In literature, authors try to use the method of comparison and contrast to help and engage the readers to have a better understanding of what the deeper meaning of the text. The command summary between both stories is there are two men, who come to both houses to offer to help a family in need. The overall problem was occurring from the short stories. Both men's were not who the families thought to be true. Teaching teaches women why men will take time out of your life just to achieve mercy for themselves. It is important to understand the necessity of the compare and contrast method because the reader needs to understand the different standpoints an author has on a subject. Between two short stories, "Good Country People" and "The Life You …show more content…
Save May Be Your Own," there are similar and different occurrences that happen within the theme, symbolism. The problems happening are not the same, but it has its similarities. Both stories show the contrast of innocence to evil, and O'Connor organizes this to prove that trust should not be given, but earned. According to Good Country People, there are many themes, but the main theme is innocence. In this short story, an altercation happened to create integrity within the story. Hulga was a very smart and educated woman. Having a degree in “Philosophy” shows the reader she is intelligent. Never less the problems Joy faced daily dealing with being disabled. It caused Joy to lack experience in the real world. Therefore, this caused her to be innocent and not realizing when people manipulate her. Throughout the book, Hulga met a man who appeared to be a nice looking Christian man. The man, Manley Pointer, was not the man who he claimed to be. Manley is a false Bible salesman. When walking around the neighborhood, Manley saw Hulga’s wooden leg, which brought him to their house. In Manley’s mind, he figures if talking about being a Christian and having faith will bring him closer to the family. When Manley said, “You just awhile ago said you didn’t believe in nothing” “I thought you were just some girl!”(CW 282). Joy knew something was not adding up. Fortunately, the whole time visualizing what Mr. Pointer is trying to undertake if everything being spoken during dinner accurate. At the end of the story he tells, “I use a different name at every house I call at and don’t stay nowhere long” (O'Connor 291). The lies were occurring, manipulation to trick innocent people to receive his accomplishments. Nowadays people live in a world were before believing what a person was saying, see if their action matches how they present themselves. People will go low just to conceive their accomplishments. Nevertheless, this is why the principal theme of "Good Country People" is Christianity. Pointer states, “The word of God ought to be in the parlor” (O'Connor 278). By him saying this, he is pushing the need for Christianity in the household. During this conversation with him and Hulga, he is trying to sell a Bible to her to try to convince Hulga that he is a satisfying Christian man that can be trusted. Furthermore, in, “The Life You Save May Be Your Own” the only innocence demonstrated is catching the real willingness of Mrs. Crater daughter. Both women are named Lucynell Crater. The daughter is mentally disabled. Unfortunately, treating Lucynell as everything has to be answered by her mother. From reading, being disabled has an effect on your life. Meaning, there are people in the world that see negativity happening daily and will try to constrain to accomplish what is needed. As from Tom Shiftlet, the first items that caught his eye was a house and a car. Tom adage the polite, welcoming Lucynell, it gave him ideas how easier it is to conquer his goals. All Mr. Shiftlet needed to fix problems around the house, and that would have gotten him closer to the car. Helping a family with needs gives Tom points. Lucynell did not speak a word until Tom came around, “He has spent a week on the farm, patching and building, and has taught Lucynell to say the word “bird” “The big rosy-faced girl followed him everywhere, saying ‘Burttddt, ddburttdi,’ and clapping her hands” (Clasby 163). The whole time Mrs. Crater is awkwardly observing them two together, seeing the way Lucynell is starting to act. If ever someone wants to marry Mrs. Crater daughter it was not happening. As for Tom, it would have been magnificent. That made the connection between Tom and Lucynell mother stronger. Both knew innocent daughter would not understand anything happening, so taking advantage of the situation was a very good idea. The main prize Tom wanted is the car in the garage. Once Tom assisted around the house and teaching Lucynell how to speak more fluently will turn things around. The idea plan once Tom has seen the car being to vanish, “The car, a mechanical womb, where he sleeps, is his means of escape” (Clasby 164). His Performance is exactly what Mrs. Crater will be a step closer to him to the automobile. Influencing readers the lack of care displayed throughout both stories. Having no care about an individual is disrespectful. Figuring out if these stories are the same or different. Obviously, both are similar to one another. The ending of the two both men leave the disabled woman behind. The fact in “Good Country People” Mr. Pointer claimed his beliefs into being a Christian are real. If that were the case leaving Joy behind would have been the last option. The Bible has never spoken to leave anyone behind and mistreat them. In the story, “The Life You Save May Be your own”, Tom came to a family that felt his companies would not have been evil to help them out around the house. In reality, do not judge a book by its cover. Furthermore, this shows when thinking your plans are flowing through, it is easy to lose all that conquered. Lucynell is not marrying the man out of love, it is for the wrong reason, and so the mother captures what she wants. Symbolism is another way that an author can express a deeper meaning through something else is spiritual.
