Comparison of the Fukushima and the Chernobyl Nuclear Disasters

1510 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster

Taking a quick look at the Fukushima and Chernobyl nuclear disasters, it may appear that they were the same situation and that history had repeated itself but the two disasters were very different. The Fukushima nuclear disaster took place on March 11th, 2011 in Fukushima, Japan. After the disaster occurred, the government left the issue to the Tokyo Electric Power Company (TEPCO), the owner of the plant. However, recently there was an increase in the amount of leaks from the power plant so the government decided to take charge. The government plans to spend $320 million to build a subterranean ice wall to control the contaminated water and $150 million on an improved water treatment unit. The Chernobyl Nuclear Disaster, on the other hand, occurred on April 26,1986 in Pripyat, Soviet Union. In other words, it occurred after the Cold War, which might have been one of the reasons that it tried to handle the situation on its own. The nuclear disaster in Fukushima, Japan is similar to the one of the Chernobyl nuclear reactor in Pripyat, Soviet Union in that both of their governments evacuated the area close to the reactors and they both did not ask other countries for help. However, the Japanese government left the mess to the Tokyo Electric Company to contain the nuclear disaster which was caused by the loss of power from natural disasters and the government handled the nuclear disaster in the Soviet Union which was caused by a faulty design with inadequate workers running it. This shows that the nuclear leak in Chernobyl was much more severe than the one in Fukushima. One similarity between the Chernobyl and the Fukushima nuclear disasters is that they both evacuated the areas surrounding the sites where the accident took place.Fu... ... middle of paper ... ...es. Works Cited http://www.theatlantic.com/infocus/2011/03/the-chernobyl-disaster-25-years-ago/100033/ http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/Safety-and-Security/Safety-of-Plants/Chernobyl-Accident/#.Uk8gydK_J8E http://www.commerce.wa.gov.au/Worksafe/PDF/Forums/safety_culture-Jane_.pdf http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/subjects/c/chernobyl_nuclear_accident_1986/index.html http://elgoog.im/search/?q=Chernobyl+nuclear+reactor+disaster Brennan, Kristine. "Health Effects of Chernobyl." The Chernobyl Nuclear Disaster. N.p.: Chelsea House, 2002. 75-86. Print. Great Disasters Reforms and Ramifications. http://go-kids.grolier.com/page?tn=/news/feature_archive.php&id=ns1-20110328&type=0tdns http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/09/03/fukushima-disaster-ice-wall_n_3858884.html Eisler, Ronald. The Fukushima 2011 Disaster. Boca Raton: CRC, 2013. Print.

Show More
Related

  • An Analysis Of Visit Sunny Chernobyl

    871 Words  | 2 Pages

    The engineers in Visit Sunny Chernobyl created a new frontier past the safety zone because they want to test the limits of the reactor. What the scientists didn’t account for is that fact that the reactors already had the potential of a dangerous chain reaction. (Blackwell 6) Consequently, their boundary destroying led to catastrophic consequences and the total annihilation of a land area because of massive radiation. Blackwell thought Chernobyl was so horrific he expressed that no one should visit without a “working understanding of radiation and how it’s measured” (Blackwell 7). These are some horrific consequences that followed from surpassing the

    Read More

  • How Chernobyl Became a Scary Word

    990 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...r. Iodine 131, another radioactive element, can dilute very quickly in the air, but if it is deposited on grass eaten by cows, the cows then re-concentrate it in their milk. Absorbed into the body's thyroid gland in a concentrated dose, Iodine 131 can cause cancer. In the Chernobyl disaster, the biggest health effect has been cases of thyroid cancer especially in children living near the nuclear plant. Therefore, because of the Chernobyl disaster we know to test the grass, soil, and milk for radiation. Also, an evacuation of the Chernobyl area was not ordered until over 24 hours after the incident. Japanese authorities evacuated 200,000 people from the area of Fukushima within hours of the initial alert. From the mistakes and magnitude of the disaster at Chernobyl, the world learned how to better deal with the long and short term effect of a Nuclear Fallout.

    Read More

  • The Disaster at Chernobyl

    846 Words  | 2 Pages

    On April 26th, 1986, operators at the Chernobyl Power Plant in Chernobyl, Ukraine, ran what they thought to be a routine safety test. But fate was not on the side of these operators. Without warning, reactor #4 became unstable, as it had been operating at a low power for a possible shutdown and the reactor’s design caused it to be unsafe at this level of power. Internal temperatures rose. Attempts to cool the system produced the opposite effect. Instantly, the nuclear core surged with power. At 1:23 p.m., the reactor exploded. The first blast ripped off the reactor's steel roof. The second blast released a large plume of radiation into the sky. Flames engulfed the building. For ten long days, fire fighters and power plant workers attempted to overcome the inferno. Thirty-one of them died of radiation poisoning. Chernobyl was the worst nuclear disaster in history. It unleashed radiation hundreds of times greater than the atomic bombs exploded over Japan during World War II. [1]

    Read More

  • Essay On Chernobyl

    1012 Words  | 3 Pages

    On April 26 1986, an accident-related Chernobyl nuclear power plant in Chernobyl has been occurred. The Chernobyl disaster was a catastrophic nuclear accident which has resulted in several explosion and fire. This causes the release of large quantities of radioactive particle into the atmosphere and then spread over the nearby area. The Chernobyl disaster is said to be the worst nuclear power plant accident in history. It is classified as level event on Internati...

