Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Comparing Lenin and Stalin
Comparing Lenin and Stalin
Comparing Lenin and Stalin
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Comparing Lenin and Stalin
happened during a time of severe political unrest. After the revolutions and the previously under delivering governments, the people of both nations latched on to a radical leader who showed passion and strength. In addition, both time periods included mass executions of anyone who was considered an enemy of the state. One difference between Napoleon and Lenin were the political systems they implemented. Napoleon was a fascist, he had a huge emphasis on the military and total control over what the public saw. Also, Napoleon used fear to justify his wars and get the people on his side. However, Lenin was a communist, he wanted to overthrow the bourgeoisie and give the labor class more power. Communists believe in an almost utopian society …show more content…
Lenin came from a middle class family, his father worked in public education and both Lenin’s parents were adamant in promoting the welfare of the country. In 1887 Lenin witnessed his older brother hanged for plotting against Tsar Alexander III; after his brother’s death, Lenin immersed himself in the writings of Karl Marx and Russian critics(Kreis). Napoleon was born on the island of Corsica, the island was actually against French rule and was defeated in an attempt to gain it’s independence. Although Napoleon’s family was not rich, his father submitted to French rule and became an aristocrat on the island. The island was impoverished so they did not attain much wealth, however, Napoleon’s father was able to secure his son a scholarship a private academy called Brienne. At Brienne, Napoleon began his military career at the age of fifteen; living in the world of French aristocrats, Napoleon became a radical revolutionary(Youth and Family Life). One could argue that these upbringings are similar, but Lenin would resent Napoleon for the fact that he Napoleon learned and grew up in aristocracy. Lenin was a vehement opponent of the bourgeoisie and would never cavort with the wealthy and noble. Napoleon and Lenin were groomed for radical change from an early age, however, the way this change was instilled in them was quite
Napoleon is in a completely different story from both Locke and Rousseau. Napoleon started out truly believing in a Lockean view of a happy society. He even said he wants one 's “..subjects to enjoy a degree of liberty, equality, and prosperity.”(120) Napoleon made promises to the people of France to “rule constitutionally”(121) and that he was going to give them a society with, “public trial, and the introduction of juries..”(120) Napoleon even went as far as instructing his men to, “respect the people whom you liberate, to repress the horrible pillage committed by scoundrels incited by our
for this similarity is that war, especially long and expensive war, causes fatigue and disdain within a nation. Without a strong leader, the people grow desperate and crave a strong leader. Lenin and Napoleon were also similar in the way they desired to be depicted in the eyes of their people. Both leaders wanted to be seen as strong and powerful leaders, who commanded authority and would bring their respective nations back.
Similarities of the two was that they both wanted freedom for their people but its believed that napoleons main goal was to
Being a part of a small noble family, Napoleon found he was able to attend a school in mainland France. He eventually found himself at Brienne, a school where his Corsican background and lack of French nobility caused him great hardship and stress from other students. This would plant the seeds of hatred for nobility inside Napoleon that would eventually lead him to destroying noble privilege based on birth in his empire....
A revolution takes place when a group does not agree with the current government and the policies they have in place. In some cases, revolutions turn violent during the attempt to overthrow the government. This is exactly what took place during the French Revolution, 1789 and the Bolshevik Revolution, 1917. Overall both revolutions found the beginning in the poor. The poor struggled under the rule of the monarchy; there was a strain on resources and high taxes. There were famine and food shortages due to bad weather, and WW1 respectively. In France, the nobility, first and second estates, did not have to pay these high taxes which further angered the poor. Both French and Russian nobility and monarchy were to blame for the suffering experienced. In the French and Bolshevik Revolutions there were philosophical ideas that guided the people to put a stop to their suffering, these ideas fueled extremist groups that brought upon violence and overall the goal of these Revolutions were not permanent. French and Bolshevik Revolutions had revolutionary ideas that went hand in hand with revolutionary violence and ultimately left the countries in chaos for some time after.
According to Machiavelli Napoleon is the better leader. He's the better leader because to Machiavelli you have to use and have the qualities of the fox and the lion. And, Napoleon is menacing, and he is not afraid to use force. Also, Napoleon is like kind of tough. The way the author describes Napoleon it's as if he's not afraid/scared of anything now. Or even then. But he's also very selfish and self centered. Which is a bad thing, because you have to look out and be helpful to other people in order to be a good leader. But Napoleon would still make a better leader according Machiavelli.
