The Hunting Ground and The Invisible War expose evidence of an national epidemic of sexual assault cases both on college campuses and in the U.S. Military. While the pervasiveness of sexual assault within the United States is alone concerning, the malpractices of these prominent institutions is more alarming since they trivialize rape accusations and foster a victim blaming sentiment within our society. Both films call for a revaluation of our justice system as well as our societal behaviors to achieve retribution for survivors and curb the ongoing epidemic.
The Hunting Ground reveals how colleges are incentivized by the current federal laws to sweep allegations of sexual assault under the rug. As institutions of higher education, one might
…show more content…
expect colleges to have progressive policies to strictly enforce rape policies and offer services to help survivors emotionally cope. However, in reality, colleges claim they "take rape cases very seriously" and punish the aggressors in an appropriate manner, but they often regard the protection the school's interests and reputation as more important than helping the survivor.
When a victim vocalizes that they were sexually assaulted, a blockade of obstacles from the university along with society emerge to protect the aggressors from receiving punishment. Colleges believe that rape reports deem the school unsafe and less attractive to potential applicants, which would cost the school a significant amount of revenue. Therefore, administrators often question the validity of survivors statements due to pressure from the university to shame them into silence. Administrators may also regard the statements as false allegations. Since colleges are aware of the amount of "hookups" on campus, they may have the misconception that rape reports are used to enact revenge. However, false accusations comprise only 2-8% of rape allegations and can be proven relatively easily. In addition, stereotypes and victim blaming help perpetrate the …show more content…
problem of sexual violence. Common stereotypes such as the victim did not explicitly say "no" and that intoxication gives automatic consent transfers the fault of the rape on the victim. These stereotypes isolate the survivor, rendering them vulnerable and ashamed, feeling as if they committed the crime. Moreover, society blames the victim if their behavior or clothes seemed provocative, which suggests that they deserved to be raped. When victims are blamed for their assault, they are less inclined to report it, which contributes to the cycle of sexual violence. Similarly, The Invisible War depicts how sexual assault cases go unreported in the military to protect its "pristine" reputation.
In the documentary, Sgt. Myla Haider states that the U.S. Military approach to sexual assault is designed to "help women get raped better." The chain of command forces officers to report their rape to their superior, who in many cases may be their rapist. Then, victims are penalized for alleging sexual assault since their reports diminish the performance ratings of the squadron and are viewed as a nuisance. Victim blaming is so prevalent in the military that the victim may be charged with adultery while the attackers go unpunished. The Supreme Court even substantiated this view by ruling sexual assaults as an "occupational hazard." While all sexual assault survivors face emotional distress, military victims often show stronger signs of depression. The military operates on a family mentality so when a coworker or commander violates the victim, they lose trust in their work and become so traumatized that they cannot function as a productive member of society. In addition, military survivors are more likely to contemplate suicide since their entire world seems to have violated. Having a reputation as a sexual assault victim ruins their career in the military by making them seem vulnerable so victims will not report assaults as a defense mechanism or out of fear of being dishonorably discharged by their
superiors. While both documentaries reveal the rise of unreported sexual assaults, efforts are being made to curb the epidemic. Kirsten Gillibrand, an NY Senator, has advocated for reform of sexual assault policies on college campuses as well as in the military. She, along with thirty six other senators, proposed the Campus Accountability and Safety Act, which would protect students and boost accountability and transparency at colleges. This act would establish new campus resources and support services for survivors, require a uniform student disciplinary process across campuses, and enact stiffer penalties for Title IX violations. Then, as a member of the Senate Armed Subcommittee on Personnel, Gillibrand proposed the Military Justice Improvement Act after viewing The Invisible War. The film moved her to take action since the issue became more personal when hearing survivors recount their experiences. This bill was introduced to enable the victims of sexual assault to file their cases with a JAG prosecutor instead of their commanding officers, thereby preventing commanders from changing the verdict. In addition to Gillibrand's federal mandated efforts, both institutions can impose a zero-tolerance policy for sexual assault and can prevent victim blaming by considering an intoxicated person to be incapable of giving consent. If these institutions enforced policies in which the rapists receive punishment instead of the victims, the cycle of silence would be broken since victims would willingly report and receive the justice they deserve.
