Yasmin Bansal
HZT4U0
Ms. Mitchell
March 6th, 2015
Perception of Truth As people, we tend to believe everything we see. Do we ever take the time to stop and think about what is around us? Is it reality, or are we being deceived? Reality is not necessarily what is in front of us, or what is presented to us. The environment that we are placed or brought up has a great impact on what we perceive to be the truth or perceive to be reality. Plato’s Allegory of the Cave is one of the most significant attempts to explain the nature of reality. The cave represents the prisoners, also known as the people. They are trapped inside of a cave. They are presented with shadows of figures, and they perceive that to be reality. The cave can be used as a
…show more content…
This is the case for both Plato’s Allegory of The Cave and The Truman Show. Both characters are kept from the real world and their thinking is influenced by their surroundings, which can trick them into believing something else. This is where the acceptance of reality comes in. The characters are brought up to believe whatever someone else makes them believe, and they are unexposed to the real world. The Truman Show and Plato’s Allegory of the Cave have more similarities than differences. The similarities are the characters and symbols, and the difference between the two is the setting. Both characters are trapped inside a “fake reality”, which of what they perceive to be real. Another similarity is the symbols that are present throughout both pieces. The symbol for Plato’s Allegory of the Cave is the chains that hold the prisoners inside the cave, and in The Truman Show its Truman’s fear of water. The one difference that sets these two stories apart is …show more content…
They are both similar because in both the main protagonist is trapped inside a “fake” reality, the chain symbolises the same thing in both cases and a different would be that one escape from the fake reality while the other one goes back. In the Plato’s Allegory of the Cave the men are chained and told to believe that what they see is indeed real. The same thing applies for the The Truman Show; Truman is forced to believe a fake reality because that’s what he is surrounded by for a very long time. Both characters are kept from figuring out what is real and what is just an illusion of what they think is real. In both works a fake reality is perceived as something that they live in because they are unexposed to the real world. Both the men and Truman are kept in the dark about their being more to life than an Island and a cave (shadows in the cave). This isolates them and changes their perception of the
The basic premise of the two plots is the same. Both stories deal with the capture of a young person who is to be groomed to live in a private, controlled environment to make them happy, but where they are never able to leave.
In order to understand the moral fabric of the world, it is important to question any information that is given to an individual, instead of blindly accepting the majority opinion and giving it full credibility and validity based on other people’s opinions. Plato’s work, The Republic introduces the allegory of the cave, which is metaphorical scenario that attempts to explain the importance of questioning norms that may seem trivial. Plato illustrates a cave where bounded prisoners have lived all their lives in seclusion, away from the outside world. In their immobile state, they can only look at the wall in front of them which is illuminated by a small fire that has been going on behind them. The wall constantly projects shadows of people passing by outside the cave going about their daily lives. The prisoners have never seen anything else, and they have never experienced the outside world, so they are content in what they have. Plato then, poses a problem of one prisoner escaping, and he analyzes and hypothesises what the initial reaction of the escaped man would be. The first thing the prisoner would experience would be blindness, ironically from the overwhelming exposure to light as he steps out from the cave. Soon, he will begin to realize his ignorance as he sees that the shadows he had seen all his life were actually real people. Plato concludes that his idea of the perfect life inside the cave was ill conceived and that the prisoner would have never been aware of the world outside, had he not escaped. Similarly, The Truman Show, directed by Peter Weir, follows the life of a man in the utopian town of Seahaven. What the protagonist isn’t aware of however is that his entire life has been broadcasted throughout the world; as a...
In this world we are born and raised into a certain understanding that things are a certain way. We are taught to believe that the way you do things are the way they should be done and that is the way they have always been done in the past because that is the right way to do these things. On the other hand, the way we view our world, our situation, or our current lives in our own personal circles may not be exactly what we have thought they were. Reading and watching “The Myth of the Cave” by Plato and “The Truman Show” respectively I will discuss the comparisons of similarities and differences, the significance of Truman’s name, which path would I choose if I was put in this position, and if these two stories were illustrated in Socratic virtue ethics how would
In "The Allegory of the Cave," prisoners in a cave are forced to watch shadows as people behind them are forced to accept these shadows as reality -- "To them... the truth would be literally nothing but the shadows of the images. One prisoner, however, is released, and stumbles into the real world, containing more depth and complexity than they had ever known. At first, the prisoner will be pained at the bright, piercing light, but will eventually recover. According to Plato, the freed prisoner is then obligated to return to the shadows of the cave, to inform the shackled prisoners left behind of the real world. The prisoners, however, will not believe the freed prisoner, and may even go as afra s to kill him for such "lies" contrary to their "reality." The pursuit of the truth is, therefor, a painstaking but rewarding process. According to Plato, the physical world is a world of sight, one that lacks meaning if left alone. Only those who manage to break into the sunlight from the cave will ascend to the intellectual world. The prisoners in the shadows only know of the dull physical world, while those who ascend into the sunlight learn of the spiritual world, and are exposed to the first hints of truth. The soul ascends upward into the realm of goodness and of the truth, where "... souls are ever hastening into the upper world where they desire to dwell.." The pursuit of goodness and of the truth, then, improves the soul, as the soul desires to be elevated to a higher state of knowledge and morality. Caring for the self and the soul involves freeing the shackles of the physical world and ascending to the "... world of knowledge... the universal author of all things beautiful and right... and the immediate source of reason and truth in the intellectual..." The soul yearns to dwell in a world of morality and knowledge, and only the pursuit of
