Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Elizabethan era influence on shakespeare
Elizabethan era influence on shakespeare
Critical overview of Romeo and Juliet
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Romeo and Juliet tragedy of fate or tragedy of flaw? Romeo and Juliet is a story about forbidden love by a prodigious writer named William Shakespeare. This is a highly controversial story, some people say that the ending of the Romeo and Juliet’s story was tragedy of fate. Fate is when forces outside of your control makes certain things happen, good or bad, but usually when you think of fate you think good. For an example, you are sitting in your new classroom for the first time, and you meet someone and they will turn out to be your husband in the future. Some other people might think a little bit differently. Some people say the story of Romeo and Juliet was a tragedy of flaw. Flaw is a sign of weakness or defect, also can be a problem …show more content…
that directly affects someone's actions and abilities. For an example a person may have a major temper problem which is a flaw.
In Romeo and Juliet I think there is a little bit of both flaw and fate, but I think it is mostly flawed.
Both Romeo and Juliet are responsible for both of them being dead and it is a flaw. Romeo and Juliet live in two different worlds. Romeo is a Montague and Juliet is a Capulet. Both families do not like each other. So from the beginning that was the first flaw that they both had. Juliet could have done a lot instead of doing half of the things she did. Juliet's tragic flaw is her loyalty to Romeo. Juliet was a Capulet and a conscientious child. She was shy and loyal in the beginning of the play/story. “Well, do not swear. Although I joy in thee,I have no joy of this contract tonight.It is too rash, too unadvised, too sudden,Too like the lightning, which doth cease to be Ere one can say 'It lightens.' Sweet, good night.This bud of love, by summer's ripening breath, May prove a beauteous flower when next we meet.Good night, good night. As sweet repose and rest Come to thy heart as that within my breast.” In this quote she is saying how much she loves Romeo, but she thinks it is
…show more content…
going a little too fast. But that obviously did not stop Juliet. She could not fluctuate between her love for Romeo to her own family the Capulet's. She should have decided from the beginning to follow her family by marrying Paris. But instead she marries Romeo, and was as happy as she could be. But what she did know is that could bring both of them to something bad. They widened the gap of both Capulet's and Montague's never liking each other since Romeo murdered her cousin Paris, due to the murder of his friend Mercutio. Once things started to get worse, she thought the best plan was for her to take a sleeping potion from Friar Lawrence to make her appear that she was dead. That plan scared her and could have killed her but she didn't want to end up marrying Paris. In her mind that was the only way to still be with Romeo and not marry Paris. Her loyalty was her strength, but it was also led to her afterlife.But it didnt just led to her afterlife it ended to Romeo’s to. Romeo's tragic flaw is his defiance, his rashness of action before thinking through things thoroughly. In the beginning of the play Romeo was in love with a girl named Rosaline, but she didn't love him back. Soon later he was falling in "love" with Juliet within minutes of meeting her, even after finding out that she was a Capulet. He Forgot all about Rosaline after meeting Juliet, though he had been depressed for weeks due to his unreturned love. Romeo should have thought about what he was getting himself into, but it never crossed his mind that maybe he should not associate with Juliet considering she is a capulet. Romeo wanted to see Juliet after the ball was over, but Montagues are not allowed in the Capulet's house. Romeo should have stayed with his friends and when home but instead he left his friends after the Capulet ball and climbed back into the Capulet compound, where he could have be killed if discovered. Once he sneaked into the Capulet's house to see Juliet he swore his love to Juliet and asked her to marry him. After that he killed 2 people which got him banned for life. Romeo left Verona and went to Mantua. He heard the Juliet was “dead”. Romeo doesn't think before he continues to do something, so his first plan was to go to an apothecary (An apothecary is a person who prepared and sold medicines and drugs). He sold everything of his just for a potion that killed him. He Killed Paris once he got back to Verona without even knowing who he was. Paris had come to the Capulet tomb to innocently place flowers for his ‘dead’ fiance. He thought that Romeo was there to defile the crypt. Killing himself though he should have realized that Juliet was alive. After two days, Juliet should not have still had rosy lips and supple flesh. Romeo notices this, but cannot figure out that she must be alive. He rashly poisons himself though she awakened within minutes.”O my love, my wife!Death, that hath sucked the honey of thy breath,Hath had no power yet upon thy beauty.Thou art not conquered. Beauty’s ensign yet Is crimson in thy lips and in thy cheeks, And death’s pale flag is not advancèd there.” Shortly after he kills himself and come to find out Juliet was actually dead. Romeo’s saw that every decision he made had a consequence that came along with it.
