Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
The relevance of biological theory in understanding crime or criminal behaviour
The relevance of biological theory in understanding crime or criminal behaviour
The relevance of biological theory in understanding crime or criminal behaviour
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Criminology has undergone various changes over the years in terms of ideas, concepts and theories. Before the ideas of early and modern criminology, crime was explained by Moralism, or the idea that criminal behavior was caused by evil spirits, sin or the devil(1). Thankfully, these ideas soon fell out of favor in the age of enlightenment and gave way to classical theories of criminal behavior. While early criminology was based off of classical, biological and psychological theories, modern criminology is not much different as many of these theories simply evolved. Modern criminology is still composed of psychological and biological theories, and classical theories simply evolved into neoclassical theories. These theories, both modern …show more content…
and antiquated influence how the criminal justice functions, but also help to develop new laws and crime prevention by the use of logic and scientific observation. Early criminology was composed of classical, biological and psychological theories. Classical criminology brought forth many new ideas concerning crime and punishment including the concept of using punishment as a deterrent and the idea of “swift punishment”. In the words of “The Father of Criminology” and early classical theorist, Cesare Beccaria, “The more promptly and the more closely a punishment follows commission of a crime, the more just and useful it will be” (2). Fundamental to Classical criminology was the concept that human beings are fundamentally rational and that most human behavior results from free will coupled with rational choice. Early biological theories were the first theories to use positivism to explain crime causation. Early biological theories attempted to correlate physical features and heredity to crime causation, but did so rather unsuccessfully as these theories have shown no real scientific link between physical features and criminality. Early psychological theories were characterized by two major ideas: personality and behaviorism. Personality theory built on the idea of cognitive science, including personality disturbances, the process of moral development and diseases of the mind. Behaviorism examined social learning with an emphasis on behavioral conditioning (3). Early psychological theories developed the concepts of the psychopath and sociopath. While many of theories introduced by Classical, biological and psychological criminology lost favor, others developed into modern concepts and neoclassical ideas. Modern criminology is heavily influences by Neoclassical theories.
Concepts of Neoclassical criminology include the just deserts model, routine activities theory, capable guardians, situational crime prevention, target hardening, determinate sentencing, and both specific and general deterrence. While punishment is a central feature of both classical and neoclassical thought, neoclassical thinking is expanded to support the ancient concept of retribution (4). According to modern neoclassical thinkers, if a person commits a crime then he or she deserves to be punished. Modern biological theories try to explain crime causation through genetics and heritability just as early biological theories attempted to do. Contemporary biological theories stress the interaction between biological influences and the surrounding social and physical environments. Modern biological theories also include brain dysfunction theories, body chemistry theories, hormonal theories and biosocial criminology. Contemporary psychological theories have evolved to include the modeling theory, behavior theory and cognitive theory, as well as the concepts of psychoanalytic criminology. Modern psychological theories have greatly influenced how the criminal justice system treats people suffering from psychological problems. Today, criminals can be acquitted from their crimes by reason of insanity, as was seen in the case of Andrea Yates in the murder of her five children in 2001
(5). Despite some early Criminology theories originating from the early 1700's, many continue to influence today's criminal justice system and are used as the basis for contemporary theories. As classical theories evolved into neoclassical theories, so to did biological and psychological theories evolve into their contemporary counterparts. It shall be interesting to see how future theories evolve or deconstruct today's theories on criminal behavior and whether or not antiquated theories such as those of the Classical school of thought will still be respected and used to form our laws and the heart of our criminal justice system.
1. There are a couple of differences and similarities between the classical and biological theories of criminology. The biological theories of crime support the idea that an individual commits a crime due to their biological make-up and had criminal tendencies because of certain abnormalities that an individual may have had and not because the offender in their right mind chose to commit the crime. The classical theory has the belief that every individual has their own right in the way in which they act upon, so they commit a crime because they choose to do so, not because it is in their biological make-up.
Criminology is the scientific study of the causes and prevention of crimes. Criminology also uses a vast amount of theories to explain peoples’ actions, mental state, and their drive for committing crimes. Some crimes have monetary benefits, while other crime are committed in revenge or in spite of another, which would be called crimes of passion. Because it can be sometime difficult to understand why certain crime are committed, the only thing we can do is use theories to better decipher thoughts, morals, and reasons behind committing crimes.
Akers, R, & Sellers, C. (2009). Criminological theories: introduction, evaluation, and application. New York: Oxford University Press, USA.
Criminological theories interpret the competing paradigms of Human Nature, Social Order, Definition of Crime, Extent and Distribution of Crime, Causes of Crime, and Policy, differently. Even though these theories have added to societies understanding of criminal behaviour, all have been unable to explain why punishment or treatment of offenders is unable to prevent deviancy, and thus are ineffective methods of control. The new penology is a contemporary response that favours the management of criminals by predicting future harm on society. However, all criminological theories are linked as they are a product of the historical time and place, and because of their contextual history, they will continue to reappear depending on the current state of the world, and may even be reinvented.
...ifferent crime patterns and thought processes of criminals. The reasons can only come from these theories and will help the justice systems become more prepared to react towards different crimes. However, with adding some enhancements, projects and experiments these two theories have the potential to change the criminology realm forever.
