Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Critique the stages of moral development presented by kohlberg
Critique the stages of moral development presented by kohlberg
Critique the stages of moral development presented by kohlberg
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
et al. 1989 as cited by Psychology 216, 2009). From this, the moral reasoning theory was developed based on the thinking of the University of Harvard Profession Lawrence Kohlberg and inspired by renowned philosophers Jean Piaget, John Dewey and James Baldwin Barger, 2000). It suggests that forms of aggression is related to the stage of moral reasoning or ethics amongst athletes who respect reward commitments in sports (see figure 1)
Figure 1: Kohlberg 6 stages of moral reasoning identifying the social orientation groups
Kohlberg believed that you could not skip a stage and not everyone reaches the highest stages even in adulthood. He believed social reasoning was related to social interaction. This is a very intriguing biological theory
…show more content…
(2000): A Summary of Robert Kohlberg’s Stages of Moral Development, University of Notre Dame. Retrieved from http://www.csudh.edu/dearhabermas/kohlberg01bk.htm
Coakley, J (2014); Cox (2007): Aggression and Violence in Sport Coakley Chapter 7, Cox Chapter 13 [Power Point Presentation] Retrieved from Wilson College Psychology ESS 330
Frankl, D (2001): Principles of Sociology and Psychology: Aggression and Violence in Sport, Unit 7, Department of Kinesiology and Physical Education, School of Health and Human Services, California State University, L.A. Retrieved from http://instructional1.calstatela.edu/dfrankl/curr/kin370/pe370u7.htm
Psychology 216 (2009): Introduction and Causes, Chapter 6. [Power point presentation]. Portland Community College. Retrieved from http://www.pcc.edu/staff/pdf/602/PSY216Chapter6PPT(introandcauses).pdf
Question # 2B
Due to wide variations, deviant behavior in sport is defined using 3 theoretical approaches. Using the functionalist theory it is defined as a rejection of the cultural goals or the means of attaining these goals, identifying that the wider the difference of the behavior is from the accepted norm of sports, the more deviant it is and is grounded in rules and punishment for those breaking the rules, considering those breaking the rules as weak and perhaps mentally disturbed (Coakley,
…show more content…
Sports have good developmental effects on young people, but can also lead to deviant behavior if not managed. There are instances where it is good to keep kids off the streets but then on the other hand some athletes do not serve as role models for aspiring athletes. Cox (2007) cites research that athletes do not have higher rates of deviant behavior than non-athletes, but have higher rates of alcohol and binge drinking and felony rates are concerning. Coakley (2014) cites an experiment study by Trulson, 1986 where 34 delinquent males underwent Tae Kwon Do training for 6 months. There were three groups with group 1 undergoing respect, fitness, self-control, Group 2 free sparring and self-defense techniques, and Group 3 jogging no training. The results shows that group 1 had fewer tendencies of delinquency while group 2 had an increased rate and no change was seen in group 3. Another study cited by Coakley (2014) by sociologist Eldon Snyder (1994) suggests that athletes can become separated from the community after bonding with team players. This can lead to
Kohlberg’s Theory of Moral Development is three levels consisting of two stages in each. Kohlberg’s Theory explains how a human’s mind morally develops. Level one is typically common in younger children. The two stages in level one are pre-conventional stages. Stage one is obedience and punishment driven; one will judge an action by the consequences given. Stage two is out of self interest. Level two is mostly common in teenagers. The stages in this level
R, Elvik, and Kim k. "Accident Analysis & Prevention." Body-contact sports: Catharsis or reinforcement?. 6.1 (1974): 85-91. Print
As long as there have been sports, there has been violence in them. Ice hockey, particularly due to its increasing popularity as a professional sport, has brought up several ethical issues regarding the act of fighting in hockey. There are strong arguments for both sides of this present problem in the world of hockey. Numerous male athletes, including children as young as nine years of age, have suffered injuries as an outcome of fighting and it should be considered if it should be part of a sport that very young people grow up with (Brust, Leonard, Pheley & Roberts, 1992).On the other hand, fights create excitement and the sport of hockey might grow in terms of popularity, making the problem of fighting in hockey complex and difficult to resolve (“Towards An Explanation Of Hockey Violence: A Reference Other Approach”). Even though hockey is known to be a very aggressive and fast-paced sport, the unsportsman-like action of fighting in hockey cannot longer be tolerated.