He was too hasty in almost every one of his choices throughout the play. For example, he was too quick in marrying Juliet. After that, he chose not to think before killing Tybalt, which is the action that led him on a downward spiral from which he would never recover. When he killed Tybalt, he was once again acting on his impulses. This time, however, his impulse was one of anger, hatred, and rage. In a duel that was to prove his greatest mistake, he killed Tybalt. Because of his choice to murder this man, he was exiled from Verona.Juliet's had a lot of loyalty to Romeo. This flaw is a good flaw to a point; however, it becomes the reason she dies in the end. She cannot live without Romeo, so she takes her own life so that she'll never love or marry another.Juliet became upset and went to the Friar for help, resulting in the mistakes that led to their deaths being made.The play begins with the Prologue, and that is where it tells us of their fate. "Two star-crossed lovers take their life." That theme is present throughout all of William Shakespeare's play. Any mentioning of the stars refers to fate and what has already been decided. It's as if the characters have no control over their lives or over their decisions and actions. They must accept their fate because they can do nothing to alter
it.I
Fate can be defined as being “a power that determines and controls everything that is or happens,” (Newfeldt (Ed.) p.431) while destiny can be described as “what is predetermined to happen in spite of all efforts to change or prevent it.” (Newfeldt (Ed.) p.321) Therefore, fate is the entity that decides all that will occur, and destiny is the decision made by fate. Tragedy can be defined as the dramatic representation of serious and important actions that turn out disastrously for the main character. This indicates that the tragedies in Romeo and Juliet were the deaths of Romeo and Juliet, and to say fate and destiny were not responsible for these tragedies, is to say the characters of the play, rather than some intangible force, were aware and in control of the actions that caused Romeo’s and Juliet’s
In the play Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare, all the choices made by the star crossed lovers have consequences. The two lovers blame fate for their misfortune. They refuse to believe that fate does not determine the end result, only that they can do that. At the beginning of the play, Romeo is presented with a plethora of choices. The audience is introduced to Romeo as he sulks over his lover Rosaline.
Because of the time this play was written, people would have strongly believed in bad luck and fate, but the characters were equally to blame. It was just a question of which one is to blame the most for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. First of all, Romeo could be most to blame for the deaths of himself and Juliet, he asked Juliet to marry him when he hardly knew her. Romeo declared his love for her and went to friar Lawrence and asked the friar if he would marry them, Romeo says "Then plainly know my hearts dear love is set, on the fair daughter of rich Capulet, by holy marriage, when, where and how, we met, we woo'd and make exchange of vow. " If Romeo had restrained himself from killing Tybalt, or waited a day before killing himself after hearing about Juliet's death, it might have ended happily, and if Romeo didn't have such deep feelings, his love with Juliet wouldn't have existed in the first place.
Some people may not believe that destiny is something that truthfully exists in the world. These people doubt that there is anything that is actually meant to be, or supposed to happen, thinking that there is always a way around troubling predicaments, knowing that it is not necessary to turn out just one certain way. They trust that whatever occurs in their lives comes as a result of the decisions that they make with their own free will. Others believe that whatever happens during the course of their lives is inevitable and every event is laid out before them like a road map to life, in other words, fate. William Shakespeare's play, Romeo and Juliet has fate as an exceptionally crucial element which makes fate as important as any character in the production. The events leading up to and during the party were definitely caused by fate. The moment that Romeo and Juliet meet is the exact incident that leads to their death, however unaware these "star-crossed lovers" are to that fact. Thus, fate is undoubtedly the most responsible influence for the couple's tragedy.