In “Plato’s Cave,” two characters, Socrates and Glaucon, engage in a conversation about an allegory of a cave, with Socrates providing exposition for Glaucon. Socrates's explanation of the cave has extensive detail, for an allegory is an extended metaphor. For example, Socrates describes how the people in the cave have been “in this [cavelike] dwelling since childhood, shackled by the legs and neck” (“Plato’s Cave,” paragraph 1), and that “they stay in the same place so that there is only one thing for them to look at” (“Plato’s Cave,” paragraph 1), and in this case, that is “whatever they encounter in front of their faces” (“Plato’s Cave,” paragraph 1). That means that the people inside the cave are shackled in such a way that they are always in the same spot and can only see whatever is in front of them. Socrates goes into further detail and mentions that “between the fire and those who are shacked… there runs a walkway at a certain height” (“Plato’s Cave,” paragraph 2), and that there are people walking along a low wall and are “carrying all sorts of things that reach up higher than the wall” (“Plato’s Cave,” paragraph 2). Simply put, there is a walkway between the fire and the people in
To begin, Plato’s Allegory of the cave is a dialogue between Socrates and Glaucon and its main purpose, as Plato states is to, “show in a figure how far our nature is enlightened or unenlightened.”(Plato) The dialogue includes a group of prisoners who are captive in a cave and chained down, only with the ability to stare straight at a wall. This wall, with the help of a fire, walkway, and people carrying different artifacts and making sounds, create a shadow and false perception of what is real. This concept here is one of the fundamental issues that Plato brings up in the reading. “To them, I said, the truth would be literally nothing but the shadows of the images.” (Plato). These prisoners, being stuck in this cave their entire life have no other option but to believe what they see on the wall to be true. If they were to experience a real representation of the outside world they would find it implausible and hard to understand. “When any of them is liberated and compelled suddenly to stand up a...
The Truman Show has several comparisons to Plato’s Allegory of the Cave. Truman’s home, Seahaven, represents the prisoner’s cave and the water becomes Truman’s chains. The actors that play as Truman’s friends and family represent the shadows that appear on the wall. After attempting to leave, Truman spends a long time sitting in his car observing the world and eventually predicts what will occur, just as the men in the cave predict what will appear on the wall next. In the Allegory, the prisoner had to be dragged out kicking and screaming because he was comfortable with the lie. Christoph says the same thing about Truman as Plato says about the man; he is comfortable with his false reality. Plato stated that once knowledge is gained, no one
The Cave Allegory was Plato’s attempt to compare what he called “the effect of education and the lack of it on our nature”. Plato had another Greek philosopher by the name of Socrates describe a group of people who lived
From the beginning of the time, when civilization was still building and growing, many were searching of what the truth was really about in this world, for instance, the Greek Philosophers. In the present, The transformation of the past and the future is so vast and astonishing because time was capable of affecting the humans significantly. There is no doubt that there is a vast gap between ancient days and the present modern day, however, Greek Philosopher Plato’s work, The Allegory Of The Cave is greatly relatable to the movie called, The Truman Show. Plato’s work, Allegory of the Cave and the movie, The Truman Show, share a mutual development in the situation of the plot and symbolism, which
The Truman Show and “The Allegory of the Cave” are both examples of what people see, is the only reality they know. In Plato's allegory, it tells a story about prisoners. They are all chained up facing a cave wall. There is a fire behind them that causes shadows. Since these people have never been outside the cave, they believe that this is their reality. The cave also doubled as a pathway. Animals and people would pass by every day. The fire projected the shadows of the people and animals onto the cave wall. The prisoners actually believed that the shadows were real. One day one of the prisoners was freed from the cave. They were able to see the world around them for what it really was. Confused and amazed the freed prisoner came back to untie
Plato’s analogy begins in a cave. The cave is meant to represent the physical world or the world of sense experience. A number of prisoners are bound by their necks and legs so that they cannot turn around. They have been this way since birth and know no other life than this. Behind the prisoners are a low wall, a walkway and a fire that burns. From time to time individuals carry objects like marionettes in front of the fire and shadows are cast against the wall in front of them. The prisoners observe the shadows that flicker before them and have developed a game over time. They try to predict the movements of the shadows. They associate the sounds made by the individuals with the shadows as this is
Comparing The Allegory of the Cave by Plato and The Truman Show, some similarities can be witnessed
The circumstances that are described by Plato have a metaphorical meaning to them. The allegory attacks individuals who rely solely upon; or in other words are slaves to their senses. The shackles and chains that bind the prisoners are in fact their senses .In Plato’s theory, the cave itself represents the individuals whom believe that knowledge derives from what we can hear and see in the world around us; in other words, empirical knowledge. The cave attempts to show that believers of empirical knowledge are essentially ...
Plato's Theory of Forms draws parallels to The Allegory of the Cave, highlighting the concept of human beings being ignorant to true perfection. In the writing Plato uses symbols to convey a veiled meaning. The philosopher says, “The prisoners s...
Plato, a student of Socrates, in his book “The Republic” wrote an allegory known as “Plato's Cave”. In Plato's allegory humans are trapped within a dark cave where they can only catch glimpses of the world above through shadows on the wall.2 Plato is describing how the typical human is. They have little knowledge and what they think they know has very little basis in fact. He describes these people as prisoners, in his allegory, and they are only free when they gain knowledge of the world above the cave.