Deviance & Mental Illness According to the DSM-5, mental illness is defined as a "behavioral or psychological syndrome or pattern that occurs in an individual. That reflects an underlying psychobiological dysfunction" (Raskin, 2012, para. 4). This paper will examine the relationship between deviance and mental illness and specifically how mental illness is defined as a form of deviance by society. Through a constructionist approach and the labeling theory, one can examine why those with mental disorders are considered to be deviant in society, how mental illness is labeled as deviant and the stigma that has been created, as well as the effects of a deviant status due to mental illness. Constructionist Approach to Mental Illness A constructionist …show more content…
Therefore, how mental disorders are exemplified through entertainment media is useful in understanding this approach. In the television world, the mentally ill are usually used to serve as a dramatic feature. Unfortunately, the dramatic needs usually include a overemphasizing of stigmatized and negative images of those with mental disorders. This often includes violence, bizarre behavior, and failure. These representations of the mentally ill only increase the deviant and stigmatized views that society has of those with a mental illness. There are differing views among professionals in regards to whether labeling someone as mentally ill is harmful. Studies reveal that most people experience conflict when interacting with ex-mental patients (Signorielli, 1989). Some people see mental patients as disturbing, while many feel the need to help and support them. Television seems to do little in reducing the negative imagery of mental illness, and does little in influencing and convincing the public that people can recover from mental illness as well as are able become productive members of society (Signorielli, 1989). This image of mental illness portrayed through TV shows and movies most likely will cultivate the ignorance and neglect of the mentally …show more content…
Rosenfield (1982) examines the effect of mental disorder patients’ gender in regards to psychiatric hospitalization. She states that there are conflicting perspectives as to whether males or females receive an increased societal reaction in general for residual deviance. Rosenfield proposes that both males and females receive an increased societal reaction when the deviant behavior is believed to be inconsistent to traditional social norms for their gender. Her findings reveal that men are more likely to be hospitalized for depression and neurosis, while women are more likely to be hospitalized for substance abuse and personality disorders. Likewise, Rosenfield’s findings are consistent with this belief, and are specifically consistent with society’s gender social norms. Rosenfield states that the "decisions for hospitalization depend on the nature of the deviance, in terms of the correspondence with sex role norms, for males and females. Males are more often hospitalized for "feminine" types of disorders than are females. Females are more often hospitalized for "masculine" types of disorders than are males” (Rosenfield, 1982, p. 22). Thus, when analyzing gender roles in regards to the deviance of mental illness, the severity of the societal reaction to deviance is a function of the degree to which the assumptions and expectations are violated. Mental disorder expectations in regards
1. The main thesis of the article is that deviance means going against the social norms. Social norms are also different for which person. Rosenhan says that pseudo patients are never detected as sane because each staff member has a confirmation bias. The setting of the mental hospital confirms their bias and they read each behavior from every patient and taper the behavior to fit the diagnosis.
There is an umbrella of different mental disabilities that are not shown on television. Common disorders are usually depression, anxiety, and less often, bipolar disorder (Bastién 12). Even more common, when disorders such as schizophrenia, dissociative identity disorder, and antisocial personality disorder are portrayed on television, they tend to give off a negative connotation on mental disorders. Not all people with mental disorders are “idiosyncratic serial killers” like Hannibal or “grotesquely destructive characters” like Elliot on Mr. Robot (Bastién 13). If society is not developing a stigma of those with mental
The stigma and negative associations that go with mental illness have been around as long as mental illness itself has been recognized. As society has advanced, little changes have been made to the deep-rooted ideas that go along with psychological disorders. It is clearly seen throughout history that people with mental illness are discriminated against, cast out of society, and deemed “damaged”. They are unable to escape the stigma that goes along with their illness, and are often left to defend themselves in a world that is not accepting of differences in people. Society needs to realize what it is doing, and how it is affecting these people who are affected with mental illness.
This stereotype contributes to the stigma individuals’ face and encourages social exclusion and intolerance, especially in schizophrenia (Ray & Brooks Dollar, 2014). Ken sought out help and went to the emergency room because he recognized he was severely depressed. There, the doctor promised he would not be put in restraints, yet when he was taken to the hospital, he was placed in restraints because it was company policy (Steele & Berman, 2001). Due the stigma that individuals with mental illness are violent, Ken was not treated fairly (Stuart & Arboleda-Florez, 2012). Stuart and Arboleda-Florez (2012) are very credible authors to be writing on the effects of stigma in mental health. Both authors have experience in psychiatry, combatting stigma and mental health issues.
Mental illness is more common than one would like to believe. In reality, one in five Americans will suffer from a mental disorder in any given year. Though that ratio is about equivalent to more than fifty-four million people, mental illness still remains a shameful and stigmatized topic (National Institute of Mental Health, n.d.). The taboo of mental illness has an extensive and exhausting history, dating back to the beginning of American colonization. It has not been an easy road, to say the least.
