Harry Harlow's Controversial Experiments

442 Words1 Page
bulb-icon

Recommended: Should animals be used in research

During the twentieth century, Harry Harlow performed one of the most controversial experiments that led to a scientific breakthrough concerning the parent-child relationship. It paved the way for understanding terms such as secure, insecure, ambivalent, and disorganized relationships (Bernstein, 2014, 364). During the course of this study, Harlow separated baby monkeys from their birth mothers and isolated them in frightening environments. According to the video “H.H. Overview”, this proved the monkey’s preference for a comforting mother versus a nutritional one. However, this raises the question: can his experiments be deemed ethical, or did his scientific inquiry overstep boundaries?
According to our class discussions and Harlow’s experiment, holding and comforting a baby is psychologically more important than food. However, Harlow was recorded stating that “the best way to understand the heart, was to break it”. Referring to the question previously asked, can his study be deemed ethical? Ethics can be defined as morals, or wanting to prevent discomfort to others (Bernstein, 2014, 37). Based on this definition, I do not believe he exercised his ethical responsibility to these baby monkeys, which correlates to our discussion in class that it can be seen as unethical. Also, our moral code dictates that …show more content…

The cost, in this experiment, was the separation of a baby monkey from its mother. Also, it was forced to endure inhumane conditions by being frightened, not knowing what it did to deserve such treatment. I understand the positive implications that can result from experiments on animals, but only the tests that are absolutely necessary should be performed. In saying this, Harry Harlow crossed the line when he caused the baby monkeys psychological scarring. He had already collected definitive data from the previous wire and cloth mother tests, so this extra step was not called

Show More
Related

  • Review of Stanley Milgram’s Experiments on Obedience, by Diana Baumrind and Obedience, by Ian Parker

    890 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Ethical Issues of the Milgram Experiment.” Associated Content. Yahoo, 8 November 2008. Web. 12 October 2011.

    Read More

  • The Strange Situation as a Measure of Attachment Type

    470 Words  | 1 Pages

    The Strange Situation, in which infants are exposed to eight different episodes involving the mother and/or a stranger, is widely used to test attachments, although there are many different views regarding its validity and reliability. In order for the Strange Situation to be considered reliable, a child tested at different times should produce the same reaction every time; this was supported by Main, Kapland and Cassidy’s 1985 study which found that 100% of infants who had been securely attached before 18 months were still securely attached at 6 years, and 75% of those who had been anxious-avoidant remained so. One interpretation of attachment type (based on the Strange Situation) is that it is a fixed characteristic and therefore cannot be changed, but if there is a change in family circumstances this is often not the case. Attachments to mothers and fathers have been proven to be independent – Main and Weston (1981) found that children reacted differently depending on which parent they were with. This shows that the attachment types shown by the Strange Situation are based on qualities of distinct relationships as opposed to a child’s characteristics.

    Read More

  • Alfred Kinsey and William Masters and Virginia Johnson: Were They Ethical?

    1629 Words  | 4 Pages

    In order to understand whether the research Alfred Kinsey, or any researcher, conducted was scientifically acceptable, one has to understand the rules of ethics and the scientific method. The rules of ethics include informed consent of the participants; voluntary participation; restricting the use of deception and debriefing the participants after the experiment; keeping the information about the participants confidential; and providing alternative activities (Huffman 18-19). The scientific method i...

    Read More

  • Harlow's Experiment and My life

    804 Words  | 2 Pages

    Harry F. Harlow was an American Psychologist who studied human behavior and development through studies of social behavior of monkeys. Harlow got his BA and PhD of Psychology from Stanford University. Then, later on got a job and did his studies at the University of Wisconsin. Harlow’s experiment consisted of young monkeys being separated from their mother right after birth. Then, the monkeys were raised in the laboratories which had mothers that were made up of wired mesh and another with wood and a terry cloth. When the infant monkeys were placed in the cage with only one mother was equipped with a nipple which was the wired mesh mother. It was placed so the infant monkey could nurse. Even though the wired monkey had nourishment, the young monkey would most often cling to the terry cloth mother. Harlow would place a monkey inside a cage. Then, began to make loud noises against the cage or play recordings that made the monkey feel insecure. The monkey always seemed to go toward the terry cloth mother as it began to get scared. The infant monkey would go for comfort, but eventually would get nourishment from the wired mother.

    Read More

  • The Little Albert Experiment by John Watson and Rosalie Rayner

    1876 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Little Albert experiment has become a widely known case study that is continuously discussed by a large number of psychology professionals. In 1920, behaviorist John Watson and his assistant Rosalie Rayner began to conduct one of the first experiments done with a child. Stability played a major factor in choosing Albert for this case study, as Watson wanted to ensure that they would do as little harm as possible during the experiment. Watson’s method of choice for this experiment was to use principles of classic conditioning to create a stimulus in children that would result in fear. Since Watson wanted to condition Albert, a variety of objects were used that would otherwise not scare him. These objects included a white rat, blocks, a rabbit, a dog, a fur coat, wool, and a Santa Claus mask. Albert’s conditioning began with a series of emotional tests that became part of a routine in which Watson and Rayner were determining whether other stimuli’s could cause fear.

    Read More

  • Ethical Violations In John Watson's Little Albert

    140 Words  | 1 Pages

    According to APA’s guidelines, John Watson’s “Little Albert” study would not be allowed today because of ethical violations. One ethical violation is the lack of consent from the subject. Little Albert could never give consent because he was an infant. Watson took advantage of the fact that Albert could not tell people that he wanted to withdraw from the study. Participants should always know what the study will involve and what risks might develop.

