Moral Beliefs Discussed in Sophocles' Antigone and Western Philosophy by David Papineau

2077 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Religion as a source of morality

Imagine someone in your family just dieda member you are very close to. This relative of yours is hated by your entire family because they thought this person displayed selfish and duplicitous behavior. Instead of sympathizing for their relative’s loss, they express feeling of antipathy, wishing the worst for this person in the afterlife and expecting you to do the same. You want to honor your loved one’s memory by throwing a memorial service, but your family forbids it and threatens to cut all ties with you if you choose to do so. Given this difficult situation, what do you feel is the right thing to do? Sophocles attempts to approach these issues of right and wrong and human morality through the characters in his play Antigone. Since there are many different takes on moral obligations and they alter between different principles of religion, civic duty, family commitment and commitment to loved ones, we learn there is no right or wrong behavior, just what we believe in our own minds to be justifiable or what is favored by society at the time.
So what exactly is morality and why does it pose such a complicated question? In the book Western Philosophy by David Papineau, it discusses the many different approaches to moral beliefs. Illustrious philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle’s take on morality are one’s personal behavior and set of inner values. Morals can also derive from a social standpoint, where the popular belief rules over all others; if most believe it to be true, then it must present itself as being true. But as stated in the book, even these interpretations can be “very narrow view[s]” (134). Morality also stems from a religious standpoint. Religion has perhaps had the biggest impact on people’s lives and the way ...

... middle of paper ...

...erent moral understandings. This often happens when a person holds strong to what they cherish, whether it be family, religion, laws, or loved ones. There is reasoning behind everything we do. Maybe our actions do not appear righteous to others, but in our own minds, we are heroes. Who cares if everyone else fails to see it?

Works Cited
Antigone. Dir. Yorgos Javellas. Prod. Demetrios Paris. By Yorgos Javellas. Perf. Irene Papas and Manos Katrakis. Kino Video, 1961. DVD.
Kruger, Chaddie. "Winning Mount Olympus." Calliope 23.3 (2012): 2. MAS Ultra - School Edition. Web. 8 Dec. 2013.
Papineau, David. Western Philosophy: An Illustrated Guide. London: Oxford UP, 2004. Print.
Walker, Kathryn. "Between individual principles and communal obligation: ethical duty in Sophocles's Antigone." Mosaic [Winnipeg] 41.3 (2008): 199+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 2 Dec. 2013.

Show More
Related

  • Antigone And Creon Analysis

    686 Words  | 2 Pages

    Human emotions and beliefs can be some of the most powerful and forceful factors in the world. They can often time cause humans to overlook their moral and civil duties and instead confront the demands of a private passion. Two people that have contrasting views about passion and responsibility can cause a major conflict which could cause a “classic war” in literature. In the play Antigone, the differences in Antigone and Creon’s passions and responsibilities helps Sophocles illustrate their central flaws. By doing so, the playwright implies that one needs to achieve a balance of passion and responsibility in order to maintain a sense if inner peace and political stability.

    Read More

  • Analyzing Antigone and Creon

    1299 Words  | 3 Pages

    Sophocles play titled Antigone, embellishes the opposing conflicts between Antigone who stands for the values of family, and Creon who stands for the values of state. Sophocles explores the depths of Antigone’s morality and the duty based on consequence throughout the play, as well as the practical consequences of Creon who is passionate and close-minded. Although Antigone’s moral decisions appear to be more logical and favorable than Creon’s, a personal argument would be that both characters’ decisions in society can be equally justified.

    Read More

  • Antigone

    1762 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the struggle between Creon and Antigone, Sophocles' audience would have recognized a genuine conflict of duties and values. From the Greek point of view, both Creon's and Antigone's positions are flawed, because both oversimplify ethical life by recognizing only one kind of good or duty. By oversimplifying, each ignores the fact that a conflict exists at all, or that deliberation is necessary. Moreover, both Creon and Antigone display the dangerous flaw of pride in the way they justify and carry out their decisions. Antigone admits right from the beginning that she wants to carry out the burial because the action is glorious. Antigone has a savage spirit; she has spent most of her life burying her family members.