Lilly, J. Robert, Francis T. Cullen, and Richard A. Ball. 2011. Criminological Theory: Context and Consequences. 5th ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
The classical theory of criminology of the Enlightenment period ushered in several improvements to a barbaric system of justice which had been utilized throughout the Middle Ages (Bohm & Vogel, 2011). The classical theory encompassed the ideology of deterrence through the use of punishment, moreover, an importance is placed upon crime prevention through the use of punishment. This theory also held that all crimes would be treated alike, moreover, all offenders would be treated alike. The mitigating as well as extenuating circumstances surrounding the actions of the individual were ignored. This means all offenders would receive the same punishment without regard for their culpability.
The man credited with the birth of the classical school was Cesaer Beccaria (1738-1794), who emerged during the enlightenment period of the eighteenth century. Some argue that criminology as an independent discipline only emerged about 60 – 70 years ago (Garland 2002), and whilst not concerned with studying criminals per se in the same way that we most associate with criminology today, the classical school was hugely influential in the formation of Criminal Justice System as we know it today. Farner (cited in Taylor et al 1973) a nineteenth century commentator on Beccaria asserts :
The field of criminology has produced multiple theories, each that shaped the perception of how crimes occur in a neighborhood and by viewing these various impressions this can help explain why crimes occur. However, four criminological theories have developed the different perspectives of researchers and outlooks of the field. These approaches have enhanced society by allowing it to analyze crime by establishing an empirical foundation that way to assess which approach is most useful and regulate the difference between a good theory and a bad theory. Every method experiences level of criticisms from either researchers or public policies, however, the focus is only based on four principles that way there can be an assessment to decide which approach is viewed as right or wrong. In order, to determine which approach can be considered a good theory versus a bad theory there needs to be essential elements that give support for each theory. There needs to be criticism, however, with enough empirical evidence that can determine which
Criminology is the study of crime and criminals; a branch of sociology. More accurately, it is the study of crime as a social trend, and its overall origins, its many manifestations and its impact upon society as a whole. That makes it more a form of sociology than a law enforcement tool. But the trends it studies have a huge impact on the way the police do their jobs, the way society treats its criminals, and the way a given community goes about maintaining law and order. The writer will describe and give examples of the three perspectives of viewing crimes. The perspectives that will be highlighted are the consensus view, the conflict view or the interactionist view. Each perspective maintain its own interpretation of what constitutes criminal activities and what causes people to engage in criminal behaviors (Siegel, p.12).
The three eras that have characterized the field of criminology over the past 100 years are the “Golden Age of Research,” the “Golden Age of Theory,” and an unnamed era that was “’characterized by extensive theory testing of the dominant theories, using largely empirical methods’” (28). The “Golden Age of Research” era spanned from 1900 to 1930 according to John H. Laub. This era is identified as focusing heavily on the collection of data surrounding crime and the criminal. This data was assessed without “any particular ideational framework” (28). The second era, the “Golden Age of Theory,” spanned from 1930 to 1960, also according to Laub. This era is also rather self-explanatory, it is described by the development of theories; however, Laub
There are many different aspects of criminal justice policy. One in particular is the different theories of crime and how they affect the criminal justice system. The Classical School of criminology is a theory about evolving from a capital punishment type of view to more humane ways of punishing people. Positivist criminology is maintaining the control of human behavior and criminal behavior. They did this through three different categories of Biological studies, which are five methodologies of crime that were mainly focused on biological theories, Psychological theories, which contains four separate theories, and the Sociological theories, which also includes four different methods of explaining why crime exists. The last theory is about Critical criminology. Their goal was to transform society in a way that would liberate and empower subordinate groups of individuals.
Classical Criminology is credited with initiating the shift away from rather barbaric forms of torture. In classical criminology, the naturalistic approach of social thinkers had challenged the way of the spiritualistic approach. During this time, the spiritualistic approach was the base for all policies in Europe. This means that every crime had as spiritual meaning for which it was committed. St. Thomas Aquinas, a contributor to the topic, argued that people had a natural tendency to be good rather than evil. He also argued that because they committed a crime it did not just hurt other, it would hurt them.
Criminology is the study of why individuals engage or commit crimes and the reasons as to why they behave in certain ways in different situations (Hagan, 2010). Through understanding the reasons or why an individual commits a crime, one can come up with ways to prevent and control crime or rehabilitate criminals. There exist a large number of criminology theories, some link crime to an individual or person; they believe a person weighs the cons and pros and makes a conscious decision on whether to commit or not commit a felony. Others see the society as having a duty to make sure that its members do not engage in criminal acts by providing a secure and safe living place. Some claim that some people have hidden or dormant characteristics that determine their reaction or behavior when confronted or put in particular negative conditions (Akers & Sellers, 2012). By understanding and studying these theories, together with applying them to people, psychologists and authorities can prevent criminals from committing or repeating crimes and aid in their rehabilitation. As many theories have emerged over time, they continue to be surveyed and explored, both individually and in combination in order for criminologists to develop solutions and eventually reduce the levels and types of crime. The most popular criminology theories emphasize on the individual, positivist and classical traits. This paper will explore the classical theory, which is among the earliest theories in criminology.
The study of criminology involves three different phases. Criminals and crime have been around for as long as societies have existed; the systematic stu...