Is Sherlock Holmes an Individual or a By Product of the Victorian Age?

2779 Words6 Pages

Is Sherlock Holmes an Individual or a By Product of the Victorian Age?

To the ignorant onlooker Sherlock Holmes is simply a clever detective

amongst a horde of similar duplicates from various tales and myths of

the crime-solving era. Sherlock Holmes is the culmination from a

culture of detectives. Francis Eugene Vidocq, a “Holmes” in the

making, with an utter disregard for the official police, an ability to

disguise himself, and clever plans to catch the criminals accompanied

by an excellent knowledge of the criminal underworld. Lecoq, used

science and his cleverness to solve his crimes. Dupin, a detective who

possessed powers of deduction and reasoning. Conan Doyle used all

these essential ingredients and through an ingenious metamorphosis

produced the ultimate detective; the meticulous observer Sherlock

Holmes.

If we delve deeper into the infinite chasm of Holmes' character we

reveal more about the enigmatic figure that masquerades inside his

majestic exterior.

The entwining, interlocking tentacles of Holmes' deceivingly simple

demeanour knot together to conceal his true being. His character

cannot be confined to the restrictive boundaries we use for one and

another. His character is far more complex and intelligent than his

middle class placement in Victorian society would like to divulge.

Conan Doyle created a character, blessed with gifts of deduction,

intuition and a genius ability to solve crimes. But in forming this

wonderful concoction he thus morphed many other sides to Holmes,

seemingly oblivious to his adoring followers. He formed an untouchable

creature, unable to feel emotion and passion.

"He never spoke of the softer passions, save with a gibe and a sneer"

Emotions would only make Holmes weaker, and Sherlock Holmes did not do

weakness.

A cold calculated scientist, an ostentatious performer, an arrogant

conceited artist, a character arisen to a higher level than us

'inferior beings'

Holmes' the bohemian, Holmes' the scientist, Holmes' the detective,

Holmes' the gentleman, Holmes' the musician. Clever, genius,

conceited, arrogant, patronising, condescending. His character is more

than dual-natured. His multiple sided personality forms a complex

persona to investigate.

To dissect the inner chambers of Holme's thoughts, I will protrude

into the depths of a classic narrative; The Red Headed League which

embodies many of Holmes intricate characteristics.

In this classic narrative Mr Wilson, the stereotypical ignorant victim

is used as a long-suffering pawn in a game of cruel political chess,

he is obliviously trapped in a criminal masterminds scheming plan to

gain his revenge on society. The 'red headed league' is an exuberant

ploy to keep Mr Wilson out of his lodgings for days on end under the

preface that his

"Real vivid flame coloured tint"

had earned him a place in the ambiguous "red headed league". He has

Open Document