Maggie: A Girl of the Streets: She Never Had a Chance

1256 Words3 Pages

Maggie Never Had a Chance “She imagined a future rose-tinted because of its distance from all she had experienced before,” (53). The distance from the broken furniture and drunken bawls was not far. Maggie’s new wonderful cultural experience was a short glimpse at New York’s museums with time spent at cheap theatres and dance halls. Instead of a fairy tale story, Crane told of reality in Maggie: A Girl of the Streets – the reality that would face a young girl from a dirt poor, chaotic existence. Crane contrives to show how much weight poor pre-existing conditions have in determining the future. For Maggie, “a small ragged girl,” tears, blood, and cursing are more normal than not. Granted, the character of Maggie knew that there did not need to be perpetual fighting and ugliness, but what was her alternative? Even though she “grew to be a most rare and wonderful production of a tenement district, a pretty girl,” Maggie was born into a destructive cyclical existence (20). She grows up in the tenements, probably the same ones her parents grew up in, and experiences a routine of drunken behavior, disrespect, violence, and poverty. Eventually, her father stops coming home drunk, accosted by her drunken mother, where they break furniture and attack each other until they pass out. However, Maggie’s brother replaces him. Both father and son obtain barely working class jobs and acquire no education to speak of, except what they learn by example. Not only did Maggie identify this destructive existence in the life of her family, she also sees it in the lives of her community. Generation after generation of children fall into groups, “Rum Alley” and “Devil’s Row,” taunting passersby and reenacting the violence they see at home. Crane ... ... middle of paper ... ... it is the theatre of the working class, featuring the “popular waltz” and frequented by a “vast crowd” that “had an air throughout of having just quitted labor” (28). This is hardly high society and Crane emphasizes this in his descriptions of the actress who “galloped upon the stage,” the “brazen soprano tones,” and the “half-tipsy” audience members who join in the “rollicking refrain.” Maggie’s world is so limited that even the burlesque, and rowdy time that an unrefined Pete shows her is elevated to a position of grandeur and possibilities. Maggie exists, naïve and uneducated, on her emotions and fantasies. She is unable to cope with reality and from the start has no chance for survival in an unforgiving world especially without any support or ability to distinguish fact from fiction. Crane shows the actuality of poverty and all it entails in Maggie’s story.

Open Document