More handpicked essays just for you.
Argumentative essay on public school vs homeschool
Homeschooling vs public school
Homeschooling vs public school
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Oleksandra P Edwards
Joseph J Selvaggio
English 101
MW 2.00 – 4.30
06/10/15
Education - is a process of identity formation. School education is the way society can convey necessary skills and knowledges from one generation to another. However what happens, when school education conflicts with the true interest of student? It might seem from first sight that homeschooling is the best option, considering the current state of technology and globalization economy, but its arguable if it can truly substitute school.
John Taylor Gatto in his essay “Against school” giving a lot of arguments against the public education system. He states that’s it’s :
“designed to produce mediocre intellects, to hamstring the inner life. To deny students appreciable leadership skills, and to ensure docile and incomplete citizens – all in order to render the populace “manageable”(145).
Gatto believes its main purpose to raise mindless labor force, give them social roles with specific merits, create a “corporate society”
In my opinion its is not accurate. In addition Gatto’s arguments lack actual connection with real life. Gatto argues a lot, but doesn’t give actual solutions for raising
…show more content…
kids,as bright individuals. Homeschooling has a lot of negative sides, abouch which he prefer not to talk. One of them is lack of socialization. Homeschooling shortage socialization. Social is crucial for social development, since school is the place, where we start making connections with people: making friends, work in groups, play sports as a team. In order to become successful in society, children have to know, how to interact with other people around them, build relationships, resolve conflicts. How is it possible to learn how to ride a bicycle without bicycle. Homeschooling might give academic fundamentals, but they are as important as socializing. Children that did not experience this, and were homeschooled most of the time, have behavioral issues in life nad can not adapt to the needs of society. Another topic that Gatto doesn’t give enough attention to is access to academic resources. Gatto primerally concentrates on United States in his essay, whis is very precise, cause he argues the fundamentals of educational system in general. Countries has different technology level. In most of the countries people do not have open access to computers and enternet. School for them is the only place they can learn and develop themselve’s. How homeschooling can be possible in this conditions? Gatto doesn’t answer this question. In the final passage Gatto states: “School trains children to be employees and consumers; teach your own to think critically and independently”(149).
This statements assume that parents should guide there children in the world of learning, urge them read serious books and complicated material. Well, not all parents are the same, not all of them are well educated and brought intellectuals or simply not all of them have time for this. It is highly questionable, if they can give them more, then person with a degree with a lot of knowledge about there subject. This leads us to the fact that not all homeschooling methods are equal. Young kids are like sponges, they absorb a lot of information they are given, cause they don’t know how to cricticcly think, cause of there age. Raising kids is a great responcebility, that not everybody can
handle. Overall homeschooling is a great learning method, but education can not stand only upon it. Schools Homeschooling has a lot of downfalls, like lack of socialization, resources access and parents incompetence. Those are important features children need to survive and thrive through world, that homeschooling can not fully give. But the way homeschooling has some advantages and disadvantages into, so school have a well. It is very narrow to apply it to all kids on earth.
The average human would think that going to school and getting an education are the two key items needed to make it in life. Another common belief is, the higher someone goes with their education, the more successful they ought to be. Some may even question if school really makes anyone smarter or not. In order to analyze it, there needs to be recognition of ethos, which is the writer 's appeal to their own credibility, followed by pathos that appeals to the writer’s mind and emotions, and lastly, logos that is a writer’s appeal to logical reasoning. While using the three appeals, I will be analyzing “Against School” an essay written by John Taylor Gatto that gives a glimpse of what modern day schooling is like, and if it actually help kids
In the article “Against School”, John Taylor Gatto urges Americans to see the school system as it really is: testing facilities for young minds, with teachers who are pounding into student 's brains what society wants. Gatto first explains that he taught for 30 years at the best and worst schools in Manhattan. He claims to have firsthand experience of the boredom that students and teachers struggle with. Gatto believes that schooling is not necessary, and there are many successful people that were self-educated. He then explains the history and importance of mandatory schooling.
