The death penalty in America, currently, is in full swing, and spares nobody. Dead Man Walking is a movie chronicling the death sentence Matthew Poncelet received and how Sr. Helen Prejean, his spiritual advisor, intervened. The changes that Matthew made throughout the movie demonstrate that criminals can be able to reconcile and deserve another shot. Matthew showed reconciliation not only in his changes throughout the movie, but also during Sr. Helen Prejean’s help and during his execution.
Throughout the entire plot of Dead Man Walking, Matthew Poncelet, the convict, showed the traits of a hardened criminal. Matthew started out as a criminal-type attitude by offending other races and people (i.e. racial slurs, etc.), blamed his crime on others,
…show more content…
He showed reconciliation, love, and respect, which are all traits of a criminal that's not a bad person anymore. Matthew’s last words were, “Mr. Delacroix, I don't want to leave this world with any hate in my heart. I ask your forgiveness for what I've done. It was a terrible thing I done in taking your son away from you. Mr. and Mrs. Percy, I hope my death give you some relief. I just want to say that I think killing is wrong, no matter who does it.” This small speech may seem illegitimate in the sort that he thinks killing is wrong, but judging by the fact that he seeped in shame that he killed someone in his cell, he has a sincere dislike for killing. In this speech, Matthew showed reconciliation by saying that he thinks killing is wrong, for he did it in the first place, and is recognizing his mistakes and troubles. He comforted the victims’ families with love by saying that killing is wrong and that his death hopefully satisfy the Percys, in an effort to wish them happiness in the future. To Mr. Delacroix, Matthew said that he hoped he'd forgive him, in a sort of peace offering, in a loving manner. Matthew made his last words embody respect by avoiding abusive language towards the victims’ families, and addressing that he doesn't want to admit that what he did to the children was wrong and bad. During Matthew’s execution, he showed the traits of a nonviolent man, respect, reconciliation, and
Throughout the ages, death penalty has always been a controversial topic and triggered numerous insightful discussion. In Kroll’s Unquiet Death of Robert Harris, the writer employs pathos as an appeal throughout the whole article in order to convince the audiences that death penalty is “something indescribably ugly” and “nakedly barbaric”. While Mencken makes use of ethos and logos and builds his arguments in a more constructive and effective way to prove that death penalty is necessary and should exist in the social system.
In George Orwell’s essay, “A Hanging,” and Michael Lake’s article, “Michael Lake Describes What The Executioner Actually Faces,” a hardened truth about capital punishment is exposed through influence drawn from both authors’ firsthand encounters with government- supported execution. After witnessing the execution of Walter James Bolton, Lake describes leaving with a lingering, “sense of loss and corruption that [he has] never quite shed” (Lake. Paragraph 16). Lake’s use of this line as a conclusion to his article solidifies the article’s tone regarding the mental turmoil that capital execution can have on those involved. Likewise, Orwell describes a disturbed state of mind present even in the moments leading up to the execution, where the thought, “oh, kill him quickly, get it over, stop that abominable noise!” crossed his mind (Orwell.
Sister Helen Prejean was born on April 21, 1939 in Louisiana and author of “Executions Are Too Costly Morally”. She is a member of Order of the Sisters of St. Joseph of Medaille at the age 18 and supports the Abolishment of Death Penalty. She became internationally famous with her book Dead Man Walking: An Eyewitness Account of the Death Penalty in the United States, the book was based on her own experiences of counseling and advising prisoners on death row in Louisiana prisons. She is also the founder of Survive, which is a victim’s advocacy group in New Orleans.
“How the Death Penalty Saves Lives” According to DPIC (Death penalty information center), there are one thousand –four hundred thirty- eight executions in the United States since 1976. Currently, there are Two thousand –nine hundred –five inmates on death row, and the average length of time on death row is about fifteen years in the United States. The Capital punishment, which appears on the surface to the fitting conclusion to the life of a murder, in fact, a complicated issue that produces no clear resolution.; However, the article states it’s justice. In the article “How the Death Penalty Saves Lives” an author David B. Muhlhausen illustrates a story of Earl Ringo , Jr, brutal murder’s execution on September ,10,
The death penalty, a subject that is often the cause of major controversy, has become an integral part of the southern justice system in recent years. The supporters and opponents of this issue have heatedly debated each other about whether or not the death penalty should be allowed. They back their arguments with moral, logical, and ethical appeals, as seen in the essays by Ed Koch and David Bruck. Although both authors are on opposite sides of the issue, they use the same ideas to back up their argument, while ignoring others that they don’t have evidence for. Koch and Bruck’s use of moral, logical, and ethical persuasion enhance both of their arguments and place a certain importance on the issue of the death penalty, making the readers come to the realization that it is more than just life and death, or right and wrong; there are so many implications that make the issue much more 3-dimensional. In dealing with politics and controversial issues such as capital punishment.