For example, Flannery O’Connor used symbolism in “Good Country People” by having a not so beautiful woman change her name from Joy to Hulga. O’Connor portrays a woman who does not think highly of herself. To represent her low self-esteem Joy changes her name to Hulga. The thought of the name Joy did not fit her, so she thought of the ugliest name, “She had arrived at it first purely on the basis of its ugly sound and then the full genius of its fitness had struck her” (O’Connor 275). Joy thought that the ugliest name she could think of would fit her best because she thought she was ugly. Joy had low self-esteem because of her wooden leg and her being a large girl. O’Connor used the name change to symbolize how she felt about herself. Manley was engaged into Joy, while he was eating dinner, admiring her in every type of way. The way Manley looked in Joy's direction showed how much of a different person he was. So in his point of view, the wooden leg was not even a factor, but as a child growing up without a part of the body changes the …show more content…
conditions. Another way O’Connor uses the symbolic method in Good Country People is through Hulga’s wooden leg.
Hulga’s wooden leg is symbolic for her fractured identity. Reviewing over the novel, “Mrs. Hopewell excused this attitude because of the leg (which had been shot off in a hunting accident when Joy was ten)” (O’Connor 274). With Joy loses her leg at such a tender age, it affected her lifestyle in many different ways. It changed the way she thought of herself because she was not comfortable in her skin. Hulga was not able to participate in activities that other kids were growing up could. The identity question of who Joy was and who she was starting at such a developing age. When Mr. Pointer took Joy into the woods to a tree house, "When the salesman insists that she show him her love is true by taking off her wooden leg, Hulga mistakenly trusts in love for the first time" (Leigh 369). The way Hulga looked, shows how much of a change in her comfort zone was brought out. It convinced the audience that for the first time someone made Mrs. Hulga feel the vitality of
life. A third example of symbolism in “Good Country People” is Manley’s hollow Bible. The hollowed Bible filled with alcohol, card, and condoms. Manley states, “For a Chrustian, the word of God ought to be in every room in the house besides in his heart” (O'Connor 278). Manley tries to show people that he is an exceptional Christian and influence people to buy Bibles. In reality, his Bible is hollow and full of inappropriate things. With the Bible is dull it symbolizes the hollowness of his belief in Christianity. On the outside, he is equivalent to a caring Christian, but on the inside, he is full of non-Christian things, just as his hollowed Bible. Coming from the Hopewell family religion is a significant impact on their lives. Since Mr. Pointer was generous to come and speak, Mrs. Hopewell invites him insides the house for dinner. If a person is coming into someone’s life unexpected just trying to help, it causes things harder not to encourage the person. The biggest problem the Hopewell's should have been worrying about is why Manley never actually opened the suitcase. Mr. Pointer out tricked the family by using his kindness and humbleness. Taking advantage of Joy is much uncomplicated. In Joy's mind, Mrs. Freeman and Mrs. Hopewell made all of the decisions. This drawn dilemma for Joy. One of the symbolic things in “The Life You Save May Be Your Own” is the spirituality happening. Just because living in a desolated spot, does not mean you are safe. Apparently, Tom Shiftlet saw there was a random house in the middle of nowhere. When Mrs. Crater sees him with one armed showed his peacefulness. Tom noticed the disabled person. Meeting Lucynell was not supposed to happen. After a while of talking, Tom sees a beautiful sunset.