    Read More

  • Sophocles´ Antigone and Euripides´ The Bacchae

    1058 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Sophocles’ Antigone, the most prominent theme is the concept of divine law versus human law. The play opens with the debate between the sisters Antigone and Ismene concerning which law comes first- the devout obligations of citizens, or civic duty. Antigone requests for Ismene to assist her in burying their brother Polyneices, though the new king Creon, has prohibited burial on pain of death. It can be argued that Creon’s edict, which deprived Polyneices of his funeral rites, is understandable. The young man had been killed perpetrating the most atrocious crime of which a citizen could be guilty, and Creon, as the responsible head of state, naturally supposed that exemplary punishment was the culprit’s right...

    Read More

  • Antigone: The Theme of Family Loyalty

    902 Words  | 2 Pages

    The notion of honor and justice is prevalent throughout all types of literature. In Greek culture, honor is essential for creating a solid foundation within a society and family. Honor will follow you until the day you perish, and beyond. The honor for men in Greece is spiritual in that loved ones show respect to the deceased by giving them a proper burial. Nevertheless, when a man acts upon betrayal of the city, that man looses the privilege to die in such honor. This is evident in the life of Antigone when her two brothers, Polyneices and Eteocles, both die at each other’s hands at war when deciding the ruler of Thebes. Polyneices cannot have a proper burial, because the new king, Antigone’s uncle, Creon created a law that decrees that anyone who tries to give Polyneices a proper burial will have a dire consequence: death. In Sophocles’ Antigone, the quest that Antigone endures to stay true to her pure intentions of honoring Polyneices by giving him a proper burial is in juxtaposition with the fact that her defiance towards Creon is not only to do with Polyneices, but also to show appeasement to the gods.

    Read More

  • Morality In Antigone By Creon Essay

    1113 Words  | 3 Pages

    Envision a sibling of yours imprisoned for a blasphemous reason. There are only two paths left for your sibling, life in prison or demise. Would you labor tirelessly for their freedom in the sacrifice of yours or forsake them for your own liberties? Well, that depends on your morality. Morality has been around for many centuries, but only recently have two theorists, Lawrence Kohlberg and Carol Gilligan, been able to define morality. Kohlberg’s scale has six stages that primarily focuses on justice and fairness, while Gilligan’s scale of three stages is based upon care and social relationships. My moral judgment is an embodiment of both of these scales and more as I consider morality to not be confined to subjective scales, but boundless. Remember the question imposed above? Well, in the play “Antigone” by Sophocles, Ismene is living exactly through that. Even more, she challenges the limits of her morality to question her ability to save Antigone from Creon’s clutches. Ismene displays the most change in a character’s morality according to Kohlberg, Gilligan, and my personal scale, while attempting to extricate Antigone, which results in Creon becoming the tragic hero.

    Read More

  • Odysseus’ Search for Purpose in Homer's Odyssey

    1418 Words  | 3 Pages

    Thalmann, William G., The Odyssey : an epic of return. New York : Twayne Publishers. PA4167 .T45 1992

    Read More

  • Pride In Sophocles Antigone

    803 Words  | 2 Pages

    Having already been through public disgrace, when her own father, Oedipus found out that he was to fulfill a prophecy; he would kill his father and marry his mother, and this caused Antigone to be full of resentment toward her city.  Both of her brothers die in a battle and, Creon, the king of Thebes forbids the burial of one of her brothers, Polynices.  This must have driven Antigone to follow her moral law.  Considering the love she had for her family as well as her God, she felt that you react upon morals not upon the laws of man.  That morale law was to honor her brother and give him the respectful and proper burial that he deserved just as her other brother was given.  The love she had for her family was the only thing she had left to honor.  Ismene, Antigone’s sister was more fearful of the king’s law then the way her heart was leading her.  Her values were slightly distorted.

    Read More

  • Moral and Political Law in Sophocles' Antigone

    921 Words  | 2 Pages

    Moral and Political Law in Sophocles' Antigone In Sophocles' play Antigone, the tragedy is brought by the conflict between the moral laws and manmade political laws. Neither Kreon nor Antigone is clearly "right" or "wrong". In other words they are both "right" and "wrong".

