Compare and Contrast: Two Film Adaptations of Macbeth

1398 Words3 Pages

April, 2 2014 Perspectives

As far as we’re aware, Shakespeare wrote Macbeth in 1606, making it roughly 400 years old and in desperate need of a revival. While setting an adaptation of the play in modern day Melbourne in the midst of a gangland war may have seemed comical a decade ago, with corpses piled high from St Kilda to Sunshine in the real gang war of the Victorian city, it now seems 100% plausible. The difficulty of course, is finding a way to accurately transform noble lords of Scotland into underworld gangsters and still maintain Shakespeare’s true intentions. It’s quite simple really, you can’t.
Despite Geoffrey Wright’s efforts in producing the twenty-first century adaptation of Shakespeare’s Macbeth in 2006, and his attempt to depict the concept of stereotypical gender roles and relations in a modern context, he has served only to make a mockery of this powerful tragedy. On the contrary, Roman Polanski’s The Tragedy of Macbeth, produced in 1971, is now considered to be one of the most influential filmic illustrations of the Shakespearean play, while closely following the themes and threads of the original text.
Polanski’s Macbeth was produced in accordance with the socio-political background of the 1970s. Thus, prior to embarking on an analysis of the film it is imperative to first gain an understanding of the era within which is was released. The turn of the 1960s established a period of immense change and development within society; the age of The Man on the Moon, Communism and Women’s Liberation.
Roman Polanski intertwined several of these pressing concepts into his production and more specifically, opted to highlight the stereotypical role of women and the appropriate way of conduct, through c...

... middle of paper ...

...ginal text; the same cannot be said for modernised versions that have been reconstructed time and time again. Instead they have construed conflicting attitudes and values, through which Shakespeare’s true intentions have been lost in translation.

Bibliography
HubPages Inc. 2014, “The Concept of Femininity in Shakespeare’s Macbeth”, http://barbarahend.hubpages.com/hub/The-Concept-of-Femininity-in-Shakespeares-Macbeth > 30/3/14
Macbeth (DVD), 2006, Directed by Geoffrey WRIGHT: Martin Fabinyi, Australia.
Shmoop University, Inc. 2014, “Macbeth Theme of Fate and Freewill”, http://www.shmoop.com/macbeth/fate-free-will-theme.html > 31/3/14
SparkNotes LLC, 2014, ‘Analysis of Major Characters”, http://www.sparknotes.com/shakespeare/macbeth/canalysis.html > 29/3/14
The Tragedy of Macbeth, (DVD), 1971, Directed by Roman POLANSKI: Playboy Enterprises, United Kingdom.

Open Document