In Kirby Dick’s influential documentary “The Invisible War,” filmmaker Kirby Dick uses pathos, ethos and logos to gain information and supplementary details to make his point that there is an epidemic of rape in throughout the DOD (Department of Defense) and the fact that military sexual trauma (MST) in the United States military goes unheard, mostly unpunished and needs to be addressed at a higher level.
In 1996, Captain Derrick Robinson, Sergeant Delmar Simpson, and Sergeant Nathanael Beech were arraigned for their suspected involvement in one of the biggest sex scandals the United States Military had seen. According to CNN, between these three men, charges of rape and adultery were pending in a huge case of sexual misconduct against female soldiers at Aberdeen Proving Ground in Maryland (CNN, 2996). Following this incident, the United States Military took it upon themselves to open a telephone hotline to encourage the reporting of similar harsh crimes. Furthermore, the spike in reporting influenced extensive research to examine the prevalence of rape against women soldiers in the U.S. Military (Titunik, 2000). This paper will explore the dynamics of rape against women soldiers in the military and the research done on its prevalence.
Military records show over 20 percent of female veterans have been sexually assaulted (Ziering and Dick The Invisible War). As well as being assaulted, these women are then told no further action will be taken. 33 percent of military women do not report their sexual assault because the person to report to was a friend of the rapist (Ziering and Dick The Invisible War). Those who do come forward are punished for making such allegations. As the film continues, it begins to show overwhelming evidence of lack of punishment for the offenders....
When university or police find out about the sexual assault, they immediately blame the victim or question what the victim was wearing, drinking, or doing. “Brownmiller identified four basic rape myths: (1) All women want to be raped; (2) a woman cannot be raped against her will; (3) a woman who is raped is asking for it; and (4) if a woman is going to be raped, she might as well enjoy it” (Helgeson, 2012, p. 432). In The Hunting Ground, the rape myth, which a woman who is raped is asking for it, is seen throughout the testimonies of the survivors. Clark, herself, was told by her dean that “rape is like a football game” and asked if “looking back, what would you have done differently?” (Ziering & Dick, 2015). These rape myths affect how many victims actually report and how seriously sexual assaults are taken within universities and the justice system. For example, some women, themselves, subscribe to rape myths because they see how current cases are handled. “Women who did not physically fight off the person who raped them and who subscribed to the rape myth that “it can’t be rape if a woman doesn’t fight back” were less likely to acknowledge that they had been raped” (Helgeson, 2012, p. 434). Universities need to teach first-year students about consent and how to
According to the authors of “Enhancing Care and Advocacy for Sexual Assault Survivors on Canadian Campuses”, “Sexual assault has immediate and long-term health consequences for victims including suicide, HIV infection, depression, and social isolation,” (Quinlan, Clarke, and Miller). Another common side effect these victims face is post-traumatic stress disorder. Someone experiencing PTSD may have random outburst of anger, have trouble concentrating on day to day tasks, or may even have flashbacks of their attack. These consequences make it hard for victims to get back into the normal routine of everyday life (“Effects of Sexual Assault”). In a case at Amherst College a young women named Angie Epifano faced many of these consequences after she was raped by an acquaintance in one of the college’s dormitories. While immediately choosing to ignore what had happened to her Epifano soon became an emotional wreck. Before the attack Epifano had believed herself to be an extremely strong and independent individual. In an article done on Epifano’s story she stated “Everything I had believed myself to be was gone in 30 minutes,” (Epifano). Sexual assault takes away a piece of someone. With their hopes and dreams clouded by the tragedy they have endured, victims face a lifetime of
The common story from victims who report being raped, according to a Military Rape Crisis Center worker, is that they were “met with disbelief and skepticism, blamed for the crime, and disposed of one way or another,” (Kitfield). Until the military stops re-victimizing the victims it will never be able to completely eradicate rape from the ranks.
The level of hurt that can come from ignoring a sexual assault and that it actually happened can affect someone negatively. It can even get them to thinking bad about themselves and it can turn to the worse fast. There were many flaw’s/fallacies that were committed pertaining to these sexual assaults on campus.
