False Reality
The book, Fahrenheit 451 and the movie, V for Vendetta, have many similarities as well as differences when their dystopian societies are compared. For example, their governments and their people are similar. However, their protagonists and settings are very different. These factors affect the plot of each story, which makes them unique and enjoyable to many people.
The book, Fahrenheit 451, has a similar government to the movie, V for Vendetta. For example, they both have a totalitarian government. This means that the government has control of everything. The people in this government are under constant surveillance by the government. This shows in Fahrenheit 451 because the government has control over books. Firemen were created to burn books because they made people unhappy. In V for Vendetta, the government removed anything that was controversial, like the Quran. Homosexuality is also illegal in the movie due the strictness of its fascist leader. People were also removed if they spoke out or showed any dissent with the government. Clarisse was removed in the book because she showed signs of individuality and she was classified as antisocial. In the movie, V needed to be removed because he had a different idea of the
…show more content…
government than other people. Therefore, V died at the end of the movie, but his goals were accomplished. This brings me to the similarity of people in both stories. The people in V for Vendetta and the people in Fahrenheit 451 are very similar due to the fact they are both in a dehumanized state. Since they are in a totalitarian government, the citizens have to follow or keep up the expectations of the government in order to be kept from being eliminated by their leader. Both societies are not allowed to have certain items, because they give the citizens a chance to think for themselves, which is frowned upon in a totalitarian government. The citizens are not allowed to think for themselves because it gives people the chance to revolt if they know that the government is brainwashing them. In Fahrenheit 451, people are not allowed to have books and their shows have no point. Suicide is an often occurrence, so doctors don’t have to show up anymore. Therefore, death is not seen as anything important. The same goes for V for Vendetta, items, such as the Quran, are prohibited because people are supposed to think the same way. They are supposed to think that the government is good and anyone who goes against it, must be eliminated. Death is such an often occurrence that the people have become immune to it. When normal citizens died in V for Vendetta, society was impervious because it happened often. However, this bring me to the differences in each story. The protagonist in V for Vendetta, V, is very different than the protagonist in Fahrenheit 451, Montag. This is because Montag showed a lot of emotion compared to V. Montag, through reading the story, is a very expressive character. One could see that he was slightly insane because he could never seem to get his act together. He was always in denial about the government brainwashing him because he grew up with the mentality that the government had forced on him. As opposed to V, who was a very discreet person. This is because he wore a mask to hide his burnt face and didn’t say his name. Nobody knew who V really was, although, he was seen as a hero because he accomplished his goal of destroying parliament even though he had to die in order to achieve it. Montag could not help people realize that the government was brainwashing them, whereas V, helped most of the people in Britain realize that the government was corrupt and organized an event that everyone went to because they were fed up with the government. These differences are also impacted by the differences in the setting. These two stories have very different settings. Fahrenheit 451 was set in the United States in the twentieth century. Meanwhile, V for Vendetta was set in the twenty-first century in England, so there are obvious differences. In Fahrenheit 451, people live in cold, dark houses. This represents the people in the story because they are shown as cold, emotionless people. In V for Vendetta, the people live in apartments in the city. Secret places, like V’s den, shows the secrecy of people in the film. For example, Gordon’s house contained many forbidden items, which showed the secrecy of the people. As a result, the setting symbolizes the difference of these two stories. Overall, Fahrenheit 451 and V for Vendetta have many differences and similarities.
From their totalitarian government to their different people, these two works of art represent a society that most people, regardless of country, would not want to live in. Human beings are irrelevant and technology has taken over the lives of the people, so it is important that people should exercise their rights in order to avoid them being taken away. If we don’t exercise our rights, they’re going to be taken away. However, it is also important that we don’t take advantage of them in order to insult other people. We have a right to freedom of speech, but it does not mean that we should use it to divide people. We should use it to unite
people.
The issues the book readers in Fahrenheit 451 faced are very similar to some of the problems the Thirteen Colonies faced while under the reign of King George III. They were oppressed because of their differences, and the leaders of the times were always trying to intimidate people into resignation to their abuse. Faber and Montag's plan to plant books in the other firemen's houses as a plan to fix the discrimination is similar to how the Thirteen Colonies wrote the "Declaration of Independence"
In Fahrenheit 451, the government exercised censorship supposedly for the purpose of happiness. Through technology and media, the government was able to eliminate individuality by manipulating the mind of the people into believing the propaganda of what happiness is. The people’s ignorance made them obediently abide that they failed to realize how far technology and the media have taken control of their minds. The free thought of characters such as Montag and Clarisse collided with that of Captain Beatty, who strongly believe in and enforce the censorship, and the firemen, whose role was to burn illegal books; these clashes were Bradbury’s way
Today we have several dystopian novels out, such as; Divergent and The Hunger Games. While we know all the different societies we still have trouble trying to decide which one we believe the most, which one is the most realistic. There is older novels that most people really haven’t even heard of, like Fahrenheit 451. In Divergent and Fahrenheit 451 we were showed both authors visions of our future and how it compares to our modern day. There are so many ways that these two novels are alike, through characters, authors, and the time difference, but I believe that Fahrenheit 451 is a better overall view of our world today.
Are you really happy? Or are you sad about something? Sad about life or money, or your job? Any of these things you can be sad of. Most likely you feel discontentment a few times a day and you still call yourself happy. These are the questions that Guy Montag asks himself in the book Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury. In this book people are thinking they are happy with their lives. This is only because life is going so fast that they think they are but really there is things to be sad about. Montag has finally met Clarisse, the one person in his society that stops to smell the roses still. She is the one that gets him thinking about how his life really is sad and he was just moving too fast to see it. He realizes that he is sad about pretty much everything in his life and that the government tries to trick the people by listening to the parlor and the seashells. This is just to distract people from actual emotions. People are always in a hurry. They have 200 foot billboards for people driving because they are driving so fast that they need more time to see the advertisement. Now I am going to show you who are happy and not happy in the book and how our society today is also unhappy.
