Comparing Darnay And Charles Carton

610 Words2 Pages

Patrick McMahon Mrs. Conetta English 9 Honors B-2 26 March 2014 Two Men, Alike and Different: Charles Darnay and Sydney Carton Two characters within Charles Dicken’s A Tale of Two Cities stand out the most: Charles Darnay and Sydney Carton. While they both love Lucie, only one man makes the ultimate sacrifice for her and her family: his life. Sydney Carton giving up his life for Lucie and her family illustrates one of the stark differences between Darnay and Carton. However, at the same time, both men share many similarities. When the reader first encounters Sydney Carton, Sydney is a self-deprecating, poor unfortunate soul that has nothing to live for. This contrasts with the persona of Charles Darnay, as he marries Lucie, with whom Carton is in love. Carton even comments to Darnay, “I am a disappointed drudge, sir. I care for no man on Earth, and no man on Earth cares for me” (70, Dickens). This quote further affirms Carton’s depressed disposition. Carton, in contrast to Darnay is also described as “careless and slovenly, if not debouched” (72, Dickens). Carton, a seemi...

Show More
Related

  • Sydney Carton Quotes

    1498 Words  | 3 Pages

    This quote shows that Carton wishes he had been a better person, and knows that he could have been as successful as Darnay if only he had applied himself to his job or found love. Sydney Carton is a man deep in self-doubt and self-hatred. He is an alcoholic who is often moody and depressed (Moss and Wilson). Carton has an extremely low opinion of himself, and has no happiness or love in his life. Carton’s sacrifice ultimately purifies him, and saves him from his own self-loathing. Though Carton’s strength comes from his love for Lucie, his apathy for his life does as well; “he is a brooding individual, socially outcast, and both driven and tormented by an impossible love.” (Gonzalez-Posse 346) This quote shows Carton’s unattainable need to

    Read More

  • A comparative study of Sydney Carton in Dickens' A Tale of Two Cities

    1248 Words  | 3 Pages

    the personality can be intense. Dickens introduces Sydney Carton to us immediately after a trial, speaking to his client. It is at this point that we get a glimpse of the character of Carton, "…who smelled of port wine, and did not appear to be quite sober…" (Dickens, 100). Carton is so disillusioned with his own life, that he can’t even like his client [who looks like him],

    Read More

  • Unrequited Love: A Tale of Two Cities, and Cyrano de Bergerac

    1144 Words  | 3 Pages

    Both Sydney and Cyrano are very smart and talented characters. Despite being smart and talented, they are still able to learn additional things about themselves through their experiences with unreturned love. Sydney, while in England, is a sad, depressed but none the less talented man. According to Dickens, “If Sydney Carton ever shone anywhere, he certainly never shone in the house of Doctor Manette…When he cared to talk, he talked well; but, the cloud of caring for nothing, which overshadowed him with such a fatal darkness, was very rarely pierced by the light within him” (Dickens 198). Mr. Dickens describes Sydney as a smart man, who could “talk well”, but is overshadowed by a dark cloud of ideal laziness and disregard. He is not a confident man and does not believe he can do anything the right way. After an encounter with Lucie Manette, the woman whom Sydney loves and as the setting shifts to France, he experiences change. Carton gains that confidence and strength to become himself – a smart, worthy and confident man. Carton shows this by saying, “Shall I do well, in the mean time, to show myself? I think so. It is best that these people should know there is such a...

    Read More

  • Jarvis Lorry's Paradoxes In A Tale Of Two Cities

    599 Words  | 2 Pages

    A wastrel, Carton has no hope for a successful career in law. After paying him fees from the trial, Darnay remarks and Carton responds, ““I think you have been drinking, Mr Carton.... and no man on earth cares for me”” (99). Darnay thanks Carton for saving his life and Carton admits that he has wasted his potential and has no connections in life. Although Carton has immensely more talent in the law than his more successful associate Stryver, his lack of ambition keeps him in the position of the jackal that kills but receives no credit. Despite his unkempt appearance, Carton also retains high morals throughout the novel and has the courage to sacrifice himself all along. He tells Lucie, ““O miss Manette... to keep a life you love beside you!”” (179). Carton tells Lucie to remember his promise of sacrificing his life for one close to her. Carton does not change into a redeeming character, he possesses his strong values from the beginning. Dickens’s portrayal of Carton poses the strongest paradox of the novel as he introduces his character as a drunk and seemingly of no consequence but in the end Carton reveals his sacrificial character that he had all