In the surveys they have referenced in the article, it displays military sexual trauma increases among women during and after military deployment of unwanted sexual contact in recent years. The authors have recruited and conducted of twenty-two US servicewomen telephone interviews from May 2011 to January 2012 to participate a qualitative study with or without their MST experiences. They asked the participants questions regarding about MST during deployment and other factors which are disturbing their reporting and accessing to services against the perpetrators. The issues of sexism, high stress levels, and failed military leadership contributing factors which put these servicewomen in jeopardy of MST. Some of the interview women said that servicewomen do not report MST due to lack of support from peers, unreliable confidentiality, stigma, and other barriers. The interviewees feel more comfortable opening to medical care services after deployment in the United States that grips with sexual assault cases than throughout deployment around the world. The participants have suggested to improving the MST services: by increasing awareness, prosecution, investigation, cultural shift, and independence service providers. The interviewees recognized that Military se...
In this research paper, we will evaluate how sexual assault is handled on a college campus. What system is used and how does it
Sexual assault in the military has become one of the most controversial of all issues that have been discussed over the years. The topic has received extensive media coverage and has contributed to multiple media scandals. According to a Newsweek report done in 2011, women are more likely to be assaulted by fellow soldiers than killed in combat. The Department of Defense estimates approximately 19,000 sexual assaults occur per year amongst military personnel. That number is stifling considering that in the last year only 1,108 troops filed for investigation, and of those only 575 cases were processed. Out of the 575 processed cases only 96 went to Court Martial. Obviously from the numbers, sexual assault is a serious issue in the military. Much like in the civilian world there is bias when it comes to the guilt or innocence of the attacker, as well as the validity in the accounts of the accuser. I believe that the system in place may inadvertently contribute to the continuous rise in sexual assaults and that if this system isn’t fixed quickly, it will be detrimental to the organization as a whole. Sexual assault has seriously negative impacts on service members and their families. That impact carries over to their work, limiting mission readiness, and undermining national security.
When it comes to sexual assault on college campuses there is also the question of what can colleges do to decrease the amount of sexual assaults. Bradford Richardson and Jon A Shields wondered the same thing, so they conducted an ...
Sexual Assault in the military has become an uprising problem. Within the military community, the term sexual assault carries a meaning that includes everything from violent sexual acts such as rape and forcible sodomy, to assault with intent to commit rape, unwanted sexual touching or attention and being a witness of the crime and not reporting it. Although most believe those who commit such heinous crimes are usually a person or persons with a violent record, violence is not a prerequisite for sexual assault. Once a service member becomes a victim of sexual assault, they become much more than a victim of just the crime itself. They fall victim to their own thoughts, never being able to trust their chain of command again, jeopardizing careers
Every semester, a student attending a college campus will have at some point experience some inappropriate, unwanted attention. There is always someone at school who tends to make someone uncomfortable, be it through eye contact, persistent advances, or just uncalled for innuendos. Of course, we do our best to ignore it, or to just report the bothersome activity, but that can only do so much without someone finding a way around such things. Someone is always going the extra mile to get what he or she wants, even if it’s at the expense of the victim. We can’t turn a blind eye on our friends, our family, or our associates in these dark, sexual assault situation. Campus sexual assault is a problem with plenty of factors regarding it.
The US Military has been one of the most powerful and respected fighting forces in the world; it is also a hotbed for sexual assault. Each year, thousands of men and women take an oath to serve and protect their country and each thousands of military service members are sexually assaulted. “Earlier this week, Pentagon officials released a new report which estimated more than 70 sexual assaults occur in the military each day. ”(Shane III) Fear of retaliation, both personal and professional, and humiliation stop many service members from reporting their sexual assaults. Those few that make the bold choice to report incidents of sexual assault often finds themselves disappointed by the outcome; assaults that do get reported have an incredibly low rate of conviction of the offender.
According to a statement addressing the sexual victimization of college women The Crime and Victimization in America states that, “ One out of four women will be sexually assaulted on a college campus.” This disturbing fact has not minimized throughout the years, instead it is continuing to worsen throughout college campuses. Sexual assault is not an act to be taken lightly. Society must stop pinpointing the individuals who commit these crimes one by one, but rather look at the problem as a whole and begin to understand the main cause of sexual assault and possible methods to reduce these acts of sexual coercion.