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Fukushima Nuclear Power

    1379 Words  | 3 Pages

    Following a severe earthquake and Tsunami, 3 reactors were damaged, similar to Chernobyl. However, the event was contained with minimal nuclear leaks and no deaths. The surrounding area has already been deemed safe. Despite this, many still fear events such as this. The problem is, they should not. “As a nuclear engineer, it is depressing to read the recent reports on the Fukushima nuclear incident — not because of the incident itself (at this point I strongly believe that we will remember Fukushima as evidence of how safe nuclear power is when done right) — but because the media coverage of the event has been rife with errors so glaring that I have to wonder if anyone in the world of journalism has ever taken a physics class.” (Yost, Keith. What happened at the Fukushima reactor? Mit.edu) What he is essentially saying is that the nuclear reactors were properly managed during the event, and a major incident was avoided. He believes it instead to be a testimony to the safety of nuclear

    Read More

  • Chernobyl: The Unforgettable Engineering Disaster

    1499 Words  | 3 Pages

    Countless engineering disasters have occurred in this world, many civilians lost their lives due to corrupted constructions. The most fatal and deadly engineering disaster that took place in our history was the Chernobyl disaster. The Chernobyl catastrophe was a nuclear setback that happened at the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant in on April 26, 1986. It is seen as the most recognizable terrible nuclear power plant cataclysm ever. A nuclear crisis in one of the reactors caused a fire that sent a cluster of radioactive consequence that on the long run spread all over Europe.

    Read More

  • The Disaster at Chernobyl

    1590 Words  | 4 Pages

    Chernobyl, one word that still strikes pain and fear in the hearts of many, even after 28 years is still causing serious damage. It was largest nuclear disaster ever, Chernobyl was “. . . about 400 times more potent than the bomb dropped on Hiroshima during World War II . . .” (Walmsley “26 years on: helping Chernobyl's children”). The disaster was not immediately seen as a large threat, and this is why so many lives were taken or destroyed.

    Read More

  • Could the Chernobyl Disaster Have Been Prevented?

    1240 Words  | 3 Pages

    Hopefully, with accurate analysis and innovation, my research will teach the world of its past so this disaster doesn’t occur in the future. B - Summary of Evidence Chernobyl (chrn byl) is an uninhibited city in north Ukraine, near the Belarus boundary, on the Pripyat River. Ten miles to the north, in the town of Pripyat, is the Chernobyl nuclear powerstation, site of the worst nuclear reactor disaster in history ("Chernobyl", Columbia Encyclopedia). To specify, on April 26, 1986, Unit Four of the Chernobyl nuclear reactor exploded in Ukraine, injuring human immune systems and the genetic structure of cells, contaminating soils and waterways. Nearly 7 tons of irradiated reactor fuel was released into the environment—roughly 340 million curies.

    Read More

  • Chernobyl

    451 Words  | 1 Pages

    Chernobyl was the greatest nuclear disaster of the 20th century. On April 26th, 1986, one of four nuclear reactors located in the Soviet Union melted down and contaminated a vast area of Eastern Europe. The meltdown, a result of human error, lapsed safety precautions, and lack of a containment vessel, was barely contained by dropping sand and releasing huge amounts of deadly radioactive isotopes into the atmosphere. The resulting contamination killed or injured hundreds of thousands of people and devastated the environment. The affects of this accident are still being felt today and will be felt for generations to come.

