Greccio Meal

2601 Words6 Pages

INTRODUCTION

In his Earlier Rule, Francis encouraged the friars to preach through their actions rather than their words (Let all the brothers, however preach by their deeds). For Francis, gestures and symbols were as important as the words themselves. In the Franciscan sources, Francis depended as much on dramatic gestures and images as he did upon words he spoke (or didn’t speak) to preach his message. The meal at the Greccio provides an excellent example of how Francis used both of these elements, as well as words to make manifest “sermon”. This paper will examine this Greccio meal through the lens of two sources, the earlier Assisi Compilation and the later work, The Remembrance of the Desire of a Soul by Thomas of Celano. The Greccio meal will be compared and contrasted in these two sources, especially with regards to the significance of Francis unspoken actions within these writings. For Francis, actions did indeed speak louder than words.

Source Texts

The first account in which the story of the Greccio meal may be found is in a collection of early Franciscan documents known as The Assisi Compilation. This gathering of early sources arose soon after the election of Crescentius of Iesi as Minister General of the Order of Friars Minor in 1244. After his election, Crescentius ordered all of the friars to send him written accounts of whatever they could recall about the life of Francis. Since many of the friars who had personally known Francis

were reaching the end of their lives, Crescentius was attempting to preserve the oral memory of “those who knew him”. It was this directive of Crescentius which gave birth to the

collection of accounts which later came to be called The Assisi Compilation. This compi...

... middle of paper ...

...rding to the Assisi Compilation, was effective (Some of them began to weep loudly, considering how he was seated on the ground, wishing to correct them in such a holy and simple way).

The Greccio meal recorded in both The Remembrance of the Desire of a Soul and The Assisi Compilation are both interesting sources for looking at the more dramatic side of Francis’ ministry and the methods which he utilized to preach his message. While it may be difficult to parse the account of the meal from the historical and the hagiographical, the essential elements, primarily Francis use of performative preaching are accurate. From the standpoint of homiletics, Francis use of silent gestures and drama may have been looked down upon. But Francis uses of these things were effective at convincing his intended audience, and is that not the goal of all preaching?

Open Document