Compare And Contrast Essay: The Clemency Of The Court

1385 Words3 Pages

Colton Gillespie Mr. Rutledge English III DC - Period 3 11/30/15 Literary Comparison Essay-Draft 2 “The Clemency of the Court” written by Willa Cather for the Hesperian magazine, and “Clothes” from Arranged Marriage written by Chitra Banerjee Divakaruni, both discuss immigration to the United States. Although both authors write about the same subject, the author's’ point of view on the subject differ from one another. In “The Clemency of the Court” Cather is showing that the United States is failing in protecting its immigrants, while in “Clothes” it is showing the impact that the “American Dream” has on immigrants, and how it has the power to changes lives. In both stories, the main character struggle with the idea of the “American Dream” …show more content…

The “Clemency of the Court” was written on October 26, 1893 by Willa Cather for The Hespian magazine. This story is about a boy named Serge Povolitchky. He lived an unappealing life, but to him he did not know any different. Serge was without a father figure his whole life, and in his early childhood, his mother committed suicide by drowning herself in a puddle. He was left on his own. A man once told him “ the State will be a father to you, my lad, and a mother." A woman, whose name was Skaldi, took Serge into her home. Though she treated him poorly, giving “him what her children would not eat, and clothed him in what her children would not wear” (Carther) at least was left with a roof over his head. Skaldi beat him and he cried, but as he cried, he listened to the stories that she would tell to her children. These stories …show more content…

His innocence is what caused him to trust in this false hope. Throughout his life he had been taught that State would be there to protect him no matter what he did. “He thought he owed the State a great deal for something, he did not know what; that the State would do something great for him some day, because he had no one else.” This is what Serge believed. Up to his dying day, he had faith that the State would save him. As he was being tortured and began hallucinating, Serge says, “the State must come soon now” (Cather). This hope that he had, was hope that protection would come from the State, but instead it is what ultimately caused his

Open Document