Critical Analysis of The Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan

1831 Words4 Pages

This essay is a critical analysis that will explain the historical representation of two films that represent the World War Two Normandy Landings. The Normandy Landings took place on June 6, 1944 in France. The Normandy Landings also referred as D- Day, was an invasion by Allied forces on Normandy Beach by crossing by sea and air from English channel to Normandy Beach, which was captured by Nazi forces. The D-Day invasion is the largest war invasion by way of sea and air that included forces from twelve Allied countries. The objective was to reclaim Normandy from the Nazis and establish control over the area as the Germans were attempting to strengthen the position they had in Normandy, France . The general of the Allied forces Dwight E. Eisenhower planned and executed the massive invasion that was codenamed ‘Operation Overload’. Operation Overload involved that would involve transporting troops and supplies from the English Channel to Normandy Beach, this involved attacks from the air and troops on the ground . The Allies forces out number the Germans in Normandy and consequently reclaimed the area. The outcomes of this operation on D-Day ended with the Allied forces claiming Normandy from the Germans and in the process the loss of approximately 425,000 Allied and German soldiers. The invasions by the Allied forces were significant because it allowed access for the Allied forces to enter the border of Western Germany and fight against the Germans on their home turf. If D-Day had not occurred, the outcome for the war might have been different .
The films being assessed in the essay that both represent the events of the Normandy Landings are The Longest day a film released in 1962 and Saving Private Ryan a film released in 1998. T...

... middle of paper ...

...ents the perspectives of the war from both sides. It also is more accurate in telling the story in its entirety of the events that happened on D-Day. Saving Private Ryan only focuses only on a small number of American soldiers in the war and fails to present the entire story prior or after the Normandy Landings.
Despite representing the story of the D-Day invasion more accurately, the Longest Day lacks the more realistic nature of the effects war than Saving Private Ryan achieves (number of casualties, blood etc.). Saving Private Ryan shows soldiers who have lost body parts and that are covered in blood screaming in pain. The film also is more accurate in showing the number of Allied casualties on Normandy Beach. The Longest Day attempts to glorify the Allies in the film and doesn’t demonstration the accurate number of soldiers lying dead on the beach.
Conclusion

Show More
Related

  • The Juno Beach Invasion

    2207 Words  | 5 Pages

    Man, John, The Facts on File D-Day Atlas, The Definitive Account of the Allied Invasion of Normandy (Swanston Publishing Limited 1994)

    Read More

  • American Attack on Omaha and Utah Beaches During D Day

    3055 Words  | 7 Pages

    It was 1944, and the United States had now been an active participant in the war against Nazi Germany for almost three and a half years, nearly six years for the British. During that period occurred a string of engagements fought with ferocious determination and intensity on both sides. There is however, one day which stands out in the minds of many American servicemen more often than others. June 6, 1944, D-Day, was a day in which thousands of young American boys, who poured onto the beaches of Utah and Omaha, became men faster than they would have ever imagined possible. Little did they know of the chaos and the hell which awaited them on their arrival. Over the course of a few hours, the visions of Omaha and Utah Beaches, and the death and destruction accompanied with them formed a permanent fixation in the minds of the American Invaders. The Allied invasion of Europe began on the 6th of June 1944, and the American assault on Utah and Omaha beaches on this day played a critical role in the overall success of the operation. (Astor 352)

    Read More

  • D-Day by Stephen E. Ambrose

    695 Words  | 2 Pages

    D-Day by Stephen E. Ambrose follows the landings on the Calvados coast of Normandy from the pre-planning stages all the way up through the invasion and through about D-Day plus one - one day after the Normandy landings. The first two chapters deal with the combatants in a general fashion before moving on to the location of the landings and why it was chosen. From there, Mr. Ambrose moves into planning of the operation and the preparation for the same. This discussion of the preparation leads into a chapter on the operation specific training that the soldiers received. Then Ambrose discusses the numerous briefings that the troops underwent before the invasion was even launched and then he writes about the process behind General Eisenhower’s deciding to launch the invasion. Once that actual invasion begins, Ambrose uses oral history accounts from men on both Utah Beach and Omaha Beach to tell the story of how the day progressed. The end of the book is taken up with the British and Canadians on Gold Beach and Sword Beach, as well as the actions of the British airborne units. Finally, Mr. Ambrose ends his book with an overview of the Allied forces at the end of June 6, 1944.

    Read More

  • Pathfinders on D-Day

    1467 Words  | 3 Pages

    Germany knew that an allied invasion of France was imminent. For months, allied spies and intelligence sought to leverage the knowledge gained through the invasion of Sicily and against weaknesses in the German defense of France. General Eisenhower knew that an attack on the coast would not be sufficient to invade because Germany had reserve troops and escape routes. The 101st Airborne division’s task was to seize four causeway exits because it was expected that VII Corps would have difficulty moving inland. The 101st and the 82nd were to jump in 5 hours before the landings on Omaha and Utah beach. The Pathfinders mission was crafted thr...

    Read More

  • What If the Allies Had Invaded France in 1943?

    2421 Words  | 5 Pages

    The 1944 Allied landing at Normandy met a strong, networked German defense that initially disrupted the timing of the invasion, slowed down the Allied advance, and inflicted extensive casualties. The German shore defenses were a result of extensive preparations that began when the German High Command appointed Field Marshal Rommel to defend the western European coast. Rommel believed the best strategy against an Allied inv...