    Read More

  • Military Persuasive Essay

    1088 Words  | 3 Pages

    What is morality? Merriam-Webster dictionary states that morality is/are the beliefs about what right behavior is and what wrong behavior is

    Read More

  • Themes In Antigone By Sophocles

    1400 Words  | 3 Pages

    Family should come first and always stay loyal to them. Starting off with scene I, Creon finds out that someone has buried Polyneices when his law strictly forbids it. “Someone has given it burial that way, and gone…” (199). The readers know Antigone decided to yield to the law of the land and do what is right by her. Antigone tells Ismene, “I will bury him; and if I must die, I say the crime is holy” (192). She will do whatever it takes for her brother to rest in peace, even if that means death because Polyneices deserves as much honor as Eteocles, no matter the law.

    Read More

  • The Immense Character Development in Antigone by Sophocles

    1542 Words  | 4 Pages

    Brad Moore, a famous athlete once said, “Pride would be a lot easier to swallow if it didn’t taste so bad.” In Sophocles’ well known Greek tragedy, Antigone, the main character undergoes immense character development. Antigone transforms from being stubborn and underestimated to courageous and open-minded. In reality, it is Antigone’s insular persistence that leads to her ultimate decline in the play as well as others around her. After the death of her two brothers, Eteocles and Polynices, Creon becomes the new ruler of Thebes. With this, he grants Eteocles an honorable funeral service for his brave fighting. Claiming that Polynices was a traitor, he shows complete refusal to grant Polynices a respectable and worthy service. Clearly disagreeing with Creon’s inexcusable demands, Antigone declares she will bury Polynices herself so that his soul can be at peace. Entirely aware of the consequences and dangers of this action, which include death, she goes forward vowing her love for her family. Antigone shows strength and determination towards her brother. However, her growing sense of pride leads to her downfall as she sacrifices everything for her family. Antigone develops into an admirable character in which she portrays her defiance and courage, pride and open mindedness, and sense of moral righteousness to show vital character growth as the play progresses.

    Read More

  • Authority In Sophocles Antigone

    620 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the play Antigone written by the playwright Sophocles, Sophocles has different views of how the authority of the state over an individual should be. Sophocles attitudes of these views are shown in the Antigone, states have authority over their subjects and the subjects should obey them no matter what, regardless if what the ruler orders is right or wrong and that individuals should follow god’s law over the ruler or state’s law.

    Read More

  • Comparing Positive and Natural Law

    1441 Words  | 3 Pages

    “Do what you believe is right.” This is a phrase common to us all, brought to our attention by parents, reinforced by teachers, and preached by leaders. But how does one define what is right? Is it what we believe in our hearts, or is it what we know is acceptable? This is a predominant dilemma that can be traced throughout society, and is the main focal point of Sophocles’ play Antigone. Written in 441 B.C., Antigone is one of the earliest records of the conflict between Natural law and Positive law. Sophocles deftly exposes these two philosophical standpoints and their respective moral and political aspects by way of the two main characters, Antgone and Kreon. Antigone is a champion of Natural law, while Kreon practices the Positivist approach. Both characters deem their behavior superior towards the other, and both assume religious justification for their actions. Sophocles ultimately proves that with so much support for each philosophical standpoint, a solution to the dilemma is hardly in sight.

    Read More

  • Moral Justice In Antigone

    316 Words  | 1 Pages

    Antigone, is a play written in 441 B.C. Set in the town of Thebes, two opposing sides fight for what they believe is right. The play illustrates a battle between brothers that results in death. The brothers, Polyneices and Eteocles kill each other, with their own bare hands while battling over who will be the next King of Thebes. This leads to the main conflict of the play which centers around the distinction between law and moral justice. In this prominent interpretation of Greek tragedy, the reigning King of Thebes, King Creon makes it known that Polyneices is a traitor and will be not be buried, he will be left in the field for the vultures. Whereas the brother Eteocles will receive a proper burial. Their sister Antigone is not okay with

    Read More

More about Moral Beliefs Discussed in Sophocles' Antigone and Western Philosophy by David Papineau

Open Document