Drummer Hodge' by Thomas Hardy

834 Words2 Pages

Drummer Hodge' by Thomas Hardy

Drummers were usually the very youngest of soldiers and were

considered to be too young to fight. This instantly sets a very sombre

tone as the reader realises the soldier was very young when he died.

The word 'Hodge' is used to describe him and was once used as a

derogatory term for a farm labourer however Hardy means no disrespect

as he has openly showed his admiration for countrymen. This term is

merely one of many techniques used to emphasis how foreign the Drummer

is.

'A Dead Boche' by Robert Graves describes an encounter with a dead

"Boche"; the word boche was an offensive term for a German. These two

poems are instantly different as one is written about a fellow

Englishman whilst the other is written about an enemy.

The first stanza in 'Drummer Hodge' shows the horror of the soldier's

death and burial in a strange land:

"They throw in Drummer Hodge, to rest

Uncoffined - just as found

His landmark is a kopje-crest"

The word "throw" shows how disrespectful Hodge's burial is, he is not

lowered with dignity or given a proper military burial as he should be

entitled to. He is not even placed in a coffin and is buried "just as

found" making him sound more like an object than a person. The

Afrikaans words "kopje-crest" and "veldt" emphasise the foreignness of

Hodge's resting place, which is also highlighted again by the

reference to the "foreign constellations" that will rise nightly over

his grave. Graves' poem contrasts with this as it focuses more on how

the German visually looks and doesn't evoke the emotional feeling that

is brought about by the alienation in Hardy's poem. Gr...

... middle of paper ...

...indifference

and immunity to the horrors as he describes the dead German in a

cynical and matter-of-fact way.

It could be seen that Hardy describes the death of the soldier in an

idealised way. The imagery of stars and resting with the

constellations over the soldier is aromantic and pleasant way to be.

However his protagonist is a young boy who dies away from his home,

who will forever be under a sky he doesn't know and will eventually go

on to nourish the people he was fighting against. This seems to be

very realistic and cynical. Graves describes the dead German with very

simple and visual adjectives which instantly conjure up images in the

reader's mind. His view of the dead soldier could be seen as realistic

yet his tone, especially in the first stanza, suggests a cynicism that

makes his poem seem traumatic.

Open Document