Han and Rome were two of the greatest empires in the ancient world. But all great empires have great falls. The Han dynasty fell in 220 C.E., and Rome fell in 476 C.E. There are several contributing factors that tipped them over the edge. Three of those factors are: difficulty in collecting taxes, invasions, and government problems. Difficulty in collecting taxes are a big contributing factor to the fall of both the Han Dynasty and Rome Empire. Rome couldn’t collect taxes from the upper classes because they made their own fiefs. Rome really needed the tax money to pay for their army and all their wars. Because of the shortage of people and funds the roman army was dwindling. To fix this they hired barbarians. The only problem with this is the barbarians weren't …show more content…
always loyal to Rome. Similarly, the Han Dynasty had problems collecting taxes. Farms were getting smaller because of fathers splitting the inherence between their sons so the lower class would hide from tax collectors. Some of the upper classes would also refuse to pay their taxes. The lack of tax money caused the Han Dynasty to have a weaker government and army. Both of these empires reacted differently, the Han didn’t do anything about the military problem. Rome on the other hand tried to compromise by hiring barbaric mercenaries. These small events escalated in each empire when they faced outside threats. Invasions were a big contribution to the fall of the Roman Empire and Han Dynasty.
Rome was having problems with invasions, but having much of their army composed of barbarian mercenaries caused problems because the same people that fought with Rome, would then fight against Rome. Different barbaric tribes slowly encroached on Rome and took more and more of Rome's territory until they took the city Rome, the capital of the Roman Empire. The barbaric tribes eventually took over all of western Rome. In Han Dynasty the raids and revolts greatly influenced how it fell in the end. Invaders and revolts didn’t completely take over china like they took over western Rome, instead the slowly picked away at the Han Dynasty's economy. It took the government 21 years to get rid of the yellow turban rebellion, in that time the yellow turban rebellion ransacked and destroyed government offices while forcing the imperial armies onto the defensive. For over 200 years China fought with the Xiongnu, this fighting disrupted a portion of the silk road which was a main way of transportation and trade to the other Han cites. The Han finally defeated the Xiongnu, but in doing so they destabilized the Han
government. Corrupt government had a big part in why Han and Rome fell. Part of Rome's government problems were because they kept changing emperors. When Rome was on its decline, over 20 men became emperor in only 75 years. Also, The Praetorian Guard killed and installed new rulers at will. The Roman citizens started to lose national pride and distrust their government. The spread of Christianity led to people seeing God as more important than the Emperor. Churches started having more power over the people than the ruler. To add to this Rome's economy was put at a disbalance as churches and church officials were exempt from taxes. Han Dynasty had a corrupt government which eventually led to its citizens not trusting the government and the fall of the empire. Han Dynasty's government was corrupt, with emperors who lived only for amusement. The warlord Dong Zhuo assassinated the 13-year-old Emperor Shao, and appointing Shao's younger brother as ruler instead. People didn’t want to pay taxes to a government they didn’t trust.
Han civilization declined for two reasons, internal dispute and foreign invasions. In the empire bureaucrats were competing for power and this caused crime to happen. Landowners rebelled against paying taxes witch caused peasants taxes to increase, landowners started privately making armies, and farmers were forced into enslavement. A clear sign of the collapse in the central state was
The Han Dynasty and Roman Empire existed around the same time period and both lasted around 400 years. They each had large populations (around 50 million), conquered enemies they felt as a threat, wanted to spread their boundaries and had strong militaries. The Han Dynasty, located in China, was built on other dynasties such as the Qin and Zhou. The Great Wall of China was built during
The Roman empire was a very large and successful empire, although like many things it had to come to an end. The three primary reasons that had most contributed to Rome's fall is foreign invasions, military weakness , and weak leadership.
Rome was once one of the world's greatest empire until around 200 BCE when Rome started to crumble. The Fall of Rome did not happen suddenly, it took about 1100 years to take place. The first two centuries as an empire were named the "Pax Romana", which meant the time of Roman peace. The Romans were living the life, without a worry in the world. So how and why did Rome start to collapse, if the empire was was doing so grand and magnificent? To answer that question, the primary reasons that Rome started to decline were that the Romans had difficulty with their government which caused social problems/decay, their military was falling behind on their duties and became indolent, and natural disasters.
Both Han China and Rome had to deal with a weakening government, which in both cases led to landlords ruling over the peasants. The landlords' demands were added to the heavy taxes peasants also had to pay, leading to extreme poverty. The two civilizations faced declining cultural innovation, caused by scholars not creating
The Han Dynasty and the Roman Empire were two grand empires that rose out of preexisting territories and provided relative peace over wide areas. The collapse of the Qin Dynasty (221-206 BCE), which was the first great land-based empire in East Asia, came after a period of war, confusion, and tyrannical rule. Due to the political disorder that stemmed from the early dynastic activity, the emergence of the Han Dynasty (206 BCE- 228 CE) sprung to focus on restoring order. On the other hand, the rise of the Roman Empire (44 BCE- 476 CE) originated from consolidating authority over aristocratic landlords and overriding the democratic elements of the earlier Republic. Instead, the Roman Empire redefined the concept of “citizen” as subjects to the Roman emperor. Both empires shared similar agendas to exploit their vast territories and resources, which helped them expand their political dominance; however, despite having similar political goals and foundations, their government system, cultural ideologies and imperial expansionist natures diverged.
