Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Comparison between Brutus and Caesar
Comparison between Brutus and Caesar
The role of Brutus in Julius Caesar
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Comparison between Brutus and Caesar
Protecting Reputation with Persuasion
In The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, characters use persuasion to either benefit themselves or others depending on their motivation. Gaius Cassius, Marc Antony, and Marcus Brutus all persuade themselves or other of different things, but they all achieve the same result. Overwhelmingly, more characters use persuasion to affect others in order to fulfill their needs and wants, whether they intend to or not.
In Julius Caesar, Marcus Brutus, the best friend of Julius Caesar, tries to convince himself that he should join the conspirators to kill Caesar. Brutus believes he joins the conspirators for the good of the people, but really he benefits himself in a roundabout way. “It must be by his death. And for my
…show more content…
part / I know no personal cause to spurn at him / But for the general” (II.i.10-12). Brutus agrees that the only way to protect the people from Caesar is to kill him, so Caesar doesn’t gain too much power. Yet Brutus is reluctant because he is good friends with Caesar, so he doesn’t want to kill him. But, in order for the people not to suffer, Brutus convinces himself to kill Caesar, but not before reminding himself that he has no personal cause for this action and is acting as a martyr. That lowliness is young ambition’s ladder And therefore think him as a serpent’s egg, Which, hatched, would, as his kind, grow And kill him in the shell. (II.i.23, 33-36) Ultimately, Caesar’s greatest flaw was his ambition and confidence, which led to his best friend choosing to kill him in order to stop him from gaining too much power.
Caesar poses such a threat that his best friend would go so far as to compare him to a serpent. Brutus decides he must kill Caesar “in the shell”, or before he becomes too powerful and he nips it in the bud. Although Brutus wholeheartedly believes that he is killing Caesar for the common good, Caesar’s death still benefits Brutus. Since killing Caesar prevented him from becoming a power-hungry dictator, it saved Brutus’ back in a roundabout way. Since Brutus was best friends with Caesar, if Caesar became dictator for life and abused his position of power, Brutus would be looked down upon as well because he didn’t do anything to stop Caesar. Therefore, Caesar’s death benefitted Brutus in the way that it protected his …show more content…
reputation. After Caesar is murdered, his good friend Marc Antony is naturally upset and wants to avenge his death. When the conspirators confessed that they were the ones that killed Caesar, Antony made a request that he would be able to speak at Caesar’s funeral after Brutus does. The conspirators unknowingly agreed to a part of Antony’s plan to avenge Caesar. Antony uses manipulation through ethos, pathos, and logos to convince the crowd at the funeral to turn against the conspirators and inspire them to help avenge Caesar’s death. After Brutus speaks at the funeral and convinces the crowd to be on the conspirator’s side, Antony immediately goes up after and convinces them of the opposite. The main reason the conspirators give for Caesar’s death was his ambition, and Antony proves to the crowd that Caesar was actually not ambitious. “When that the poor have cried, Caesar hath wept; / Ambition should be made of sterner stuff. / Yet Brutus says he was ambitious” (III.ii.100-103). Antony tells of a time when Caesar gave money to the poor, and when the poor cried, Caesar cried with them, which a person who was so ambitious would not have done. Antony even goes as far to say that since Brutus called Caesar ambitious, he was wrong and is dishonorable for saying that Caesar was ambitious. As Antony continues to give his funeral speech, he manipulates the crowd by using ethos, pathos, and logos. “Poor soul, his eyes are red as fire with weeping” (III.ii.127). This line is spoken by a townsperson who was listening to Antony’s speech and was remarking on the fact that Antony had to stop speaking for a moment because he was weeping. Of course, Antony would have been devastated by the death of his good friend, but he amps up the sorrow in front of the crowd in order to get them to side with him. Antony’s speech ends with the crowd expressing their desire to burn the conspirator’s houses down and to kill them as well. Caesar’s death resulted in the amount of power Antony had to exponentially increase. Before Caesar’s death, he had all of the power as a dictator, but after he died, Antony co-ruled with two other people, him being the most dominant out of the three. Antony, Octavius, and Lepidus are having a meeting to decide whom they should execute for disagreeing with and disobeying them. “These many, then, shall die; their names are / pricked” (IV.i.1-2). As ruler, Antony is able to order people to be killed and nobody can stop him. Before Caesar died, Antony never would’ve had this power, since Caesar declared himself dictator for life. By Caesar dying, it transferred most of the power to Antony, who benefited considerably. Gaius Cassius is the first person to introduce the idea of murdering Caesar to Brutus.
