Desiree And Her Baby Dialectical Journal

465 Words1 Page

This story starts off with Desiree and her baby in the present tense, but later the author gives the readers more history though a flash back to when Desiree was a baby herself. This gives readers good foreshadowing for later when Desiree's heritage is in question. Perhaps her husband drew conclusions that Desiree was abandoned because of her mixed race, and hence he wishes her to leave with the baby, in fear of social rejection because of the tainted race in his family name. What surprises me is that there are many ways to blame the woman: she could have had an affair, her lineage could have been tainted, but they did not stop to think that he looks more mixed than she does: "Look at my hand; whiter than yours, Armand" (541). I think Armand …show more content…

Most marriages were arranged due to the appeal of social hierarchy: high class women were expected to marry wealthy plantation owners. In this story, it was apparent that the characters' love for each other was rare, and that their love was powerful—so powerful that it pushed Desiree into death for not having the love of her husband: "He was paying Him back in kind when he stabbed this into his wife's soul. Moreover he no longer loved her, because of the unconscious injury she had brought upon his home and his name" (541). On one hand, if the love they had was so instant and powerful, how could he not stay by her side. Rather, he blamed Desiree and removed the baby and her from the house without determining the truth. This leads me to question her value to him. It seems as though that his love for her was worth much less than his reputation as a planter. One look at a mixed baby left him cold and heartless, and she was not to blame: "I thank the good God for having so arranged our lives that our dear Armand will never know that his mother, who adores him, belongs to the race that is cursed with the brand of slavery" (542). So, it is not Desiree who should be punished for Armand's family history, but the cold truth is that women are blamed for the appearances of their children, and a quick look at even the most precious baby, made a man turn on his great love. This shows to say that shifting blame without absolute certainty can have devastating effects, and some will do anything to save their

Open Document