Romeo’s decisions are rash and incoherent. Due to desire, Romeo is in love again, fooled by the charms of a pretty face and is willing to take any risk to see the love of his life. After meeting Juliet, daughter of mighty Capulet, in a ball he was not even supposed to attend he chooses, after their separation, to go back to her because he feels incomplete. Just the fact that he chose to jump over the Capulet’s wall was a bad decision in itself. If he had been caught by a Capulet or the guards he would surely have been killed and he would have all these risks for nothing. His impulsiveness leads him to take an important decision without first thinking of the consequences his actions could have caused. “I take thee at thy word. / Call me but love, and I’ll be new baptized. / Hen...
Immediately after Romeo hears of Juliet’s death, he makes the major decision of killing himself in a very short amount of time. Once he makes his choice, he does not spend enough time considering what he should do, and so he is not thinking clearly about what exactly he is doing and how it affects not only him, but the people around him. After Romeo kills himself, Juliet awakens to find him dead, which leads her to kill herself. By choosing to die, Romeo not only kills himself, but also Juliet because he did not use his time to think about his actions.
Romeo is an extremely impulsive individual. Throughout the drama, Romeo makes decisions without considering the consequences. His mistakes bring about several complications that eventually lead to his untimely death. From the beginning of the novel, Romeo continuously falls in love with different people. The first Act of the play portrays an ardent love for the gorgeous Rosaline who refuses to love him. Romeo's maudlin behavior is a concern to his friends, who decide to take him to the Capulet's masquerade party. Here, Juliet's beauty strikes Romeo and his previous love for Rosaline instantaneously diminishes. After the party, Romeo encounters Juliet and makes the impulsive decision of promising to marry her. Romeo recounts the story of his newfound love and the desire to marry her, to his adviser, Friar Lawrence, and seeks his advice. The Friar explains that, "Young men's love then lies/ not truly in their hearts, but in their eyes" (89). The Friar tries to convince Romeo that his love is not true, for he hastily changes his mind about the love of his life. But Romeo does not change his mind and is wed with Juliet. Romeo is also quite brash in his decision to slay Tybalt. If Romeo considered the consequences of murdering his enemy, he could have prevented his banishment from Verona. Romeo fails to consider that there is no need to slay Tybalt because Tybalt is already headed for assassination due to the fact that he started a fray and murdered Mecrutio. Unfortunately, his impulsiveness overpowers him and Romeo fights Tybalt. If only Romeo had thought rationally, he would not be separated from his dear, sweet Juliet. His banishment causes Romeo to cry out with extreme anguish to the Friar, "Hence 'banished' is 'banished from the world,' / And worlds exile is death.
The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare Romeo and Juliet is a tragedy mainly because of the downfall of the main characters through weakness or misfortune, which lead to their deaths but these flaws are not the only reasons for this tragedy, it is possible that their fate was “written in the stars” as there are many references made about these stars. Fate (the fact that life is already planned out and is out of human control) must be one of the key factors in causing the tragedy of the “star-crossed lovers” Romeo and Juliet. It is possible that there was “some consequence yet hanging in the stars”(I iv) that already had their lives scripted down and no matter how much Romeo wanted to defy them “I defy you stars”(I, vi) he could not. This must mean that Romeo’s life was already planned out. But fate was not only interpreted in the stars, somehow it seemed that some of the characters foreshadowed their own fate, like Friar Lawrence foreshadowed “love so gentle in [Romeo’s] view, should be so tyrannous in proof”(I, I), this meaning that Romeo may see the love he has now, as wonderful, but as it continues it causes trouble.
Just as the Friar says in the beginning of the Shakespeare play, Romeo and Juliet, “Wisely and slowly, they stumble that run fast.” (II.iii.94). this was a sign of foreshadowing for for the death of the lovers, Romeo and Juliet. Even though fate was a factor that had contributed to a tragic end, there was also personal choice involved, and ultimately, the story may have had a different ending if it weren’t for the flaws of the lovers and their inability to have a grip on reality in dire circumstances. Over the course of the play, the lovers from the conflicting households have not matured and remain rather static in development. Furthermore, in this tragedy, the only son of the montages remains rather childlike, Juliet still seems immature and their relationship over all seems more like a play act on lover rather then something mature and sustainable. Overall, from start to finish, Romeo and Juliet were living in the moment, being absurd and silly rather then focusing on the future and trying to work problems out effectively.