    Read More

  • Charles Darnay A Tale Of Two Cities

    1124 Words  | 3 Pages

    Charles Darnay plays a pivotal role in the movie A Tale of Two Cities. His actions and eventual consequences drive the plot of the story. He is the nephew of the French aristocrat Monseigneur a.k.a. Marquis Evremonde. In the story, he marries Lucie Manette and therefore becomes the son-in-law of Doctor Manette. He is also an acquaintance of Sydney Carton, who is a friend of his wife. Charles Darnay is an interesting person to study because of the content of his character. He came across as an extraordinarily honest and good individual, but he has a certain complexity to him, making it enjoyable to learn more about him.

    Read More

  • Paradoxical Characters In A Tale Of Two Cities

    605 Words  | 2 Pages

    Carton exhibits his selflessness by telling Lucie that he would die for anyone that she loves. For example, Sydney Carton shows his selflessness for Lucie saying, “For you, and for any dear to you, I would do anything. I would embrace any sacrifice for you and for those dear to you. And when you see your own bright beauty springing up anew at your feet, think now and then that there is a man who would give his life, to keep a life you love beside you” (179). Sydney promises Lucie that he would die for her or even her loved ones. Carton portrays the theme of resurrection, as he dies and lives again through Sydney Darnay, Lucie’s son. Be that as it may, Sydney Carton also shows selfishness and hopelessness. Carton demonstrates his bitterness when conversing with Darnay after his trial. For instance, while talking to Darnay, Carton says, “As to me, the greatest desire I have, is to forget that I belong to it. It has no good in it for me – except wine like this – nor I for it” (97). Carton tells Darnay how he does not care for himself, and reveals his hopelessness for living a good life. Carton demonstrates his paradoxical nature through his grief with himself and carelessness, however he shows that he also does want to fix his life for the better even if that means

    Read More

  • Sydney Carton Allusions

    907 Words  | 2 Pages

    The influence of the Bible surrounds society and affects everyone, every culture, and every piece of art and literature even if people do not recognize it. In the novel, A Tale of Two Cities, Charles Dickens shift of tone and biblical allusions portrays the inevitable death of Sydney Carton for him to find his purpose in life. The book takes place during the French Revolution, in 1789, where thousands of citizens were executed due to suspicion. Sydney Carton is a drunk, depressed person, and has wasted his life by trying to find the meaning and purpose in living. Besides some ambiguous remarks to his past and the disclosure of his parents' death when he was young, Carton's past remains an unknown mystery to the reader. However, the only honorable

    Read More

  • Christianity in a Tale of Two Cities

    1696 Words  | 4 Pages

    Dickens responded to this "dog-eat-dog" social climate by writing A Tale of Two Cities as a vehicle to reform society. He intends to fortify Christian values within English culture, such as self-sacrifice and kindness, in a time when he feels these values are threatened and sometimes completely overlooked. In this essay, I will show how Dickens interweaves his moral agenda of Christian values into the novel by using contrasts, symbols, and the motif of doubles as well as the evolution of Sydney Carton into a Christ-like figure with the goal of inspiring the reader to the point of evolving into an ethically "good" human being.

    Read More

  • Charles Dickens' Use of Sacrifice in A Tale of Two Cities

    1047 Words  | 3 Pages

    The theme of sacrifice is portrayed in A Tale of Two Cities in several ways through the actions of Dr. Manette, Mr. Defarge, and Sydney Carton, but all acts of sacrifice display audacity and show how much love and compassion there must be for that person. Giving up something or risking your life for another person or name is one of the hardest and bravest acts a person can do. Dr. Manette, Mr. Defarge, and Sydney Carton’s actions showed just how much they love Lucie Manette and their acts of sacrifice showed how they would do anything to please her. Sacrificing yourself or your name for someone not only lets you achieve inner happiness, but shows how courageous a person must be to do so.