The primary issue that was addressed in the Journal article, “Moral Reasoning of MSW Social Workers and the Influence of Education” written by Laura Kaplan, was that social workers make critical decisions on a daily basis that effect others. They influence their clients’ lives through giving timely and appropriate funding to them and their families, through deciding should a family stay together or should they have a better life with another family, or connecting the client with appropriate resources that can enhance their lives. The article addresses data from an array of students from various universities. The researcher posed these questions; “Would social workers use moral reasoning (what is right and what is wrong) more prevalent if it was taught through an individual class during your MSW graduate studies, or if you obtain any other undergraduate degree, or if the ethic course was integrated in the curriculum?”
.In addition young athletes have become more aggressive. Kids that participate in competitive sports are becoming more and more aggressive and competitive the sports have become themselves. Mitchell reveals "traits like bullying and the need to dominate their oppo...
Review of “Situationism and Virtue Ethics on the Content of Our Character” by Rachana Kamtekatar
Coakley, J. J., & Donnelly, P. (2007). Violence in Sports . Sports in society: issues & controversies (9th ed., pp. 198-199). Boston: McGraw-Hill Higher Education.
The journal article, “What does sport mean to you? Fun and other preferences for adolescents’ sport participation” claims that fun, social aspects, masculinity, and identity are the main reasons youth participate in sports (Skille and Østera˚ s, 360). Oftentimes, athletes forget they are on the same team, and they start to form cliques or groups based around who has the best bench press or 40 meter dash time. As a result, teammates start to compete with each other instead of working towards the same goal. For instance, one coaching journal article claims that “moral reasoning” in youth is determined through “collective norms” or group behaviors that the coach has a hand in influencing (Shields, LaVoi, Bredemeier, Power, 748-749). A proper coaching environment should therefore revolve around a fun, supportive, and collective environment where success is encouraged through the full support of the team. This support can further be developed through proper positive mindfulness and code of conduct guidelines set forth by the coach; for instance, hazing should be discouraged and proper communication and helpfulness among teammates should be
However, one of the worst results of violent video games is increased aggression levels. Professor Mark Griffith did a study, from which he commented "The s...
... He hypothesized that moral difficulties motivated development through a group of flexible kinds of moral reasoning. From his own ideas of moral reasoning he developed a series of stages describing moral development. In 1973, while in Central America, Kohlberg developed a rare and unknown tropical disease. This disease ruined his health and brought about severe depression. On January 18, 1987 Kohlberg was reported missing. His body was later discovered in a swamp area where it is believed that he took his own life. (6)
The researchers wanted to see “the relation of verbal aggressiveness and state anxiety (somatic, cognitive, and self-confidence)” between coaches and athletes in a sex-specific sport such as volleyball (Bekiari et al., 2006, p. 630). Results examining both sexes showed males have higher levels of somatic anxiety due to the verbal aggressiveness of their coaches compared to female volleyball players (Bekiari et al., 2006). These results could be due to the kind of training and competitiveness, but it still shows how the use of language can have different effects on athletes nonetheless. Additional research done by Julie Masterson, Lisa Davies, and Gerald Masterson showed that coaches should “use positive instruction rather than negative feedback” to encourage their athletes (2006, p. 41). This backs the ideas that verbal aggression is harmful and the research “consistently shows verbal aggression may be associated with negative outcomes and learned helplessness,” two aspects that can be seen in sports that are contributed to the language that is used (Bekiari et al., 2006, p.
A. Morality comes from God. Therefore, moral behavior is that behavior that conforms to the will of God. Immoral behavior defies the will of God. The will of God is correctly interpreted by the Church. Rating: 6. I was feeling this one, until the last sentence. There are so many denominations, and the reason is that they disagree with one another. Many religions interpret what the will of God is differently, not to mention incorrectly. I do believe that a big part of morality comes from God.
Kohlberg, L. (1984). The psychology of moral development: the nature and validity of moral stages. San Francisco: Harper & Row.
Purpose The purpose of this study is to determine the relationships among childhood religiosity, childhood sport participation, and sport-learned aggression. However, other variables may affect the study. Some of them will be controlled by design.
With the increase in society taking a stance against violence, sports has become an area where some feel that the violent acts such as the hitting and fighting that occurs should be eliminated. It is very difficult to change the way that a game is played because people have been playing it that way for years. The violence in sports needs to be eliminated because of the extreme cases that continue to haunt many of the leagues and the players themselves.