When comparing different societies in ancient history you may not think that Han China and Ancient Rome had a lot in common. These two great societies had many similarities and differences, especially in their social structures. These similarities and differences are all due to Han China’s and Ancient Rome’s governments, family structures and religions. Both of these wonderful empires lasted for approximately 400 years and had lasting effects on the lands they conquered.
The Classical Era was a time of greatness. Great empires rose to power, the likes of which the world had never seen before. In the west, Rome emerged as the dominant power. Originating in the Italian peninsula, the Roman Empire would eventually stretch from Britain to Mesopotamia and Egypt, a huge empire maintained through a vast network of roads. This empire was made of hundreds of different cultures. In the east, the Han dynasty ruled China, Vietnam, and northern Korea. Han China was united not only by government, but also by culture. Confucianism, a belief system focused on maintaining order, was extremely influential, as was another belief system called Daoism, to a lesser extent. During the Classical Age, the creation of powerful empires allowed for safer trade. Safer trade allowed huge amounts of cross-cultural interaction, trade and the sharing of ideas. But as other empires had done before, and as many did after, the empires of Rome and Han China fell. Rome and Han China had both similarities and differences. The most important similarity was plagues and diseases, and the most important difference was the destruction of culture.
The Han dynasty and the Roman Empire were both powerful empires during their era. However, the ways they obtained their power varied greatly because they used different methods that involved their political structures, which revolved around their centralized governments. The Han dynasty and the Roman Empire acquired very unique techniques that allowed them to control social and political. For example, the Han dynasty adopted a religion known as Confucianism, which monitored everything in the lives of the Chinese. Contrary, the Roman Empire established a monarchy but allowed its residents more freedom as compared to the Han. Nevertheless, the two empires were similar in political structures in that the power was depended on the wealthy that were in authority, the peasants struggled with their lives because of concerning issues such as food supply. The empires were able to create and preserve a peaceful and sustainable lives for a long time, unlike the past empires. Social distribution were under the control of the wealthiest and they could effortlessly impact community viewpoints and interactions among the residents. These two empires existed during the Classical Period had comparable and various social, political, religions, as well as economical values and practices. However, they both possessed differences and similarities in their economic and social perspectives even though the two empires were established around the same era.
Now you are probably wondering with all these similar factors that lead to the demise of the empires, how did China recover successfully? The Chinese empire unlike the Roman empire, held on to their cultural identity and tried not to accept diversity in cultures. This is also called cultural homogeneity. Cultural homogeneity create a sense of togetherness. This creates less organization and religious drama. China also had more advanced technological breakthroughs in the fields of agriculture and metallurgy. This is needed to progress and recover so you have ways of keeping up with the economy. The Chinese empire also had one common religion that mostly held up. Confucianism. Having mostly the same religion unifies most people, which is also needed for a recovery. With these main factors, the Chinese empire recovered successfully.
Because Rome had grown massively, the government had to inflate many prices and impose mass taxation to pay
The Han Dynasty governed China for more than four hundred years. It rose to power in 206 BC and stayed until 220 AC. The Han Dynasty played a vital role in China’s development. This dynasty pioneered a political system and social structure that lasted in China for almost 2,000 years. The Han Dynasty and the Roman Empire were considered two of the most strongest civilizations at that time. The Roman Empire lasted from 27 BC to 393 AD. This empire changed the way Romans lived. The Romans made rapid advancements in science and technology. Both of these civilizations successfully took control of their countries. While they both have an abundant amount of similarities, they is an overwhelming amount of differences that set these two empires apart. The decline of these two civilizations were both caused by internal affairs. The Han Dynasty and the Roman Empire both ruled close to the same time span, they both had highly centralized political systems, and they both were the most advanced civilizations in their region of the world. Their similarities did not overshadow their differences however. The Roman Empire had a senate that served as their legislative body and in China, the emperors ruled over the city. The Han Dynasty implemented national equality, and used Confucianism thoughts to keep the country united, while the Romans divided their citizens into different social classes and kept ethic discrimination. While both civilizations had strong social class separators, the Roman Empire made their’s more apparent. Both civilizations were strong and advanced for their time, however, they both ruled their countries differently.
The collapse of the Han Dynasty made a huge impact in history. The fall of Han Dynasty was from internal dissent, which indicates the chaos between the European countries. Once the end of the first century B.C.E. arrived, several local families gained
All empires must come to an end. The Mongols, Ottomans, and Holy Roman Empires all don’t exist anymore. Even, the United Stated of America will come to its end in one point in time. Everything that goes up must come down. Even, Rome, one of the world’s greatest civilizations. To summarize, The Roman Empire fell because of ineffective leaders, the crumbling economy, and invasions by the Germanic Tribes.
Collecting taxes becomes harder, thus causing the economy to decline. This inevitably made it easy for the Germanic tribes to invade the Mediterranean. Constantine and Diocletian slowed down the rate of decline in Rome by allowing Christianity, trying to improve tax collection, and the creation of a second capitol in Constantinople. This only sped up the rate of decline in the western half of the empire, but strengthening the eastern half. The only surviving portion of the empire was now known as the Byzantine Empire with its capitol Constantinople.