As a person, Cassius is mischievous and good at manipulating, making him the perfect persuader. In order to persuade Brutus to join the conspiracy against Caesar, Cassius bad-mouthed Caesar and pointed out his flaws. “He had a fever when he was in Spain... / How he did shake. ’Tis true, this god did shake / His coward lips did their color fly” (126, 127-128). Cassius is acquaintances with Caesar, so he knows a decent amount about his life. Cassius tells Brutus about a time when he and Caesar were in Spain and Caesar fell ill and had a seizure. By telling Brutus this, Cassius is pointing out flaws in Caesar that make him an unfit leader. Cassius also calls Caesar a coward, showing his utter disrespect and dislike for him both as a person and a leader. Cassius also mocks Caesar by calling him a god, implying that he is the opposite since he would be so weak as to have a seizure. Although Cassius claims that he wants to kill Caesar for the good of the people, those are not his real motivations. Cassius constantly belittles Caesar and tries to prove that he is not a good leader, showing his jealousy. “I had as lief not to be as live to be / In awe of such a thing as I myself” (I.ii.102-103). Cassius does not get why everyone is in awe of Caesar’s glory and believes that he deserves just as much glory as Caesar. Cassius states that he would rather die than worship a man who is below him.
Cassius is so hostile towards Caesar because he is jealous of Caesar’s power. Since Caesar declared himself dictator for life, that makes the people in the Senate like Cassius basically powerless. By killing Caesar, there would not be a dictator anymore and the Senate would go back to having a fair amount of power. Therefore, Cassius benefits from Caesar’s death in the same way that Marc Antony did, in the way that it increases his power. In Julius Caesar, most of the characters who use persuasion use it to benefit themselves. Gaius Cassius and Marc Antony know they are using persuasion manipulatively to get what they desire, but Marcus Brutus unknowingly helps himself through his persuasion. Although some of the characters use persuasion for power, some use it to protect themselves and their reputation. Either way, persuasion is a powerful tool in Julius Caesar, and many people were fooled.
In the beginning of the Book Cassius uses anecdotes of Caesar’s weakness and faults, argumentum ad antiquatum, and ethos on Brutus to persuade him to join the conspiracy to kill Caesar, this works on Brutus and shows that anyone, even people as stoic as Brutus, can be persuaded by appealing to their motivations. Cassius, a very suspicious character thru ought the play tells Brutus to “be not jealous on me” (827), in the quote he tells Brutus to not be suspicious of him because he is just a friend who genuinely cares. Cassius does this to put himself on Brutus’ side and not seem like a distant person, this allows him to criticize Caesar and suggest that he is a bad influence on Rome which appeals to Brutus’ desire to keeping Rome safe. After setting himself up as a friend to Brutus, Cassius uses harsh anecdotes on the weakness of Caesar to show that he isn’t fit to rule Rome. Cassius recollects on a time when he and Caesar went swimming in the river Tiber and Caesar screamed “Help me, Cassius or I sink” (828) to de...