    Read More

  • Archetypes In A Tale Of Two Cities

    922 Words  | 2 Pages

    Sydney Carton has no real accomplishments in his life. After the first court case with Charles Darnay, Sydney Carton feels like he hasn’t done anything. He says to Charles Darnay, “I am a disappointed drudge, sir. I care for no man on earth, and no man on earth cares for me” (Dickens 81). Sydney Carton even knows that he has accomplished nothing in his life so he then drinks himself to sleep. In like manner, Sydney Carton doesn’t get the girl. Sydney Carton falls in love with Lucie Manette, but she is in love with Charles Darnay. Since Carton knows he is a “failure” he tells Lucie they can never be together even though he loves her. She respects his decision and then goes on to marry Charles Darnay. It’s heartbreaking to see the love of your life go on to marry another man. Despite Sydney Carton’s past, his true nature as underdog is brought to light. Charles Darnay is sentenced to death by Guillotine, so Sydney Carton decides to trade places with him to protect the Manette family. He is so selfless that he decides to accept death to protect his loved ones. Sydney Carton surpasses Charles Darnay who he looked up to for his

    Read More

  • Tale Of Two Cities Rhetorical Analysis

    1783 Words  | 4 Pages

    Dickens alleges that “Sydney Carton would never be a lion, he was an amazingly good jackal” (65). Carton is referred to as a jackal because jackals are scavengers; these animals let the lion eat all the food first, and then the jackal will eat the remains. Stryver is the lion; he is missing the intellect to extract the essence for cases. Carton stays up from ten at night until three in the morning drinking and working for Stryver. Carton gets all the information, while Stryver receives all the credit. Sydney Carton is a man in the shadows, and everyone believes he is a depressed alcoholic except for Lucie Manette. Carton loves Lucie, and he adds to her, “I wish you to know that you have been the last dream of my soul” (115). Carton is freeing his soul by telling her that he is grateful that she does not love him because he is not worthy. Carton believes he cannot change for the better; he is set in his ways, and he cannot save himself because of his fate. Carton is selfless and fragile when he expresses his feelings to Lucie, which shows how amazing he is. Carton’s delicateness conveys when Dickens claims, “there were tears in his eyes. There were tears in his voice too” (115). Carton informs Lucie, “for you, and for any dear to you, I would do anything” (117). Dickens foreshadows that Carton will save Darnay’s life by dying for him out of his love for Lucie, which is Carton’s purpose in life. Carton is similar to “an eddy that turned and turned-purposeless, until the stream absorbed it, and carried it on to the sea” (244). An eddy goes nowhere until the stream, which straightens it our as a purpose, captures it. The purpose takes him to an end, which is peace, death, or redemption. Carton has always been going nowhere, but now he has a purpose to save Darnay and

    Read More

  • Tale Of Two Cities

    439 Words  | 1 Pages

    People often give up their life to save another as an act of courage or valiancy. In the novel Tale of Two Cities, Sidney Carton’s death saved Charles Darnay. However, when Carton gave his life it was not a noble act nor did he die merely to save Darnay. Carton committed suicide to immortalize himself in the eyes of Lucie Manette, Charles Darnay’s wife and Sidney Carton’s obsession. The fact that this event saved Charles Darnay’s life was just a fortunate coincidence.

    Read More

  • Charles Darnay and Sydney Carton Compare and Contrast

    580 Words  | 2 Pages

    People can look alike, yet be very different. One of the best examples from literature of people who look almost alike, but are very different are Charles Darnay and Sydney Carton from “A Tale of Two Cities” by Charles Dickens. Although Sydney Carton looks nothing but a worthless person than Charles Darnay, as the book progresses, Carton seems to be changing.

    Read More

  • Unconditional Love Forgiveness And Mercy Research Paper

    867 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...seen. Sydney Carton, therefore, would be an exemplary disciple to this. It is Sydney Carton's unmatched love for Lucie results in giving up the ultimate sacrifice—his life. Fufilling his promise to Lucie, Carton trades places with Charles Darnay, a man he despises, on his execution day, sparing Darnay’s life but ending his own. His death enables the woman he loves to be with the life she loves.

    Read More

  • The Historical Context of A Tale of Two Cities

    2559 Words  | 6 Pages

    A Tale of Two Cities, by Charles Dickens, is a story set in the year 1775 and through the turbulent time of the French Revolution. It is of people living in love and betrayal, murder and joy, peril and safety, hate and fondness, misery and happiness, gentle actions and ferocious crowds. The novel surrounds a drunken man, Sydney Carton, who performs a heroic deed for his beloved, Lucie Manette, while Monsieur and Madame Defarge, ruthless revolutionaries, seek revenge against the nobles of France. Research suggests that through Dickens’ portrayal of the revolutionaries and nobles of the war, he gives accurate insight to the era of the Revolution.

    Read More

More about Comparing Darnay And Charles Carton

Open Document