Disadvantages Of Community Based Tourism

1621 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Impacts tourism has on the local community

Precisely, the problems of land repayment contribute to the poor affiliation of local people living next to declared protected areas (Ormsby & Mannie, 2006; Brousse-James, 2009; de Koning & Marais, 2009). Associations between the local communities and conservation agencies are stressed due to the exclusion of native communities from decision-making in the management programmes of protected areas. Some of these stressed relations comprise the awareness of various meanings and disagreements based on the role of communities in conserving biodiversity, in addition, the relationship about what have been known as community tourism (Evans, Campbell & Stonehouse, 2003; Adam & Hutton, 2012).
Local communities are directly affected by any form of activities …show more content…

But then again without a financial and commercial commitment by local peoples, the community partnership strategy might be ineffective. Even though community-based tourism projects may be in small scale, a combined tourism industry favours larger units. Community-based natural resource management (CBNRM) is a way for societies to labour together to protect their natural resources and simultaneously bring long-lasting benefits to the community (DEAT 2003:11).
Participatory methods have progressed towards community-based tourism processes, for instance social tourism and pro-poor tourism, which both aim at tourism practices that contribute to the local societies, more particularly the needs of the poor, marginalised people, community members and groups (Duffy, 2002:100-102; Scheyvens, 2002). Conservation agencies need to join services with the communities to clarify and involve the structures and processes driving the social and environmental variations they regard as …show more content…

Though local participation in nature conservation, after periods of negligence and misuse, cannot promise immediate and fruitful benefits in the short term.
The concept of a participatory community-conservation approach does not only have been fully considered in the context, it is the main objective of this study to find answers for some unclear questions, and to examine the partnership between local communities and protected areas. Community involvement in development hard work differs according to segments of the economy in a country and main local conditions under which the community involvement will be practised (Tosun, 2000; Timothy & Tosun,

Show More
Related

  • Proposed Territory of the South Okanagan- Similkameen National Park Reserve

    1535 Words  | 4 Pages

    ...ble role both as the destinations of nature conservation and recreation and tourism (e.g. Runte 1997; Mels 1999; Boyd & Butler 2000; Rytteri & Puhakka 2009). The dual designation means that ecological priorities are addressed along with the stakeholders rights to benefit from the land. This dualism has become integral to the Finnish in that regional development is increasingly brought up in park plans. 5(The idea that national parks should be integrated more deeply into the regional tourism economy while keeping conservation goals which are consistent with the EU regulations and other international agreements(Saarinen 2007) has helped arbitrate stakeholder discourse.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Sand County Almanac By Aldo Leopold

    637 Words  | 2 Pages

    Our system today is inherently opposed to developing a relationship with the land because it depends on evidence in terms of monetary worth. “One basic weakness in a conservationist system based wholly on economic motives is that most members of the land community have no economic value” (246). How much is a wildflower or a songbird worth? Therefore, this infinitely complex ecological system, which depends upon an unforeseeable amount of community-shaping mechanisms, tends to become increasingly diseased. “It tends to ignore, and thus eventually to eliminate, many elements in the land community that lack commercial values, but that are (as we know) essential to its healthy functioning” (252).

    Read More

  • Agricultural and Rural Society After the Black Death

    1519 Words  | 4 Pages

    ...at small farms constitute 90 percent of the world’s farms and employment of 1.3 billion people. This dominates agriculture in developing countries because two-thirds of the 3 billion rural people in the world live off the income generated by farmers managing some 500 million small farms (Halberg & Müller, 2012, p.21). Additionally, there are benefits to land conservation for local communities that involves reduced environmental hazards, improvement of water quality from ground recharge, economic gains from agricultural production from exporting, and the natural settings that bring tourism generating the economy (McMahon & Urban, 2010 p.2). It is only through the awareness of this informational insight into the differences between community types and their transitions throughout time that the public can explore and discover economic incentives for rural communities.

    Read More

  • North Texas Nature Reserve

    657 Words  | 2 Pages

    According to the IBO, conservation is the sustainable usage of natural resources and preservation is the exclusion of human activity in places not yet infiltrated. One way to ensure the conservation of biodiversity is through habitat conservation. Designing protected areas allows the natural fauna and flora to flourish. However, questions such as these should be asked when creating a protected area: What’s the ideal shape for the reserve? Should the entire reserve be one or should there be separate areas? How close to human society should this reserve be?