Cassius truly believes Caesar has a frail state of mind and is unfit to have any form of authority in Rome. At first glance, his words and ideology seem to strive for the end of tyranny and become the savior of Romans, but it is clear he puts more emphasis on his rank rather than the well-being of others. When he states that their ranks were not their fault and should be taken into their own hands he intends to take his place by force with no regards for the Roman people or government. Additionally, Cassius shouldn’t be commended for saving Caesar from drowning because he remembrances on that deed to convince others that Caesar is feeble than most, yet he is treated like a god. Cassius’s greed for power motivates his murderous motivations but his ability to manipulate others to his will is also evident in his words. He refers to Caesar’s overwhelming power similar to a Colossus while he and the others “…walk under his huge legs… ” or are hidden in his glory. In reality though, the senators are more esteemed than despised. Another way Cassius misleads others is by faking Caesar’s fascist behaviors toward the commoners. He does so by forging negative letters about “Caesar’s Ambition” for Brutus to be pressured into joining his cause. Consumed by envy, he convinces Brutus to assassinate Caesar for the righteousness of the people but his incentive has
A character from Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, Cassius, exhibits Machiavellian attributes by manipulation and a drive to accomplish his goal of assassinating Julius Caesar by any means. Cassius was able to successfully manipulate both Brutus and the fellow conspirators. Cassius was able to influence Brutus enough to make Brutus believe that killing Julius Caesar, Brutus’ best friend, was the right action. Initially, Brutus was wary of Cassius when Brutus said, “Into what dangers would you lead me, Cassius?” (1.2.69) Subsequently, Brutus is persuaded as he states, “...what you have said / I will consider” (1.2.176-177). Cassius is willing to control any person who stands in his way. Cassius successfully turned Brutus against his best friend in order to achieve what Cassius believes to be best for Rome. When Brutus says, “Let me not hinder, Cassius, your desires” (1.2.35) it is clear that Cassius has swayed Brutus to believe in his cause. In Julius Caesar, we do not see Cassius as the main leader of the cons...
Brutus thinks that killing Caesar is a noble act because it is for the good of Rome. However would Brutus have thought this if Cassius had not tricked him into believing it? It could be argued that Brutus manipulated himself into thinking what he did was honorable when really it was not and he was just following what Cassius wanted him to do. Brutus even says in the beginning of the play that he does not have it in him to kill Caesar. “Into what dangers would you lead me, Cassius/ That you would have me seek into myself/ For that which is not in me?” (1.2.60-71) It seems that Brutus’s thoughts on the subject change completely after assuring himself that it is for the good of Rome. Cassius does the same thing. He convinces himself that Caesar is corrupt when really he is just jealous of his power. Caesar is also guilty of this. For example, he is superstitious only when it is convenient for him. He does not believe the soothsayer when he tells him to “beware the ides of March,”(citation?) but he believes Decius when he says that Calpurnia’s dream means he will be a good ruler. Caesar does not want to accept that he could be in danger. He trains himself to only believe in good omens.
Cassius is a sly, deceitful and an untrustworthy character. Caesar described him best. He said (act1, scene 2, line 195), “Yond Cassius has a lean and hungry look; He thinks too much. Such men are dangerous”. Cassius is very superstitious. This is shown when he says (act 5, scene 1, line 75) “ you know I held Epicurus strong, and his opinion. Now I change my mind, and partly credit things that do presage…”. He believes in omen and signs that foretell events to come. Cassius is conceded. This is shown when he says to Brutus (act1, scene 2, line 116), “ And this man is now become a god, and Cassius is now a wretched creature, and must bend his body if Caesar careless but nod on him…”. Cassius continues on saying about times when he saved Caesar from drowning and when he saw Caesar with a fever and he started to shake. All this tells us that Cassius thinks he is just as good or even better than Caesar.