...t on the spot, and are too immature. Romeo and Juliet’s spring of blind love quickly deepens and causes them to face situation that they have never faced before. They do not know how to handle their bizarre complications, as the story takes a quick, unpredicted turn and turns into a nightmare for them. Romeo and Juliet are forced to make rash decisions one after the other and do not consider the possible solutions other than suicide, causing them to look up to suicide as their only hope. Their bizarre complications are caused by their blind, immature, and excessive love and their act of taking their own lives is also caused by immaturity, idolatry for each other, and the shortness of time. Romeo and Juliet suicide at the end of the story, due to the shortness of time and the extremity of their love; they believe that they have no other options, other than suicide.
After Romeo is misled about his beloved Juliet 's death, he desperately finds for "a rainstiff wretch [who] would sell [the poison to] him"(V.ii.35). This demonstrates his immaturity and youthfulness as he were guided by his emotions instead of rational thinking. Because his heart was torn with sorrow, he was not able to make a sagacious decision taking into account the subject carefully. Romeo could have waited for Friar Laurence 's message to come as Friar told him he will contrive a clandestine plan to resolve the problem between Romeo and Juliet. It was his choice alone to kill himself, no one forced him to do it. If Romeo would had kept it together and mourned properly, he would have lived happily with Juliet. Furthermore, Juliet also decides to take the same action. Instead of searching for a new way of living, she hoped for "some poison yet doth hang on [Romeo]/ to make [her] die with a restorative"(V.iii.163-167). This clearly illustrates how they used the power of decision making unwisely. Juliet was too indiscreet to disobey her parents and follow her lover who she knew only for a couple of days. Both of these characters did not recognize the power of love and caused a self destructive violence. Romeo 's tragic flow was proved to be fatal when he was unable to see the consequences of his decisions. His downfall spiral was determined
Romeo has taken the poison, which caused instant death, and Juliet had awoke and seen Romeo, she took his dagger and killed her self. I believe that Shakespeare wanted the audience to believe that fate was to blame and no matter what choices the characters made fate would always have intervened and the outcome would have been just as tragic. This is because this fits in with the major influence of the time, during the Elizabethan period the theme of fate and Greece god’s where what they believed and where influenced by.
“Feather of lead, bright smoke, cold fire, sick health, still-waking sleep, that is not what this is” (Shakespeare 1.1. 179-180). A string of contradictions explain the love story of Romeo and Juliet, a contradiction. Some critics consider this story a tragedy because Shakespeare once wrote; “the fault is not in our stars but in ourselves”. While others say it does not follow the standard Aristotelian form of tragedy (Krims 1). Romeo and Juliet can not be a tragedy because no flaw causes them to fall, the lovers, could not have controlled fate, and family and friends assisted them to their deaths.
Romeo had a few character flaws that helped cause this. One of these was him going to the dance. If he had never gone to that dance then he would have never met Juliet, meaning the tragedy would have never happened. Juliet's father also had a character flaw that tied into this, he let Romeo stay after Tybalt told him that there was Romeo there who is a Montague. If he had listened to Tybalt then Romeo would have not met Juliet. Another one of Romeo's character flaws was a lot later in the story. He was told that Juliet had died and he rushed to her tomb. When he got there he said to himself that she did not look dead because she was not really pale and still had a reddish tint to her cheeks. If he would have been more observant he could have known that she did not actually die and that would have prevented the death of him and Juliet. Juliet also had some character flaws. One of them was her wanting to marry Romeo. She knew that she was not supposed to marry anyone from the Montague family because of the big feud. She ended up getting married to him despite the feud among the families. This marriage was where the Friar messed up. He should not have agreed to secretly get Romeo and Juliet married, he could have just told them no. Instead he got them married
To a great extent, the misfortunes in Romeo and Juliet occur as a consequence of fate, which controls both luck and disaster. ...