People often like to joke about famous people that are develop mental illness. Others show sympathy towards them and do whatever they can to help them. The author of THE DOUBLE STANDARD OF MENTAL ILLNESS suggest that “we sympathize with those who suffer in silence and gawk and grimace at those who suffer in plain sight” (1). In the 19th century an average citizen wouldn’t know that a famous person was suffering from mental illness because information wasn’t spread as quickly. In the 21st century information is spread very quickly which causes people to learn things really fast. Comedy shows often make light of the issues a celebrity is going through as a form of entertainment. Recently comedian Robin Williams committed suicide after suffering from depression. Many people showed sympathy towards him & his family. However recently Amanda Bynes, a child star, has been suffering from schizophrenia and has been made fun of constantly. The majority of people don’t see mental illness as a problem unless someone dies as a result of
Moreover, the labeling perspective on mental illness... was first formulated decades ago, when mental hospitals were the predominant type of care for persons with mental health problems… Patients were described as undergoing a moral career, which involved the loss of all previous roles because of the way mental health care was structured, and which finally lead to a so-called spoiled identity, the result being that reintegration in society was very difficult, if not impossible (Verhaeghe et al.
The discussion of mental health is slowly being brought to the social surface to create a more inclusive society for those dealing with a mental illness. However, those with a mental illness are continuously being affected by stereotypes, prejudice and discrimination by those who simply don’t comprehend the complexity of the human brain (Glaser, G.2017). As more people become mental health activist, they are exposing the plethora of issues surrounding the overall mental and physical stability of those who are negatively affected by the social construct of what it means to be normal.
Throughout her presentation, she explains how public stigmas, once again, cause label avoidance pushing many who need help away from treatment. She then goes on to explain how these stereotyped behaviors cause discrimination towards people with a mental illness from employment to housing which only leads to the creation of more stigmas. Finally, she states how the impact of stigmas is associated with the reduction of self-esteem, overall poor health, and problems with interpersonal relationships (Willits). By using this presentation I am able to connect what we have learned about mental health stigmas to my article. First off, for example, Morris explains how psychiatric units invoke people to imagine a frightening place where insane patients are strapped down and poked and prodded for care (Morris). This stereotypical idea relates to how Willits described general stereotypes associated with mental illness such as crazy and dangerous (Willits). On top of that, Willits explained how these stigmas have negative consequences for patients (Willits). This relates to Morris’s explanation on how the stigma around institutions has caused these units to shut down forcing many people to be homeless or live in jail
Most people gather what they know about mental illnesses from television and film. Unfortunately these media portrayals are inaccurate and create stigma. They depict people suffering from mental illnesses as different, dangerous and laughable. Characters are often addicted to drugs or alcohol, are violent, dangerous, or out of control. Horror film characters like Norman Bates in Psycho, Jack Torrance in the Shining, or Hannibal Lecter in Silence of the Lambs associate the typical 'psycho- killer' with people who suffer from a mental illness. But dramas and horror films are not the only film genres that create stigma. Comedies like What About Bob and many others not only stigmatize, they also make fun of mental illnesses and the people who suffer from them. This paper will discuss how the film Me, Myself & Irene is an inaccurate, offensive and stigmatizing portrayal of an individual suffering from schizophrenia. It also discusses what can be done to counteract the stigma created by these types of films.
Shutter Island, directed by Martin Scorsese and starring Leonardo DiCaprio, is a frightening film full of twists and turns that presents a highly dramatized depiction of mental health and psychiatric treatment. It fulfills a checklist of the classic elements of Hollywood’s psychological horror genre: foreboding asylums, psychiatric experimentation, dangerous mental afflictions, multiple personalities, intense hallucinations, and even lobotomy. The media’s portrayal of psychiatric disorders and treatment is an important contributor to the continued stigmatization of mental illness in our society. This paper will analyze which aspects of Shutter Island portray
One of the arguments for this side is that the media often twists and bends the truth of how those who suffer from mental illness lead their lives. This is often seen in entertainment media such as movies and T.V. shows. An aspect of this was researched by Forensic Psychology Professor Scott Parrott and Assistant Professor Caroline Parrott. They conducted research through seasons of Law and Order, a show which mental illness is significant trait in many of the characters. They had a randomly selected amount of episodes judged of their mental illness content: the amount of mental illness in the show, typical personalities of those with mental illness, etc.
“People with mental illness are far more likely to be victims of crime than to commit them.”
Sociologists have been examining crime and its causes for over 150 years, and through several researches, various explanations have been used to describe crime and deviance. Crime is a behaviour that goes against all formal written laws of a given society (Haralambos, Smith, O 'Gorman, & Heald, 1996). Laws in different societies differ, so do crimes i.e. what may be considered as a crime in one society may not be in another different society. For instance, while same-sex relationship is accepted in some countries like the United States, United Kingdom etc. it is illegal in countries like Nigeria, and most Arabic countries. Other examples of general crimes are theft/robbery, murder, kidnapping and others. Once a crime is committed, sanctions
Mass media “references to people with mental health problems found more than four in ten articles in the press used derogatory terms about mental health and nearly half of press coverage related mental illness to violence and crime” (Esseler, 244). This is causing for people to look down upon the mention of mental illnesses and many times ignore the importance of confronting this issue. Therefore the importance of removing this stigmatization is crucial. Education allows to make more informed decisions and then changing the perception of mental illness can lead towards policy changes toward the improvement of mental health (Sakellari,