...ition" (Commine p. 35) to Stalin's regime. Despite his ability to be ruthless, Trotsky was no match for Stalin when it came to struggle for political power that ensued after Lenin's death. The antagonisms between the two were very little but there were some. For example, both Stalin and Trotsky were "philosophical materialists" (McClellan p. 77) who were once in the same Russian Social Democratic Party as youths. In addition, they both competed for Lenin's place in office. However, the personal differences between the two were the reason for their rivalry. As committed communists, Stalin and Trotsky both believed in the revolution but conflicted in their different strategies for it to take place. Despite their personal differences and antagonisms, but Joseph Stalin and Leon Trotsky became two patrons of world domination, neither to be beyond recollection.
... It is important to understand that since France had just exited a revolution, it was pretty fragile; one big mistake and France might have ended up in another one. Napoleon was not only a child of both the French Revolution and the Enlightenment, he was also a very intelligent person. His cunning and wits led him to be one of the greatest, if not the greatest, enlightened despots of all time. Works Consulted (none of the above).
Isaac Murrin Mr. J. Pharion Freshman English 20 February 2013 The Similarities and Differences between Lenin and Stalin Vladimir Lenin and Joseph Stalin were similar in what they claimed to be, but in actuality they were very different people. Although Stalin claimed that he followed Leninism, the philosophy that Lenin developed from Marxism, he often distorted it to follow what he wanted to do. While Lenin wanted to make a unified society without classes, with production in the hands of the people, while Stalin wanted to make Russia into a modern industrial powerhouse by using the government to control production. Lenin accomplished his goals through violence, because he thought achieving the Communist revolution was worth using violence, with a ‘The ends justify the means’ mentality. Stalin also used violence to accomplish his goals, however Stalin used much more violence than was often necessary to accomplish his goals.
One last mistake that most people could call Napoleon’s greatest, would be his Invasion of Russia. When Czar Alexander I stopped complying with Napoleon’s demands with the Continental System, put heavy taxes on French luxury products, and refusing to let Napoleon marry a sister of his, Napoleon thought that it was time to put Russia back in his place. With this idea in place, Napoleon gathered a huge amount of troops from all around Europe, which first entered Russia on June 24, 1812. A quote from Sutherland states that “It was the most diverse European army since the Crusades”. History experts expect that at least 450,000 Grand Armée soldiers and maybe even 650,000 ended up crossing the Niemen River to fight the Russians on the other side (approx. 200,000). Napoleon
Napoleon has an obvious relationship with the famous Russian dictator, Joseph Stalin. Joseph Stalin was the dictator of the Soviet Union who was known from the mid 1920’s to 1953. Just like Napoleon, he was a cold, heartless dictator who would kill anyone who did not agree with what he had, to say just like Napoleon in the book Animal Farm. Napoleon used lots of violence in order to keep and maintain his leading position in Animal Farm. An example of this can be seen when Napoleon is training the puppies, but he is not doing it not for their own education, but instead so that they could protect him and eliminate anyone who stands in his way.
Both countries were bitter about losing their freedom of speech and lived in fear of the secret police, yet in Hungary this was present on a bigger scale. In Both countries'current leaders were forced to resign and received no support from the USSR. In Hungary this event was repeated as the leader Rakosi was no better and public demonstrations caused a change in government yet again. Similarly, both new leaders proved capable of desiring reforms in the country. The.
Rule of Lenin vs the Tsar The beginning of the 20th century saw a great change in the political structure of the Russia. A country once led under an autocracy leadership. was suddenly changed into a communist state overnight. Dictatorship and communism are at separate ends of the political spectrum. This study so clearly shows both involve the oppression of society and a strict regime in which people are unable to voice their opinions.
The Similarities of Tsarist and Communist Rule in Russia Both forms of government did depend on high degree of central control. However, some Tsars and Stalin exerted more central controls than others. Stalin’s stronger use of central control created differences between the two forms of government. The Tsars used different levels of central control.
Marxism and Leninism According to most historians, “history is told by the victors”, which would explain why most people equate communism with Vladimir Lenin. He was the backbone of Russia’s communist revolution, and the first leader of history’s largest communist government. It is not known, or discussed by most, that Lenin made many reforms to the original ideals possessed by many communists during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. He revised Karl Marx and Friedrich Engles’ theories to fit the so-called ‘backwardness’ of the Russian Empire.