    Read More

  • The Chernobyl Meltdown

    1479 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Chernobyl meltdown was one the biggest meltdowns of the decade, the implications of Chernobyl didn’t just resonate in Russia, but the uranium contamination was found all across Europe. Sheep farmers from North Cumbria were affected by the radiation contamination. After the contamination, scientists came to help the farmers who were affected. Our presentation on the article also discussed the broader implications for the public understanding of science and how the deficit model failed in the article. The deficit model was used to discuss the problems with science and the lay people. The public’s negative attitude towards science is because of their ignorance towards it and the remedy was to dumb down the information to the lay people. This article discusses how both science and the lay people were misunderstanding each other. This was through miscommunication and standard view of the public understanding of science which lead to people to initially trust everything the scientists would say.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Speech: We Must Use Alternative Power Sources Instead of Nuclear Energy

    1650 Words  | 4 Pages

    I. (Gain Attention and Interest): March 11, 2011. 2:45 pm. Operations at the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant continued as usual. At 2:46 pm a massive 9.0 earthquake strikes the island of Japan. All nuclear reactors on the island shut down automatically as a response to the earthquake. At Fukushima, emergency procedures are automatically enabled to shut down reactors and cool spent nuclear fuel before it melts-down in a catastrophic explosion. The situation seems under control, emergency diesel generators located in the basement of the plant activate and workers breathe a sigh of relief that the reactors are stabilizing. Then 41 minutes later at 3:27 pm the unthinkable occurs. As workers monitored the situation from within the plant, citizens from the adjacent town ran from the coastline as a 49 foot tsunami approached. The tsunami came swiftly and flooded the coastline situated Fukushima plant. Emergency generators were destroyed and cooling systems failed. Within hours, a chain of events led to an explosion of reactor 1 of the plant. One by one in the subsequent days reactors 2, and 3 suffered similar fates as explosions destroyed containment cases and the structures surrounding the reactors (Fukushima Accident). Intense amount...

    Read More

  • Chernobyl Disaster

    1263 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Chernobyl accident is to this day one the worst nuclear accident ever along with the Fukushima nuclear power plant, with the difference that the Chernobyl accident was handled terribly by the government. The disaster occurred on April 26 of 1986, when a cut of power supply was being simulated and a sudden surge of power in the reactor 4 of the nuclear power plant generated the overheating of the reactor core that caused the detonation of hydrogen built up in its internal parts. This caused a tremendous increase in the level of ionizing radiation in much of Europe. The Chernobyl accident was going to happen sooner or later. Operational standards, as well as design, construction without a containment vessel and quality control of nuclear power were handled by Communist Party political criteria, not technical and economic criteria. Operators did not have to meet strict safety standards and ensure the plant against any type of risk by paying higher premiums because the plants belonged to the state, not like the way is done in Europe, USA and Japan were those safety standards are strictly controlled.

    Read More

  • The Effects of Chernobyl Nuclear Disaster on Humans and the Environment

    778 Words  | 2 Pages

    "The tops are leaping off the reactor lip" this was the first warning which the control room received before the destructive explosion in Chernobyl that occurred at 1:23 AM local time. Twenty three minute after the warning in the morning of 26 April 1989, the reactor exploded. The Chernobyl nuclear accident was an unexpected catastrophe that can happen in the history of producing nuclear power. International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) defined a nuclear accident as an accident that includes any activities that lead to the release of radioactive material and causes significant consequences. The location of Chernobyl city is in the north of Ukraine near the Belarus border. That nuclear accident happened when in reactor number 4 in the Chernobyl nuclear power in the Soviet Union exploded. Because of that extreme explosion, the radioactive emissions dispensed into the environment and caused immediate deaths, illnesses and many health problems. World Health Association (2013) reports that during the accident, one person died immediately and another one died in the hospital due to the harmful injuries he received. Health World Organization (WHO) (2006) also reports that a few weeks after the disaster 28 people died because of the Acute Radiation Sickness(ARS). The Chernobyl nuclear accident is one of the major disasters in the history of nuclear power which had many serious effects on humans and the environment.

    Read More

  • Environmental Disaster: The Chernobyl Disaster

    980 Words  | 2 Pages

    One of the most significant environmentally damaging instances in history was the Chernobyl incident. In 1986, the Chernobyl Nuclear Plant in Ukraine exploded. It became one of the most significant disasters in the engineering community. There are different factors that contributed to the disaster. The personnel that were tasked with operating the plant were unqualified. The plant’s design was a complex one. The RBMK reactor was Soviet design, and the staff had not be acquainted with this particular design. As the operators performed tests on the reactor, they disabled the automatic shutdown mechanism. After the test, the attempt to shut down the reactor was unsuccessful as it was unstable. This is the immediate cause of the Chernobyl Accident. It later became the most significant nuclear disaster in the history of the

    Read More

  • Essay On Chernobyl Disaster

    1188 Words  | 3 Pages

    On April26, 1986, the nuclear power plant was exploded in Chernobyl, Ukraine. At 1:23 AM, while everyone were sleeping, Reactor #4 exploded, and 40 hours later, all the city residence were forcefully moved to other cities, and they never return to their home. The Chernobyl disaster is ranked the worst nuclear accident. The Chernobyl nuclear power plant was ran by the Soviet Union central nuclear energy corporation. (International Atomic Energy Agency-IAEA, 2005)

    Read More

More about Comparison of the Fukushima and the Chernobyl Nuclear Disasters

Open Document