The theme of Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451 can be viewed from several different angles. First and foremost, Bradbury's novel gives an anti-censorship message. Bradbury understood censorship to be a natural outcropping of an overly tolerant society. Once one group objects to something someone has written, that book is modified and censorship begins. Soon, another minority group objects to something else in the book, and it is again edited until eventually the book is banned altogether. In Bradbury's novel, society has evolved to such an extreme that all literature is illegal to possess. No longer can books be read, not only because they might offend someone, but because books raise questions that often lead to revolutions and even anarchy. The intellectual thinking that arises from reading books can often be dangerous, and the government doesn't want to put up with this danger. Yet this philosophy, according to Bradbury, completely ignores the benefits of knowledge. Yes, knowledge can cause disharmony, but in many ways, knowledge of the past, which is recorded in books, can prevent man from making similar mistakes in the present and future.
“Remember when we had to actually do things back in 2015, when people barely had technology and everyday life was so difficult and different? When people read and thought and had passions, dreams, loves, and happiness?” This is what the people of the book Fahrenheit 451 were thinking, well that is if they thought at all or even remembered what life used to be like before society was changed.
“Revealing the truth is like lighting a match. It can bring light or it can set your world on fire” (Sydney Rogers). In other words revealing the truth hurts and it can either solve things or it can make them much worse. This quote relates to Fahrenheit 451 because Montag was hiding a huge book stash, and once he revealed it to his wife, Mildred everything went downhill. Our relationships are complete opposites. There are many differences between Fahrenheit 451 and our society, they just have a different way of seeing life.
The book Brave New World by Aldous Huxley and the movie V for Vendetta both take place in a dystopian future. Each one very different, but similar dystopian societies with many similar aspects such as luring citizens into false happiness, censoring citizens from different forms of literature, and characters who can really see behind the government’s façade and tell what is wrong with society. Similarity between the two ranges from meek things such as a similar setting with both societies residing in London, or more intricate things like similarities between the governments. Since the beginning of mankind humans have long since craved for a feeling of belonging and to be a part of something. Over the long history of mankind this same feeling has led to the growth of civilizations and societies. Eventually leading up to modern day societies with governments such as republics, dictatorships, and democracies. Each with its own different ways of
The theme of Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451 can be seen from several different viewpoints. Bradbury's novel primarily gives an anti-censorship message. Bradbury understood censorship to be a natural projection of an extremely tolerant society. The society envisioned by Bradbury in Fahrenheit 451 is often compared to Huxley's Brave New World, according to the researchers at novelguide.com. Though both works certainly have an anti-government theme, that is not the core idea of Bradbury's novel.
In Fahrenheit 451 Censorship play a big role in the story, Censorship is the act of changing or supp...
Often, dystopian novels are written by an author to convey a world that doesn’t exist, but criticizes aspects of the present that could lead to this future. Ray Bradbury wrote Fahrenheit 451 in 1951 but discusses issues that have only increased over time. The encompassing issue that leads to the dystopic nature of this novel is censorship of books. The government creates a world in which it is illegal to have any books. Firemen are enforcers of this law by being the ones to burn the books and burn the buildings where the books were found. By censoring the knowledge found in books, the government attempts to rid the society of corruption caused by “the lies” books are filled with in hopes the people will never question. In Fahrenheit 451, censorship is a paradox.
The North Korean government is known as authoritarian socialist; one-man dictatorship. North Korea could be considered a start of a dystopia. Dystopia is a community or society where people are unhappy and usually not treated fairly. This relates how Ray Bradbury's 1953 novel Fahrenheit 451 shows the readers how a lost of connections with people and think for themselves can lead to a corrupt and violent society known as a dystopia.
Fahrenheit 451’s Relevance to Today Fahrenheit 451’s relevance to today can be very detailed and prophetic when we take a deep look into our American society. Although we are not living in a communist setting with extreme war waging on, we have gained technologies similar to the ones Bradbury spoke of in Fahrenheit 451 and a stubborn civilization that holds an absence of the little things we should enjoy. Bradbury sees the future of America as a dystopia, yet we still hold problematic issues without the title of disaster, as it is well hidden under our democracy today. Fahrenheit 451 is much like our world today, which includes television, the loss of free speech, and the loss of the education and use of books. Patai explains that Bradbury saw that people would soon be controlled by the television and saw it as the creators chance to “replace lived experience” (Patai 2).
The Hunger Games and Fahrenheit 451 are both great examples of dystopian fiction. A dystopia is a fictional world that takes place in the future that is supposed to be perceived as a perfect society, but it’s actually the opposite. Other things that a dystopian society might display are citizens both living in a dehumanized state and feeling like they’re constantly watched by a higher power. Dystopias are places where society is backwards or unfair, and they are usually are controlled by the government, technology, or a particular religion. The Hunger Games and Fahrenheit 451 are both in the dystopian fiction genre because the societies within them show the traits of a dystopia. Both of them also have characters that go against the flow of the normal world.
The one main similarity and difference that goes hand in hand is what makes them dystopian. In both books the main characters, Winston Smith and Guy Montag, experience having to submit to their government’s rules and eventually not being able to do so anymore and going against the most enforced rule. Winston, character of 1984, wrote and thought against dystopian leader Big Brother which lead to mental, emotional, and physical manipulation to get him to not only follow but love Big Brother. Guy , character of Fahrenheit 451, on the other hand, did not write against his political leader, but read against him