Brutus turned on his best friend and stabbed him in the back. In Julius Caesar’s final moments he noticed his best friend as a traitor. “Et tu, Brute! Then fall, Caesar”, these are Caesars last words as he is stabbed in the back by his friend. Since Brutus thought what he did was for Rome, he did not kill his best friend out of spite or hate he killed his best friend Julius Caesar so that Rome could live. Brutus was tricked into believing that Caesar would not be fit to be king, and would destroy the place Brutus loves, Brutus killed Caesar to protect Rome. Despite what Brutus did, he did only what he thought was the only thing he could do to save Rome. He thought not about his position he thought about the people. Yet he killed Caesar off
Cassius and one of the other conspirators discuss the plan on getting people to turn against Caesar. As Cassius is talking to Cinna he says, “Three parts of him is ours already, and the man entire upon the next encounter yields him ours” (I.iii). Cassius is trying to write fake letters to people turning against Caesar that Brutus will believe. Brutus decides the best thing to do is kill Caesar because of the letters and the convincing of Cassius. When Brutus and Cassius first meet, Cassius is already acting as a mirror for Brutus. When Brutus thinks Cassius is leading him to danger Cassius says, “So well as by reflection, I your glass will modestly discover to yourself that of yourself which you yet know not of” (I.ii). Cassius believes he could be the conscious of Brutus and lead him in the path of killing Caesar. Brutus and a conspirator finally get ready for the death of Caesar. As Brutus draws near the final moment of Caesar’s death he says, “Since Cassius first did whet me against Caesar I have not slept” (II.i). In the beginning of the story Brutus was said to be one of Caesar’s closest friends. Cassius turned it all around and then made Brutus suspicious of Caesar. Brutus admits that the planning of Caesar’s death has brought a nightmare upon him. Cassius was a shadow that Brutus followed which resulted in the death of
Brutus’ leadership and compassion for others make him a popular figure amongst the Roman people, and it is his reputation that establishes him as an influential individual. For example, despite the fact that Brutus loves Caesar like a brother, he warily joins the conspiracy to assassinate him. He does this because he believes that Caesar’s ambition would become tyranny and that Caesar’s death is a necessary evil in order to preserve the liberties of the Roman people. In his own words Brutus claims, “It must be by his death; and for my part, I know no personal cause to spurn at him, but for the general.”(Act 2, Scene 1, Page 1116). In addition, Brutus takes the reins of authority from Cassius and becomes the leader of the conspiracy. He gains this prerogative because of his convincing tongue and powerful influence. His leadership is evidenced when he begins to challenge Cassius’ ideas. When Cassius asks the conspirators to “swear our resolution”(Act 2...
When Brutus betrayed Caesar for the good of Rome by killing him, he had no idea that he would regret it later on in his life. Brutus wanted to kill Caesar because he thought that if Caesar became king, he would forget who his real friends are and he would not pay attention to them. He also thought that Caesar would become too powerful and therefore did not want him to be king. This is shown when Portia says, “…Brutus hath a suit / that Caesar will not grant…” (2.4.41-42). Although Brutus had a clear conscience, the people of Rome did not. This eventually led to Brutus being driven out of Rome by the citizens. Not being associated with Rome anymore made Brutus’ life worse and he eventually took his own life as the only way to...
Many characters in Julius Caesar demonstrate qualities of contrasting ambitious objectives. Deception and manipulation appear to be two of the main qualities contributing to the plot for the assassination of Caesar. Although Brutus is seen as the leader of the conspirators Cassius established himself as a deceitful manipulator with an immoral agenda. Although seen throughout the play, Cassius’s soliloquy primarily demonstrates the immoral aspects of his character as he is driven by manipulating Brutus’s political position for personal advancement.
In Julius Caesar two men, Antony and Brutus, make two different speeches but with the same concept of ethos, logos, and pathos at Caesar's funeral. Brutus claims that it is okay that he killed Caesar and makes a speech about it. Antony is the more persuasive speaker than Brutus because he uses ethos, pathos, and logos better than Brutus. Brutus has a way with the people. He is a politician, and he knows how to get the people on his side.
