How Did Gertrude Stein Write Melanctha

843 Words2 Pages

Gertrude Stein was a well-known American author who was best known for her modernist writing along with her works in poetry. Within both her writing and poetry she focused on a specific theme dealing with homosexuality. In 1909, she wrote Three Lives which housed at the center of the book one of her most critically popular short stories titled “Melanctha”. “Melanctha” has been a controversial story for many critics for a number of reason but many look at the connection between Stein’s own life and the story of Melanctha. An analysis of Stein’s work “Melanctha” reveals to readers that Stein placed pieces of her own life into the story to express her own identity issues and the issues of race during her lifetime. Stein’s story of “Melanctha” in Three Lives has been well-known for its ability to challenge conservative realism. In regards to her depiction of black characters like Melanctha, Rose Johnson, and James Herbert, Barbara Will says,
“In writing ‘Melanctha’, Stein found herself in a complex web of racial contradictions. She was very much drawn to African-American popular musical culture at the turn of the century, …show more content…

Melanctha shows her ability to stay true to her culture and still not accept being stereotyped as either black or white. It can be mentally difficult for Melanctha to not be able to be a biracial individual, and since she cannot, she can only be seen as spiritually unfulfilled. Once Melanctha’s death happens, Stein is still dealing with the racial labels that still surround certain places. Melanctha’s death is Stein’s own issue of the uncertainty of the racial system that has surrounded her personal life. The traditional race belief embraced by Rose Johnson and also Jeff Campbell shows that they are not able to understand Melanctha’s revolt towards the ethical aspects of life, and the hypothetical burden of the

Open Document