As the minutes tick down to his death, Poncelet begins to break down and his lack of remorsefulness dissolves. His only comfort is Sister Helen and his newly found forgiveness from the Bible. We can once again feel the pain that overcomes Poncelet as he fully grasps what is about to happen. Then, when the restrained Poncelet is displayed in front of the witnesses, including Mr. and Mrs. Percy and Mr. Delacroix, he asked if he has any last words. Poncelet states that he refuses to die with hate in his heart and apologizes to the devastated families. This scene becomes even more upsetting when you see Poncelet and Sister Helen mouthing ‘I love you’ to each other and when Helen reaches her arm out to comfort Poncelet as the first set of lethal drugs are injected.
Employing pathos and logos, Baude gives an explanation for why the death penalty is flawed as he tells the tale of a man on death row. Baude claims “.Judgments, right or wrong. This concern with concepts such as finality, jurisdiction, and the balance of powers may sound technical, lawyerly, and highly abstract. But so is the criminal justice system. Law must provide simple answers: innocence or guilt, freedom or imprisonment, life or death.”
Early societies were based on a simple code of law: "an eye for an eye
It's dark and cold, the fortress-like building has cinderblock walls, and death lurks around the perimeter. A man will die tonight. Under the blue sky, small black birds gather outside the fence that surrounds the building to flaunt their freedom. There is a gothic feel to the scene, as though you have stepped into a horror movie.
The capital punishment has been cited as a reasonable sentence by those who advocate for retribution. This is essentially when it comes to justice so that people take full responsibility for their individual actions. Studies have proved that the decision to take away life of a person because they committed a certain crime serves to perpetuate the crime in question. It also serves to enhance the progress of organized and violent crime. It has been noted that various flaws in the justice system has led to the wrong conviction of innocent people. On the other hand, the guilty have also been set free, and a plethora of several cases has come up when a critical look at the capital punishment has been undertaken. Killers hardly kill their victims deliberately, but they probably act on anger, passion, or impulsively. In this regard, it is not proper to convict them exclusively without
While one person lays with their wrists circumscribed to the worn leather of the gurney, another person holds two skin-piercing needles. The individual holding the needles is an inexperienced technician who obtains permission from the United States federal government to murder people. One needle is held as a precaution in case the pain is too visible to the viewers. Another dagger filled with a lethal dosage of chemicals is inserted into the vein that causes the person to stop breathing. When the cry of the heart rate monitor becomes monotone, the corrupt procedure is complete. Lying in the chair is a corpse when moments ago it was an individual who made one fatal mistake that will never get the chance to redeem (Ecenbarger). Although some people believe that the death
...,” once again quoting the Bible. He seems to take this literally at first, but eventually begins to see it in a different light. When Poncelet finally confesses to raping Hope Percy and killing Walter Delacroix, he is now able die with “dignity,” as Sister Prejean would say.
The film Dead Man Walking focuses on the controversial topics surrounding the death penalty and whether or not the legal system possess the right to kill a person as punishment for a crime. The movie is about Matthew Poncelet on death row and his struggles while awaiting his execution. The death penalty was reinstated in the United States in 1976, and some states have chosen to do away with executions, even with the development of lethal injection. In Tim Robbins’ movie Dead Man Walking, he employs characters to convey how the death penalty eliminates the possibility of rehabilitation, the way a punishment fits the crime, and the guarantee that killers cannot kill again to strengthen death penalty arguments throughout the movie.
When someone is legally convicted of a capital crime, it is possible for their punishment to be execution. The Death Penalty has been a controversial topic for many years. Some believe the act of punishing a criminal by execution is completely inhumane, while others believe it is a necessary practice needed to keep our society safe. In this annotated bibliography, there are six articles that each argue on whether or not the death penalty should be illegalized. Some authors argue that the death penalty should be illegal because it does not act as a deterrent, and it negatively effects the victim’s families. Other scholar’s state that the death penalty should stay legalized because there is an overcrowding in prisons and it saves innocent’s lives. Whether or not the death penalty should be
A death penalty is the sentence of execution for murder and some other capital crimes. Capital punishment can also be applied for treason, espionage, and other crimes. The death penalty, or capital punishment, may be prescribed by Congress or any state legislature for murder and other capital crimes. The Supreme Court has ruled that the death penalty is not a per se violation of the Eighth Amendment 's ban on cruel and unusual punishment.