To begin, there are several concepts about compulsory education that aggravates John Gatto and he explains his concerns in his essay “Against School.” Gatto’s first concern is everything is about school is boring. “Boredom is the common condition of schoolteachers (Gatto 608).” If the teachers are bored, they will create a dull and boring environment for the students. “Boredom and childishness were the natural state of affairs in the classroom (Gatto 608).” Lack of creativity and freedom is another concern of Gatto. “An educational system deliberately designed to produce mediocre intellects (Gatto 611).” Also, Gatto thinks school is unnecessary. “George Washington, Benjamin
Juveniles are being taught that in order to have a nice car, branded cloths and the house of their dreams, by getting into an expensive mortgage, they have to be an employee of a huge corporation. In addition, they have to undergo to a prestigious school, study hard, have excellent grades in order to become popular and respectable in the world. However, many people would not become those super leaders, but these majority of people have a great role in the capitalism society of the US. As Gatto says, “We buy televisions, and then we buy the things we see on the television. We buy computers, and then we buy the things we see on the computer. We buy $150 sneakers whether we need them or not, and when they fall apart too soon we buy another pair” (38). Such results are in part of a wrong education that teenagers have received trough many decades. In addition, Gatto highlights that modern educational system has been working in a six basic functions methods that makes the system strong and unbreakable: The adjustable function, indulge students to respect authorities. The integrating function, which builds the personality of the students as similar to each other as possible. The diagnostic and directive function, which allows a school to set permanent scholar grades in order to determinate his or her future role in society. The differentiating function, which gives to the student a good education and after his or her role is diagnosed, they prevent any educational progress. The selective function, function that the system has used to prevent academic growth for the non-selected students. The propaedeutic function, which works in the selection of specific groups of intellectual adults to keep perpetuating the system all over again making it a continuous sequence. (Gatto 34). Gatto’s facts revealed the survival of the educational system for decades,
There are many supporting ideas such as success without modern schooling, criticism of American education systems, and basic functions of modern teachings. Furthermore, writer’s subject positions can help to understand his idea to the reader who have the same subject positions such as teacher in the public school, father who have sons and daughters, and an older people who want to change the American public school system, which force schooling not true learning. These examples help to find the reason people change the school system. Gatto uses these controlling ideas to support his idea and to convince the reader by developing his questions about the deficiency school system in the United States of
In his essay “Against School,” John Taylor Gatto illustrates his view point that the American population would be better off by managing their own education. He compares the school system to the concept of boredom; that students as well as teachers are victims of the long ago adopted Prussian educational system: “We suppress our genius only because we haven’t yet figured out how to manage a population of educated men and women. The solution, I think, is simply and glorious. Let them manage themselves.” In other words, Gatto believes that the main reason for the existence of schooling consists in that it trains our children to be obedient citizens who can’t think on their own. His point is that as a society we cut off the intelligence and creativity
Although the reason some families choose to home school is because they want a stronger, more personal education for their child, it has been seen that some children simply drop out of school and say that they are homeschooling, when in reality they are not studying anything since tradition education is not required in the Un...
... people are more advantaged than others and will receive a top notch education, while others will receive a mediocre education that will prepare them less for college and more for a working class job. There most likely is a connection between social class and the educational opportunities presented to students, but it is also possible that other social forces are at play which determines the quality of a student’s education. In Gatto’s essay it was argued that are educational system is designed to perpetuate faults in order to create a manageable society. He supports his argument with various strong statements which makes his logic convincing, but he falls short when backing the credibility of his claims. The strengths of his essay prove to also be its weakness, which results in a piece of literature that only succeeds in arousing emotional reactions from readers.
The education system is set up in a way that allows all citizens an equal opportunity to better themselves; at least this is the way it was intended. There are many flaws in the public education system that do not seem to be given the necessary attention. Although this education is free of cost to the students, they still deserve a good quality learning experience. “In I just Wanna Be Average” by Mike Rose, a man who experienced a lesser quality education growing up tells about his struggles in school. Many students in the public education system are being cheated out of the experience they crave the same way students in the past had been. Student education is being affected by many factors that should not play any role in the quality
Educators attempt to change that system to make it better, but their change was not that great as an example for the world. Also, did that change qualify education systems to compete with other systems or not? Some examples and reasons have made me agree with some of the points from Gatto’s and Edmunson’s and disagree with them. John Taylor Gatto, in his essay “Against School: How Public Education Cripples our Kids, and why,” argues that the contemporary purpose of education in public schools is to produce “harmless electorate,” “a servile labor force,” and “mindless consumers” (28). According to Gatto, he is blaming public schools for claiming that the purpose of education is to shape students to certain expectations and habits without their interests.
In today’s American society, quality education is important for one to succeed. Without proper education, a person will find it extremely difficult to apply for college, a job, or to pursue his or her dream. Typically when Americans think of education, public education is the first to come to mind. Public education has been around for centuries and is provided to most children throughout the United States. Due to this fact, public education has been the go to education source for years. Though, this trend is slowly changing with many parents deciding to home school their children instead. Many factors are the cause for this issue, but the common arguments arise from a certain few. For students, public school provides many opportunities ranging from social connections, school sports, and the exposure to teachers who are experts in their fields. But homeschooling is often superior because it offers additional time for students to participate in various extracurricular activities and community service, allows for more individual attention, personal character development, and it offers less exposure to discrimination that is received in the public school environment.
As the population in public schools increase, the problems in these schools are also on the rise. These changes are leasing to the way parents are schooling their children. Many parents are leaning towards homeschooling as a solution to this problem. This increase in homeschooling can be directly related to an increase in school violence, the offering of a lack luster curriculum, and lack of student teacher interaction.
All children in America have the right to a quality education. Most students receive that education through conventional means, going to a public or private school. There is another option for today's children, home schooling. Home schooling is a controversial issue. While it does have its benefits, some people believe it has too many downfalls to be an effective method of education. In this paper, topics such as academic impact, social impact, and parental opinions of home schooling will be discussed.
I have chosen to write this essay about homeschooling. Homeschooling is one option for schooling children, along with public and private schools. Many people do not believe in homeschooling because they do not trust that parents are teaching their children correctly. They argue that parents can’t teach their children without proper training and that without it. They also worry that students will not learn to socialize or function in society and that homeschooling is just a way to hide children from the real world. A lot of people fear homeschooling because they do not know very much about that form of education. On the other hand many peoples opinion is that homeschooling has many benefits and that it gives
“Is getting a good education important to you?” Most people when asked this question would answer, “Yes.” This is because it teaches us valuable life skills and prepares us to communicate and engage with others in the world. Education has taken on many forms over the years, and one of the more successful components of education has been homeschooling. Once considered a criminal act of defiance, homeschooling is now legally an option in all fifty states for parents to consider, and it has a substantial