Compare and Contrast: Passage 1: Description of Tom, Passage 2: Gatsby

818 Words2 Pages

Compare and Contrast: Passage 1: Description of Tom, Passage 2: Gatsby

seen

The first passage is a description of Tom. He is portrayed as strongly

built: "It was a body capable of enormous leverage-a cruel body." He

also seems to be a brutal an supercilious man. Words as "arrogant",

"sturdy", "gruff" and "husky" create a mood around him which is quite

unpleasant. This description is very objective and we get a clear

picture of what Tom looks like. We are also given a description of

Tom's voice as being "...a gruff, husky tenor..."

The other passage is not really a description of Mr Gatsby, but rather

an occasion which he fits into. The description we are given about

Gatsby is much more unclear than that of Tom. The night makes the

atmosphere more mysterious around Gatsby. Here words as "night",

"trembling", "silhouette" and "dark" set the theme of the passage.

There is a clear contrast in the themes between the two passages. In

the first one 'day' or 'light' can be said to be a theme in comparison

to the 'night' or 'darkness' in the other.

Even though the description of Tom is quite objective, the sunshine

and clearness has a high symbolic importance to the passage and makes

it more of a contrast to the other passage. This sunshine could be

there because Tom is an antagonist in the novel, thus his description

should not be complicated as, for example Gatsby's. Thereby he is

connected to unambiguousness, whereas Gatsby is connected to darkness

and implying that his character will be revealed later on.

The sunshine which is connected to Tom could mean that his character

is exposed and open for everyone to look at. This could be connected

to that his characteristics are those of a fascist prototype...

... middle of paper ...

...asting themes are day and night and

the tone and the techniques are based around these themes. The

techniques are quite different in the two passages; in Toms there are

many negative words and his body is personified as "cruel". In

Gatsby's passage there are more words connected to obscurity and

Gatsby is not at all illustrated negatively. The techniques create two

contrasting moods in the two passages. Tom's passage is more simple

and it is not as interesting to read as Gatsby's passage. Tom's

passage is almost unpleasant to read because one could almost think he

is a monster by his account. The tone in Gatsby's passage is more

calm. The presence of the night makes everything more subjective and

abstract. A potential effect of this is that the reader will feel more

comfortable with this passage. Things connected to the night are

usually more interesting.

Open Document