He is so motivated by ambition that he decides to kill Caesar, the leader of Rome. Although dedication can be a good quality, in Cassius, it blinds him to all other things and makes him ruthless in his quest to rule Rome. Cassius’s desire for power is evident when he states, "Men at some time are masters of their fates. The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars, But in ourselves, that we are underlings" (1.2.146-148). Cassius’ ambition leads him to go as far as to convince a dear friend with manipulation and false notes to help him plot to kill Caesar. His ambition makes him power hungry and he lacks the honor to back up his overzealous behavior. Cassius envies Caesar and because of this he resorts to bribery, assassinations, and imposing taxes for personal
Cassius is unhappy about Caesar potentially becoming king of Rome and Cassius works to encourage Brutus to plot against Caesar by saying, “except immortal Caesar, speaking of Brutus and groaning underneath this age’s yoke, have wished that noble Brutus had his eyes” (1.2.61-64). Cassius mentions to Brutus that people are speaking about Rome and how they wish Brutus would notice what could happen if Caesar is crowned. Cassius reveals to Brutus that the people are wondering why someone as noble as Brutus is not aware of what could happen if Caesar is crowned. Cassius is practically stroking Brutus’ ego to make him feel as though he is wiser than Caesar and should do something about Caesar. Once Caesar is dead and the triumvirate and Cassius and Brutus’ armies are in battle, Cassius yet again proves he is dishonorable when he exclaims that, “If this be known, Cassius or Caesar never shall turn back, for I will slay myself” (3.1.24-26). Committing suicide was not an honorable thing to do because it was not accepting the consequences of one’s actions. Cassius does not have the same honest reasons for the conspiracy as Brutus does, so he is constantly worried about being caught. Throughout the play, Cassius threatens to kill himself because to him, it is the easy way out and he can escape his problems without solving them. In Act 4, Cassius plays the pity card in order to make Brutus feel bad for him when he complains, “Strike, as thou didst at Caesar. For I know when thou didst hate him worst, thou lovedst him better than ever thou lovedst Cassius” (4.3.110-113). Cassius whines to Brutus that Brutus does not care as much about him as he did about Caesar. Cassius is manipulating Brutus to make him pity him. He knows that Brutus does not want Cassius to be upset so Brutus will try to reason with him, ultimately allowing Cassius to have his
In this play, Cassius’ motivation is completely inspired by evil and hatred. His jealousy of Caesar and greed for power drives him to create the conspiracy and start plotting the death of Caesar. While talking to Casca, he says, “What trash is Rome, / What rubbish and what offal, when is serves / For the bas matter to illuminate / So vile a thing as Caesar!” (I.iii.109-112). This shows some of the true feelings Cassius has about Caesar. He believes that Caesar is not worthy of his power and does not want anyone to hold more power than him. Although he justifies the killing of Caesar as an act for freedom from tyranny, his motivation is full of bad intent. In an attempt to disguise his true motives, Cassius convinces Brutus, an honorable and well-respected man, to join the conspiracy. He tells Brutus, “Brutus and Caesar-what should be in that “Caesar”? / Why should that name be sounded more than yours? / Write them together, yours is as fair a name. / Sound them, it doth become the mouth as well. / ...
Both Cassius and Brutus conspire against Caesar, yet Shakespeare depicts Brutus as doing a noble job compared to Cassius as doing a greedy and envious task. Cassius believes that he is stronger than Caesar. Therefore, Cassius does not understand why Caesar is in power and he is not. Cassius is also envious of Caesar. In Act I Scene II, Cassius describes to Brutus the time he had to save Caesar in a swimming race. Since then, Cassius feels superior to Caesar. In Cassius’ mind, kings’ right to rule should be based off of strength, not intelligence or virtue. On the other hand, Brutus knows that although a king should be strong, he must also be virtuous. Brutus always elaborates on the topic of honor. In fact, his first priority is to keep his own honor intact and Brutus fears that Caesar will change when he is crowned. Brutus says, “He would be crowned: How that might change his nature, there’s the question.” (Act II, Scene I, Page 49, lines 12-14) He senses Caesar’s greed for power, and ...