    Read More

  • Northern Quoll Case Study

    806 Words  | 2 Pages

    Although the assessment displayed many threats, this project will address only one causal chain: of the inefficiency of co-management agreement in the park. The contributing factors for this direct threat are first, the lack of revision of the agreement since 1991. The last stage of the co-management agreement inside of Kakadu National park was signed 27 years ago. Although this co-management agreement has been through different stages and revisions, very important aspects of the context have changed since then. It is proposed in this project that a revision is needed to assure that the agreement has both benefits for traditional owners and to wildlife in the park. Secondly, currently, there are conflicting agendas and conflicting definitions of the problem within the participants. This has created for different programs and policies to be created, often in conflict with one another. For example, wide-range poisoning of quolls by traps to kill dingoes implemented by one agency that seeks to exterminate invasive species (such as wild dogs/dingoes). Another example of what different problem definitions can create is the foxes example. An agency can see foxes as the main issue, and the solution is to target foxes with poisoning bait. What happens, then, is numbers of feral cats and rabbits, which are also hunted by foxes, tend to boom once the foxes are gone. So, small marsupials (i.e. quolls) will still be hunted – only by cats instead – and the rabbits will wreak havoc in the landscape, depriving native animals of food and shelter. This connects to the third contributing factor, the multiplicity of agencies, and lack of exchange between them. Because Australia works under the frame of a decentralized government, many agencies and organizations do not communicate with each other or are held accountable. This then creates a very complex social process, which then creates a very

    Read More

  • The Use of Marine Protected Areas for Conservation Efforts

    2405 Words  | 5 Pages

    These four studies evaluated the use of marine protected areas (MPAs) as the primary tool for conservation efforts. Within Fox’s study he identifies four components that increase a MPA’s effectiveness, all of which focus on bringing together the goals of the governing bodies involved, as well those of the locals who rely on the marine systems in question for resources. The research presented by Edgar and his team presents similar findings as they identify five factors that have shown to increase the success of MPAs after they studied 87 different MPA locations. In addition to identifying the key factors that contribute to MPA success, they also identify some factors that lead to MPA failure. Halpern’s study focuses on the limitations of MPA networks and the broader scope issues that need to also be addressed in order to for MPAs to be truly effective. Halpern and his team suggest that an EBM approach may be the best solution for addressing these issues. Chuenpagdee’s research also highlights the challenges and issues surrounding the implementation of effective MPAs. The study included an in-depth look into four case studies that focused on the design stages of MPAs, and the social issues that must be taken into consideration, and how the incorporation of local communities into management efforts could lead to increases in MPA network success and sustainability. The compilation of data presented in these studies, all highlight the fact that nations are increasing the number of MPAs, in order to reach international goals of conservation, however even if the global area goals of protection are met, it is clear that the success of these protected areas will be heavily dependent upon the socioeconomic issues surrounding the impacted ...

    Read More

  • Tourism's Impact on Australia

    1988 Words  | 4 Pages

    Tourism impacts can be generally classified into seven categories with each having both positive and negative impacts. These impacts include; economic, environmental, social and cultural, crowding and congestion, taxes, and community attitude. It is essential for a balance on array of impacts that may either positively or negatively affect the resident communities. Different groups are concerned about different tourism impacts that affect them in one way or another. Tourism’s benefits can be increased by use of specific plans and actions. These can also lead to decrease in the gravity of negative impacts. Communities will not experience every impact but instead this will depend on particular natural resources, development, or spatial patterns (Glen 1999).

    Read More

  • Analysis Of National Parks Are Not Enough To Protect Nature By Erick Solheim

    923 Words  | 2 Pages

    Although, the author could have benefited from the incorporation of these outside resources into his piece, the Anthropogenic focus of conservation and the romanticized ideal of national parks is still highlighted and credible through other literature. In the article, Solheim interprets the data released by the Protected Planet Assessment of 2016. He presents the data with a minimal bias and challenges the traditional public views of conservation to bring to light underlying issues of management.

    Read More

  • Disadvantages Of Tourism In Thailand

    2249 Words  | 5 Pages

    Half of century has gone since ‘tourism boom’ began in 1960s (Tirados, 2011). Nowadays, desire to be a tourist is virtually universe which has made tourism become a central element of globalization. The profit brought from tourism is something that we cannot deny however everything has its two sides which are good and bad, advantages and disadvantages or positive and negative. Thailand is a great example to find out the advantages and disadvantages of the development of tourism impact on the country.

