merciful death.
George shoots Lennie because he sees what the other people on the ranch would do to Lennie. After asking Curley if he could not shoot Lennie, Curley tells George that, "'I’m gonna shoot the guts outa that big bastard myself, even if I only got one hand. I’m gonna get ‘im'" (50). This shows that the others on the ranch weren't going to consider that Lennie was disabled, and Curley would try to make his death very painful. This gives George a motivation to kill Lennie: so he could make his death as painless as possible. This makes the reader have sympathy towards George. Additionally, the result of George killed Lennie, who would be the closest person to George to die at his hands, leaves George devastated that he had to do something like that to his best friend. Even though it is the best option and if I were in that scenario, the thing I would do, it understandably still makes his feel heart-broken. Ultimately, the whole book has made me feel sympathy towards George, but the ending makes me feel so much
Killing someone is never right. No one pointed a single finger to George for killing Lennie. They all thought it was ok since Lennie killed Curley’s wife, it is not ok to kill a person. All of them went out to drink after Lennie was dead. George did not even care, Lennie trusted George with everything. Lennie would probably be arrested for killing Curley’s wife, but he did not deserve to be killed. Lennie was a special person, he did not know his own strength. He never meant to kill Curley’s wife. George knew that but decided to kill Lennie anyways. That is not the definition of a true friend. No one accused George of anything, but instead were happy that Lennie ended up being
“I killed my best friend,” was the exact thought that hovered in George as he watched his best friend, Lennie, recumbent, cold, and still, on the grass by the riverbanks. In the book of Mice and Men, George faced the dilemma of knowing that he had killed the one he loved the most. Though it was no accident, it was for the good of Lennie. If Lennie had been allowed to live, he would only face the worst of what life has to offer. So instead of having to watch his best friend in pain, George took the initiative to end all of the cruelty of the world and send Lennie to a better place. Therefore, George was justified in killing Lennie.
George felt though an extremely difficult choice, killing Lennie himself was the right decision. Curley was gonna get his revenge and George did not want that because he did not want Lennie to die painfully. “‘I’ll kill the big son-of-a-bitch myself. I’ll shoot him in the guts.’”(Steinbeck 96). When Lennie killed Curley’s wife, Curley wanted to give him the most painful death. Curley wanted to shoot Lennie in the stomach which wouldn’t kill you at first, Instead you would bleed out slowly and painfully. George didn’t want Lennie to suffer so he knew he had to get to Lennie before Curley did and kill Lennie the fastest and least painful death he could which he did. Lennie would be arrested and thrown in jail for
This shows throughout the book with the many different mistakes Lennie makes. Lennie starts off by killing mice, then he kills a puppy and finally a woman! After Lennie kills Curley’s wife George responds by saying “I should of knew… I guess maybe way back of my head I did.”(Steinbeck 94). George knew it was gonna come to this and he probably also had a feeling Lennie was going to continue to kill more people or animals. Plus, when the character in the book; Candy asks who did it, George says “Ain’t you got anr idea?”(Steinbeck 94). That shows that George knew he was gonna have to do something about Lennie. George was going to have to do something about Lennie sometime, and after George killed a woman he knew there would be no other choice that to kill Lennie through non voluntary
Lennie was shot by a friend who cared about him. There was no hatred between them making the death non-revengeful. It was just as if Lennie was hooked up to a machine that kept him alive and George pulled the plug. He was bound to be shot anyways so it was better that George "pulled the plug" instead of Curley. Curley would have shot Lennie in the guts to have Lennie suffer a more painful and slow death. It shows that George really cared for Lennie.
For several years you have been taking care of your grandma, who has been suffering in the hospital. You pray that she gets better. But day after day, you see the hurt in her eyes even though she tries to fight through it. You know that she won’t get better until you put her out of her misery and end her life. But once you know she is gone you will miss her deeply but it will be better for her and all her pain will go away. In the novel, Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, one of the important characters, George, faces a similar struggling situation with his best friend Lennie. Lennie murders the wife of another important character, Curley. George has to make an important decision that will affect the rest of both
George kills Lennie because he did not want to witness Lennie being hurt or killed carelessly, run off by in his own and not being able to take care for himself, and Lennie’s mental disorder will never change how Lennie reacts to certain situations. Many believe taking the life of another without consent is unacceptable but in certain situations like George’s, he has to decide due to Lennie’s mental disorder that was leading him into unpleasant situations. George is an admirable character who choose to protect and do justice to his distressed friend,
In fact, near the ending of the story, he unintentionally snapped Curley’s wife’s neck trying to quiet her (91). Failing to recognize his own strength, Lennie accidentally took her life, proving that he was perilous. By shooting Lennie, George prevented Lennie from accidentally injuring or killing anyone ever again. His verdict was correct in view of the fact that he sacrificed his friend’s life with the intention to protect the lives of others. Furthermore, George’s decision protected Lennie. As a punishment for his deeds, The workers wanted Lennie executed. George realized this and told candy, “Curley’s gon’ta wanta get ‘i'm lynched. Curley’ll get ‘im killed,” (94). In consequence of killing Curley’s wife, Lennie unknowingly put himself in harm's way. Curley’s motive for wanting to kill Lennie was spite and revenge. So, instead of allowing Lennie to be murdered alone and afraid, George took matters into his own hands and made sure his friend died knowing he was cared for and full of hope. Through it's ironic, George’s choice protected Lennie from the malice of others, thus keeping him unafraid and unharmed. However, others may believe
George shouldn’t go to jail for killing Lennie, even though Lennie was completely innocent. Lennie is illiterate and ill-informed. He killed Curley's wife and many animals and to keep people safe from him would be hard. He might of had to just stay in one place all day alone, that isn't good for a human. Lennie's death could save many lives.
In conclusion, George killing Lennie was a murder because of lack of consent and Lennie was not suffering physically. In this society, people are scared of the unknown, and that is how they lived. No one realized what they were doing was wrong. But Lennie was just like everyone else, only different because of a small, mental setback. The characters did not seem to realize that Lennie believed in a future ahead of him, and that he had hopes and dreams just like them. Life is incredibly short, and no one should deserve
Should George have shot his friend Lennie? George probably did the right thing by shooting Lennie. How can we condemn George for sparing his friend Lennie the pain and fear of being killed by someone else? He did something society sees as wrong, but he did it for a good reason. Lennie didn’t deserve to die, but there was no other alternative. Curley wanted to kill Lennie, and since George cared for Lennie, he figured the best thing would be for him to put Lennie out of his misery.
After Lennie gets into the debacle with Curley’s wife, he runs to the oasis described at the beginning of the book. George fears the men will tear Lennie apart and murder him. He also knew he would be institutionalized, or “caged” if he survived the attack. He had the moral clarity that let him see that killing Lennie was the best thing for him. When George kills Lennie, it’s a kind of mercy killing.
George did not want to kill Lennie, but at the same time, he did not want him to have to suffer the horrible consequences; he knew that Lennie’s death would be beneficial to Lennie in the future. Furthermore, George knew what was best for Lennie and decided to kill him for his own good.