Hopewell’s daughter, Joy who renames herself to Hulga. Hulga who is also like Phoenix, a victim of circumstances, is highly educated, was shot in the leg while young, and thus has a wooden leg and is also sick in that she has a weak heart. Hulga, goes through these circumstances and takes them negatively, she is seen as not only rude but also always cross and insensitive to other people’s feelings or emotions an example of this is when she shouted at her mother, Mrs. Hopewell, at the table “Woman! Do you ever look inside? Do you ever look inside and see what you are not? God!” (Clugston,
In her story, “Greenleaf”, the author Flannery O’Conner shows us that people can sometimes blind their factual vision of the world through a mask of dreams, so that they would not be able to make a distinction between reality and their dreams of reality. O’Conner unveils this through the use of point of view , character, irony, and
Joy Hopewell is the name given to Hulga by her mother and father when she was a baby. This name brings to mind a person who looks on the brighter side of things and doesn’t let things discourage her. In the readers mind this name may perhaps bring about the image of a teacher or someone who works with children in a well light happy place. It is also a softer more vulnerable name, which may have been O’Conner’s intent in using the name Joy. In the story Joy changes her name to Hulga Hopewell because of the fact that she feels it better suits her personality. During her childhood Hulga had an accident in which her leg was shot off of her body; therefore, she has to wear a wooden leg that is rather bulky so by having the name Hulga it helps her to deter many people from asking questions or trying to get too close to her. Due to this accident Hulga becomes a brooding person, not very fond of company and entertainment. The name Hulga brings to mind a rather large Swedish woman who could probably break a man in half. It is a brooding name and awkward on ...
Freeman, mother of Carramae and Gylnese and Mrs. Hopewell Hulga’s mother. Both characters have a major impact towards Hulga’s life. Mrs. Freeman, as described by O’Conner is seen more of a realist who speaks and thinks freely. She is a very passionate woman and “had a special fondness for the details of secret infections hidden deformities, assaults upon children”, which in this case applies to Hulgas state of appearance, her deformity the artificial leg. This quote shows the bond Hulga has with Mrs. Freeman since she is very passionate about deformity. Hulga appreciates Mrs. Freeman because she helps her distinguish a more realistic view of life and the world, rather than following the same old good Christian morals. On the other hand Mrs. Hopewell, joys mother is seen as a good woman who has good Christian values. O’Conner uses this symbolistic name of Mrs. Hopewell because she carries hope with her where ever she is. “People who looked on the bright side of things would be beautiful even if they were not” (173). She is a very optimistic good Christian and follows good country people morals. She is as well proud of her ability to see well in anyone she crosses and help any situation that is in a bad state. O’Conner’s usage of indirect characters like Mrs. Hopewell and Mrs. Freeman play a role in Hulga’s nihilistic life as an angel and a demon. Both constantly attempt to influence their beliefs without forcing their opinions towards
Joy/Hulga has two items that are used alternately to describe her, the eyeglasses that counter her weak eyes and are a sign of her intellectuality, and the wooden leg that she wields through sound and appearance as a weapon against her mother’s solicitude. When Manley Pointer removes her glasses and steals her wooden leg, she is left totally weak and vulnerable. The Bible salesman himself uses the illusion of Bibles as a symbol. He has claimed to have a suitcase full of Bibles to sell, but his moral laxness is revealed when he opens the case to reveal two Bibles, one of which has a hidden
STUDY GUIDE ----- The Anthem Chapter 1 1.a. What is the difference between a and a? The society that is represented in the novel is futuristic in terms of the actual date, yet incredibly underdeveloped to what we experience today. The political structure obviously works, because there doesn't seem to be much discontent among the citizens.