    Read More

  • Summary Of A Question Of Ethics By Jane Goodall

    677 Words  | 2 Pages

    In her essay “A Question of Ethics,” Jane Goodall, a scientist who has studied chimpanzees for years, tries to resolve a heavily debated ethical dilemma: Under what circumstances is it acceptable to cause animal suffering to prevent human suffering? Her answer, however, remains uncertain. Although Goodall challenges scientists to avoid conducting unnecessary tests on animals, she does not explain the criteria by which scientists should determine necessity.

    Read More

  • The Necessities of Animal Experimentation

    1270 Words  | 3 Pages

    Writing this paper did not affect my original line of thinking in regards to the topic. I support animal rights in every way, and am extremely against any sort of testing. Observing the “necessities” of animal testing did not, in any way, alter my negative view of animal experimentation.

    Read More

  • The Necessity of Animal Testing

    980 Words  | 2 Pages

    The types of experiments performed at the University of Buffalo and the University of California depicts just some of the few horrors of animal testing. According to the article, during these experimentations the eyes of monkeys were implanted with metal coils into their eye sockets in order to study movement ("Update: Animal Testing"). Often times animals are tested upon in laboratories, living in cold isolated environments. The moral aspect of the debate, is whether or not animals should be utilized and later euthanized for the purpose of human benefit, especially when only one party decides. As a resu...

    Read More

  • Harlow's Cloth And Wire Monkey Experiments

    498 Words  | 1 Pages

    In this experiment a psychologist named Harry Harlow had an idea about the effects and damages of love and conducted them in the 1960’s. Harlow demonstrated the powerful effects of love. His experiments were often inhumane and just cruel. But they uncovered many truths and facts that have heavily influenced our understanding of child development. Harlow’s experiment involved giving young monkeys a choice between two different "mothers." One was made of soft terrycloth, but provided no food. The other was made of wire, but provided nourishment from an attached baby bottle. Harlow removed young monkeys from their natural mothers a few hours after birth and left them to be raised by the wire and terrycloth mothers. The experiment demonstrated that the baby monkeys spent significantly more time with their cloth mother than with their wire mother. Basically the infant monkeys went to the wire mother only for food,but spent most of their time with the comforting terry cloth mother. The monkey would turn the the terry cloth mother as a security blanket. In the end of the experiment when the mothers were removed from the room, the effects were substantial. The young monkeys no longer had a security blanket or anything to comfort it for exploration and would often freeze up, rock, scream, and cry.

    Read More

  • Harry Harlow's Theory On Rhesus Monkeys

    501 Words  | 2 Pages

    Indeed no animal should have to go through terrible conditions in which they are helpless and depend upon the researchers to take care of them and get little to no care just for the sake of scientific research. For example “the real mother macaques, realizing their babies were being stolen, screaming and banging their heads against the cage; the infants choo-chooing as they were hurled into a separate space. […] The cages were smeared gold with grief, the infant macaques all balled over themselves with their tails held high to show their tiny oozing anuses” (Slater137). It is clear that the monkeys were undergoing lots of stress, and yet none of the researchers did anything to lower their stress and anxiety. Specifically “the researchers tried to attach the masked ball to the surrogate mother, and the infant screamed in horror, rushed to a corner of its cage, rocked violently, grasping it’s raw genitals” (Slater139). Additionally this poor rhesus monkeys was purposely put into an uncomfortable situation, therefore showing that these tests were unethical. Namely “the iron Maiden was a special surrogate mother Harlow had designed; she shot out sharp spikes and blasted her babies with air so cold and forceful the infants were thrown back against the bars of their cages, clinging and screaming” (Slater140). About a year after the research had started,

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Jahrling's Research

    234 Words  | 1 Pages

    These experiments that were conducted on the monkeys have a high chance of encouraging other countries to take the same actions and produce their own experimentation. If other countries were to be suspicious of the actions that the scientists have taken they too might undergo certain testing. Take Russia as an example. They are another country, other than the Unites States, that have their hands on the smallpox virus. They too can begin experimenting on animals if they believe this virus can be a threat. Some felt, “the biggest danger of Jahrling’s research was that it would look suspicious to other countries and would encourage them to do their own experimentation. We would start an arms race over small pox.” (211). Preston claimed that, this

    Read More

  • Ethical Issues In Lord Of The Flies

    1261 Words  | 3 Pages

    I believe that the experiments did go unethical to a point of it only being a test it shows that the mind is a beautiful disaster if not maintained well. The novel Lord of The Flies is a great example of what authority and corruption leads to without ethics and morals. This was all in all a devious example of our society.

    Read More

  • Milgram's Experiment Ethical Research

    1315 Words  | 3 Pages

    Milgram’s experiment did not meet all the ethical guidelines despite no real physical harm to the participant nor the confederate, the experiment broke the code of conduct in regard to what constitutes an ethical study in a number of ways. The first issue was that Milgram used deception; he thought this to be necessary to help meet his aims in a valid way, and although some levels of deception are at times

    Read More

  • Dasein in Being There

    3218 Words  | 7 Pages

    Some years after I'd abandoned this line of thinking, resigned to the fact that the experiment could probably never be carried out in an ethically acceptable way, a college professor encouraged me to read Jerzy Kosinski's novel Being There. In this novel's main character, Chance, I found, after a fashion, an approximation of the very project I'd been dreaming about all those years: a human being raised in a static and unexciting environment, with very few other human influences.

    Read More

More about Harry Harlow's Controversial Experiments

Open Document