    Read More

  • Land Use Planning Case Study

    871 Words  | 2 Pages

    On the one hand, participatory approach to land use planning can provide openings for the decentralized administration of land management and enhance legal protection of local land rights through contributing to formal recognition of existing land tenure systems. According to Chigbu et al, (2015) four functions of land use planning that directly links to tenure security. (1) Its capacity to identify or determine land areas, parcels and uses and users. (2) Its propensity to enable documentation of land areas, parcels, rights, restrictions and responsibilities. (3) The opportunities it provides for stakeholder involvement, compensation of claims and community participation. (4) Its impact on land value, land markets and credit opportunities. On the other hand, land use planning, promoting sustainable natural resource use and environmental management are generally part of the mandate of local governments. And these prerogatives often tend to be weakly developed, both legally and with respect to capacity building and methodology (Hilhorst 2010). Unclear property rights and tenure insecurity are the major constraints to the potential of successful land use planning. According to UN-Habitat (2008, p. 17), poor land use planning associated with insecurity of tenure and incompletely specified land rights leads to problems of air and water-borne pollution from agricultural and industrial land use. Though there is a

    Read More

  • Impact of Tourism in the Caribbean

    1790 Words  | 4 Pages

    Fletcher’s article helps to provide more of an insight on why these Caribbean countries rely on the tourism industry, giving a greater perspective of the workings of capitalism as in order to survive it must continually grow. While it is important to note that looking at one small area in the Caribbean and its impact on the tourism industry, cannot lead me to draw any general conclusions– as not every Caribbean country will react to the tourism industry in the same way - the study discussed on Jamaica’s Ocho Rios still can provide perspective as to how this heavy reliance on the tourism industry can affect the social, cultural, environmental, and economic standing within such countries. Further research must be conducted on all different effects and within tourist sites in order to come to a general conclusion. Many researchers have offered frameworks on how to prevent such negative impacts from occurring, and this can be helpful for the future of this fast-growing industry. As a person who has travelled to the Caribbean quite frequently (as I have family members who reside in Barbados), because I stay with family members and thus can see the island from a local perspective, I have witnessed first hand the small ways in which the tourism industry affects a big Caribbean tourist destination such as Barbados; not just with those deemed as outsiders with the tourism industry, but those working within it.

    Read More

  • Environment Managment Paradigms in New Zealand

    1518 Words  | 4 Pages

    Legislation aimed at protecting New Zealand’s environment and natural resources has been through countless reforms to better tailor it to the various discourses that surround environmental management. In Simin Davoudi’s (2012) reading “Climate Risk and Security: New Meanings of “the Environment” in the English Planning System”, Davoudi discusses that environment can be seen in various different ways, as local amenity, heritage ,landscape ,nature reserve, as a store house of resources, as a tradable commodity, as a problem, as sustainability and as a risk (Davoudi, 2012). Although, Davoudi’s typology relates to aspects of New Zealand’s environmental management paradigms, it fails to include some important aspects such as indigenous and community inclusion. Davoudi’s (2012) typology can provide for future guidance in the discourse surrounding environment as risk.

    Read More

  • Essay On Tourism

    2970 Words  | 6 Pages

    Tourism is an important and intricate element to society. It affects economical, social, cultural and environmental elements. Tourism can be argued to have a negative impact on the environment and decrease our already depleting resources, but tourism can also be argued to be a major contributor to strengthening economies, spread cultural traditions and improve people’s lives. Tourism

    Read More

  • Essay On Impact Of Tourism

    809 Words  | 2 Pages

    Nowadays in the rea of globalization, according to the World Tourism Organization, “seven hundred million people travelled abroad in 2003”, and the number is estimated to increase to 1.6 billion by 2020. (International Labour Organization, 2005). Tourism is spreading in unusual places. A lot of people want to be in the midst of adventure. It is a vital source of revenues for the GDP of many countries. I partially agree that tourism hugely benefits the local community. This essay will discuss some of the economic, social and environment effect of tourism on the host community.

    Read More

  • Ecological Knowledge Essay

    1021 Words  | 3 Pages

    Humans, no matter where they live or what their backgrounds are, we find ourselves at the center of the fight with concern for sustainability of the environment. Knowing the land that you live on is an important part of connecting with nature and life around you. It is especially important to connect with the environment for those who work and live in less developed part of the world. Those in third world countries, India for example, rely on nature to provide support and much of their livelihood. The role of nature and how ecological knowledge play a part in our lives is important to examine. There are distinctions within the certain aspects of life that involve the expertise of local practices, especially when addressing the ideas of cultural and development in certain parts of the world.

    Read More

More about Disadvantages Of Community Based Tourism

Open Document