When looking into works of literature, some stories seem to be similar to others. They can have a similar setting, point of view, theme, or sense of language and style. However, all of these points could be very different as well and could cover different theme or style. Flannery O’Conner’s “Good Country People” and Alice Walker’s “Everyday Use” have some contrasting elements, such as their points of view and use of symbolism, but their similarities in the underlying theme, language, and the setting of these stories reveal how these two stories are impacted by education on both the individual and their family.
Straying away from life as a whole only to be alone, some may say is the strong way to heal themselves when dealing with extreme grief or a major crisis . In the book Wild, twenty-two year old Cheryl Strayed thought she had lost it all. Dealing with the loss of her mother, her family torn to pieces, and her very own marriage was being destroyed right before her very eyes. Living life with nothing more to lose, lifeless, she made the most life changing decision of her life. Strayed never seems remorseful on her decisions to up and leave everything behind while deciding to flee from it all. This being her way of dealing with life, it shows her as being strong; a woman of great strength and character. She shows personal strength, which is more than just a physical word. It is a word of very high value and can only be defined by searching deep within your very own soul.
Hopewell and Joy-Hulga, but also contains a humorous, yet judgmental tone in the story that defines the characters, mostly in Hulga. Hulga is considered the most ironic character in the story because of the little understanding she has of herself regardless of how well educated she is. She may consider herself the smartest woman in the story and may have pride in herself but what she doesn’t know is that Manley, a man who ironically sells Bibles and yet, is not a Christian, proves Hulga wrong in the end and makes her the one with stupidity. Using third person limited allows the reader to gather a deeper understanding of characters by using other characters that know them better than themselves. Overall, it is highly important to dig deeper into the story regarding narration by asking, who is narrating and why is his/her perception important and how does tone and irony contribute to the characters. In this case, the tone and irony gives the reader a better understanding of each individual character, both antagonist and
“Wild Geese” is very different from many poems written. Oliver’s personal life, the free form of the poem along with the first line, “You do not have to be good,” and the imagery of nature contributes to Oliver’s intent to convince the audience that to be part of the world, a person does not need to aspire to civilization’s standards.
What is in a story if you can’t take something out of it and relate to your everyday life? The book “Typical American” by Gish Jen, gave me something that I never fully, and I probably still don’t, comprehend: foreigners, and their struggles in making a new life in another country. I have been on my share of trips, both domestic and abroad, but was never in a distant land long enough to feel the effects of the unknowing these people felt every day. The manner in which this story was presented has given me a new insight into, not only foreign nationals, but more importantly, how one goes about presenting emotional feeling not just through words, but setting, characterization, point of view, conflict, and theme.
This essay has compared the differences between the societies in these two novels. There is one great similarity however that both make me thankful for having been born into a freethinking society where a person can be truly free. Our present society may not be truly perfect, but as these two novels show, it could be worse.
In the beginning of both of the pieces of literature, the main character(s) have not had the experience that will shape their values yet. Rather, as time moves forward in the stories, the
The struggles both characters face demonstrate character development and contribute to the themes of the stories. Both short stories prove to be literally effective in that they disclose the main themes at the outset of each story. Although the themes may alter over the course of the stories, they are clearly defined in their respective introductions.
Step after step after step. After step. The heat is barren and the weight of this backpack is too much for these shoulders. Giving up is the only thing on this hiker’s mind. However, change is at the end of the journey, and a chance to start over and become someone new. While hiking, Cheryl Strayed said that, “It is impossible for you to go on as you were before, so you must go on as you never have.” Hair, clothes, personality, and people all change. Without it identity would be impossible to discover and talent would never be found. There have been many inspirational figures that have shown their hard journeys to become what they are. The most interesting one is about Cheryl Strayed. “Her mother’s death from cancer devastated Strayed, and