    Read More

  • The Media Techniques Used to Produce D-day Landing on the Saving Private Ryan and The Longest Day

    1279 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Media Techniques Used to Produce D-day Landing on the Saving Private Ryan and The Longest Day

    Read More

  • Walter Lord The Day Of Infamy Summary

    380 Words  | 1 Pages

    The Day of Infamy, by Walter Lord, portrays the little details and planning paving the way to the bombing of Pearl Harbor. The story is set in Japan to Hawaii on December 7, 1941, a day noteworthy to the bigger occasion of World War II. Walter Lord invested an incredible measure of energy finding and meeting survivors from both sides of the battle; they shared their recollections, reviewing the fear, and perplexity they encountered, while praising the bravery of numerous.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Foreshadowing In Saving Private Ryan

    719 Words  | 2 Pages

    The reason the movie starts out with the soldiers invading Normandy is to show people that war is not a joke and many people die for the United States. In a later scene while the US is fighting in the streets of Germany, Private Jackson yells “Get down Parker”, and a tank then shoots and kills Parker and Jackson (Jackson). This scene and many others show the audience just how fragile life is and how it can be taken away in an instant.

    Read More

  • Book Critique of The Longest Day

    868 Words  | 2 Pages

    Book Critique of The Longest Day Cornelius Ryan, born in Dublin, Ireland in 1920, worked as a reporter covering the battles in Europe from 1941-1945 and then the final months of the Pacific Campaign. His articles were printed in both Reuters and the London Daily Telegraph. His first book was The Longest Day, published in 1959, selling over 4 million copies in 27 different editions. In 1962, a director named Darryl Zannuck made the book into a movie. Ryan's next book was The Last Battle, published in 1966.

    Read More

  • Coping with War: A Comparison Between Slaughterhouse Five and A Farewell to Arms

    1622 Words  | 4 Pages

    Earnest Hemmingway once said "Never think that war, no matter how necessary, nor how justified, is not a crime." (Ernest Hemingway: A Literary Reference) War is a gruesome and tragic thing and affects people differently. Both Vonnegut and Hemmingway discus this idea in their novels A Farewell to Arms and Slaughterhouse Five. Both of the novels deal not only with war stories but other genres, be it a science fiction story in Vonnegut’s case or a love story in Hemingway’s. Despite all the similarities there are also very big differences in the depiction of war and the way the two characters cope with their shocking and different experiences. It is the way someone deals with these tragedies that is the true story. This essay will evaluate how the main characters in both novels deal with their experiences in different ways.

    Read More

  • The Longest Day: Book Vs. Movie

    1581 Words  | 4 Pages

    For a long time, when anyone thought of a war movie, they immediately thought of Darryl F. Zanuck’s, The Longest Day. Cornelius Ryan, who was the author of the book by the same name, and happened to be a D-day veteran himself, wrote the movie. The book meticulously recreates the events preceding and during the invasion. It is filled with detailed descriptions of multiple occurrences during the invasion. It explains everything from mass attacks on beaches and towns to humorous anecdotes. The book wasn’t exactly a story involving characters, and neither was the film. The Longest Day is more a story of tragedy, glory, and courage surrounding one very important day. And even though mainly American and English filmmakers produced the movie, the movie and book both portray the Germans fairly. But the film added so much to the story that the book could not. Without some of the stunning visuals that the five (Zanuck went unaccredited, but was said to have directed over half the movie) directors put in the film, it would have been impossible to comprehend the scale of it all.

    Read More

  • John Toland: The Battle Of The Bulge

    871 Words  | 2 Pages

    To write this book the author, John Toland, had to devote 15 years researching different stories from all sides of the war. He studied war memoirs, interviewed war veterans, and read military documents. While doing this he focused on both the allied and axis forces to truly understand both sides of the story and be able to write such a descriptive and accurate piece of work. This research was used in the book to describe the unlikely victory of the Americans over the Germans during the “Battle of the Bulge”.

    Read More

  • World War II and Hollywood

    1381 Words  | 3 Pages

    Fyne, Robert. The Hollywood propaganda of World War II. Metuchen, N.J.: Scarecrow Press, 1994. Print.

    Read More

  • Hollywood Propaganda: The Glorification of War by the Film Industry

    2268 Words  | 5 Pages

    War has been present since the beginning of human history. Likewise, war movies have been present since the movie industry began. Just like most other genres of film, war films have been created as a form of entertainment to profit a person or organization. More people are willing to spend their money and time on a feeling of action, excitement, heroism, and patriotism than gruesome and horrid images of real and common human destruction. Propaganda has been used by governments for a very long time and when motion pictures came into existence, governments almost immediately saw the new medium as an opportunity to influence the public. Governments such as the United States of America, cooperate with the movie industry to use this influence to promote a positive perception about war in order to gain support for wars. The movie industry portrays war in an exciting, glorified, romanticized, and heroic light and often demonizes the enemies; this causes an unrealistic public perception of war which leads to greater positive public opinion and support of real wars.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Film War Horse

    1373 Words  | 3 Pages

    The movie I chose to analyze for historical accuracy was War Horse. This movie was set in the First World War, starting in Britain but the story also explored France and Germany during this time period as well. Three scenes will be analyzed: the trench warfare scene between the British and the Germans, the scene where the British soldiers were gassed, and the scene where the British were getting patched up and nursed. War Horse does well to stick to the historical accuracy of what happened during the First World War due to the fact that the three scenes that I have chosen to analyze are not embellished and are close to what really happened.

    Read More

More about Critical Analysis of The Longest Day and Saving Private Ryan

Open Document