Comparing The Past In Beloved And The Selected Poems Of Paul Laurence Dunbar

1943 Words4 Pages

The theme of the past is a key aspect of 'Beloved' and the 'Selected Poems of Paul Laurence Dunbar' as the narrators, in both texts, have a nostalgic perception of the many years that have passed, whether the memories are pleasant or grim they are reflected upon with – at the very least – a hint of admiration alongside a deep longing to return to the past. Similarly, in Arthur Miller's 'Death of a Salesman', the tragic hero, Willy Loman, is also constantly drifting back into the past to when his sons were ambitious young men and he was a successful businessman. 'Beloved' was set after the American Civil War in 1873, where many black people were heavily mistreated and suffered long and gruelling years of slavery. The novel was written in 1987, …show more content…

Likewise, Paul D confined his emotions and memories of his sufferings into the 'tobacco tin lodged in his chest' which was so tightly 'rusted' shut that nothing 'could pry it open'. Morrison uses this metaphor to describe what Paul D's 'red heart' decayed into; an old rusty tobacco tin is not of interest to anyone and the fact that it was ‘lodged’ into place conveys that as the heart was failing, anything else that was lying around was carelessly shoved in its place. This portrays how no one, including himself, cared about what he was holding onto – whether he was emotionally scarred or not, was of nobody's concern – as the expectation of the time was to just deal with what you had to endure and get on with life with what you had, or decline into madness like Halle, Aunt Phyllis, and Jackson Till; who all turned mad and underwent, according to a critic, ‘A complete loss of self’. The tobacco tin could also play a part in a metaphor; like burning the trapped contents of the rusty box, Paul D smoulders the memories he has until they are hazy like the smoke from the tobacco – the intention is to make the harsh memories less painful to reflect upon or easier to escape from. In contrary, the rhyme scheme of ‘A Drowsy Day’ is ABCCBA, which portrays how the narrator is constantly trapped in their own …show more content…

The poem is centred on a man who sombrely wishes he could go back in time questioning 'could events be changed?' The man is left with a mixture of sweet and tragic memories, recalling how he felt at each moment in time and describes them as 'not so joyous' for reflecting upon them only brings him 'pain' and 'grief' whereas when he was living the moment, he was elated with happiness. The narrator is used to portray the regret and yearning to make amends in the past with the woman whom he loved and ended up losing due to fame – this may reflect Paul Laurence Dunbar’s relationship with his wife whom he divorced in 1902. However, this is also a depiction of human nature and how almost everyone wishes things had turned out differently in their life as everyone longs to go back and alter their mistakes, but these wishes are in 'vain' as whatever hopes and dreams – in the context of ‘Beloved’ it would be wishes of freedom and lost loved ones – they have at the time 'may not be' the same anymore. Similarly in 'Death of a Salesman', Biff longs to have done more studying in high school so he wouldn't have 'flunked' his maths test, thus tarnishing his chances of entering university. All three writers use their characters to show the audience that they should make the most of their opportunities or they will spend the rest of their years

Open Document