Christian Marriage: A Theological Argument Analysis

854 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Five characteristics of christian marriage rites

Introduction
In the 1983 _Code of Canon Law_, canon 1055 §2 states very clearly that a valid marriage between two baptized individuals is always a sacrament: “For this reason, a valid matrimonial contract cannot exist between the baptized without it being by that that fact a sacrament.” In “Faith, Contract, and Sacrament in Christian Marriage: A Theological Approach,” Michael Lawler takes issue with this position. He argues that it is not supported by the theological tradition of the Church and argues that without an active, personal Christian faith the sacrament of matrimony is not received, even if a valid rite is celebrated by two baptized persons. He states “The active faith of the participants is an essential prerequisite not just for …show more content…

Marital contract and marital sacrament…are separable in marriages between baptized nonbelievers…^4^

He contends that these are questions that “have troubled the…Church for the past two centuries” and “have not as yet received genuine _theological_” solutions. Lawler then posits that canon law has “difficulty dealing with the theological fact of Christian faith” because it is “impossible to make clear beyond doubt” the “theological fact of Christian faith.”^5^ Lawler states, “The reality of faith will be central in this study…”^6^ and then goes on to develop a definition by reviewing the writings of St. Thomas Aquinas, the teachings of the Council of Trent and of the First Vatican Council, and summarizes by quote Juan Alfaro. At that point he offers his working definition: “The faith that is obedience and self-surrender to God, the traditional _fides qua creditor_, is a free, and at least a minimally conscious and explicit, …show more content…

To support his argument, Lawler reviews New Testament scriptures emphasizing “the necessity of faith for salvation.”^8^ He also references the Council of Trent, summarizing its position of faith: “There is not the slightest doubt that the Fathers of Trent wished to affirm the primacy of active personal faith for salvation” but going on to acknowledge that the minimalism (and even nominalism) of the Counter-Reformation theologians was detrimental “in understanding the role of personal faith in the sacraments.”^9^ He then critiques this approach by a review of the writings of the

Show More
Related

  • Our Mutual Joy The Religious Case For Gay Marriage By Lisa Miller Summary

    707 Words  | 2 Pages

    Lisa Miller uses the Bible as a basis for her argument for gay marriage in her essay "Our Mutual Joy: The Religious Case for Gay Marriage". She first begins her argument by saying that neither the Old Testament nor the New Testament show model examples for marriage. Therefore, neither a homosexual or heterosexual couple would want to look to the Bible for marriage advice. Instead, the Bible should be read for its universal truths. Miller goes onto say that there is no real definition of marriage in the Bible, and the laws and guidelines in the Bible were put in place for a culture that no longer exists. If Christians no longer subscribe to animal sacrifice, then why would they condemn homosexuality? She ends by discussing the fact that Jesus ' message was one of inclusion. So, all those who claim to follow the Bible 's teachings should love others regardless of their sexual orientation.

    Read More

  • Christianity As A Living Religious Tradition

    1291 Words  | 3 Pages

    Christianity is clearly a living religious tradition through both the significant person in Roncalli, and the practice of baptism. The continuing effects of the impacts of Pope John XXIII in his encyclicals and himself catalysing Vatican 2 and ‘aggiornamento’ create the sense that Christianity is a living religious tradition. The sacred practice of baptism allows adherents to make physical their faith, including the belief in the trinity, and allows candidates to become one with God through the renewal of life, abolishing original sin. It is evident that both aspects of the Christian faith have lead to Christianity being considered a living religious tradition.

    Read More

  • Better to Marry Than to Burn: Clerical Celibacy in Modern Times

    1883 Words  | 4 Pages

    Wengert, Timothy J. "The Book of Concord and Human Sexuality, Seen Through the Institution Of Marriage." Dialog: A Journal of Theology 48.1 (2009): 9-18. Academic Search Premier. Web. 5 May 2014.

    Read More

  • The Support of Married Couples by the Catholic Church

    1154 Words  | 3 Pages

    Text Box: “I, (name) do take thee, (Name) to be my lawful wedded husband/wife, to have and to hold from this day forward, for better, for worse, for richer, for poorer, in sickness and in health, to love and to cherish, till death do us part.†A quote from the traditional Wedding Mass

    Read More

  • Comparing Marriage Views: Judaism, Christianity, and Islam

    1220 Words  | 3 Pages

    From a Christian’s point of view, marriage is an institution created by God between a man and a woman (Mat 19:3:4) The book of Matthew goes on to show that for the sake of marriage a man would leave his father and mother and cling to his wife. Copeland refers to marriage like a tent, whose walls shelter a man and a woman - one man and one woman - the one consecrated to the other (Copeland, M 2015) http://executableoutlines.com. God’s plan for the married couple is to avoid temptation and fornication. According to Matthew 19: 6, “What therefore hath God joined together, let not man put asunder.”

    Read More

  • Beliefs on Marriage and Divorce

    2007 Words  | 5 Pages

    Marriage and divorce are culturally ruled, as I have noted from my interviews with friends and family of different cultures who have married, perhaps some have divorced, and with each experience in love they have culturally accepted values that pertain to their overall ideals and values on love, marriage, shared values, etc. The purpose of this paper is to establish a clear understanding of human nature as it relates to the portrait of adulthood and mate selection; institution of marriage, procreation, and even divorce as it relates to acceptance of failed expectations and moving on. I was not surprised to learn that the people I interviewed were traditional in their beliefs that marriage is a serious commitment that should be respected and approached for longevity.

    Read More

  • Five Non-Religious Reasons Of Marriage: Dennis Prager's Arguments For Marriage

    1249 Words  | 3 Pages

    Once upon a time marriage was a requirement of society and a value to many women who wanted a stable life. It stand as a commitment to their husband and to God. It remain a way to start a proper family in the eyes the Lord. It was what many mothers and daughters dreamed of. Now that, many generations have passed many people believe marriage is not valued and Divorce rates are higher than ever. Religion has also become optional and there’re many different religions to choose from. Cohabitation has also reigned over society one doesn’t need to wait till marriage. Now you are able to move in with the person you love at any point in life. Marriage had started as a first option to many but it has become the last. There are still reasons why marriage

    Read More

  • The Causes And Effects Of Divorce

    1048 Words  | 3 Pages

    While certain churches accepted the idea of adultery allowing divorce, the other situations were all in the gray area. This lead to division among the church as a whole and those people who were in the gray. Divorce even under the biblical expectations was often frowned upon in the early church, with one party being seen as the victim and one as the “guilty party”. In her article, Some Church Historical Perspectives on Divorce and Remarriage, Bertha Katschke-Jennings touched on the early churches dealings with those going through divorce, “ The Church was generally severe in the treatment of the “guilty party,” and the punishment was usually ostracism.” (Katschke-Jennings, B. 1984, Pg. 47) The church distanced themselves from whom they deemed “guilty” in order to maintain a firm stance on the act of divorce. The church’s actions have left many people on the outskirts, feeling alienated form God and His people. Culture has deeply changed the way that the church reacts to those who go through divorce. While the church’s view my not have shifted too much on what warrants a divorce, we are seeing more grace given to those who are dealing with this topic , some might argue too much. There are those who believe that the church has become to accommodating to those who are contemplating or have went through a divorcee in order to be more approachable. In his article, Opinions Divorce and Remarriage, Robert Spaemann

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Conjugal View Of Marriage

    1168 Words  | 3 Pages

    Sherif Girgis wrote his article, “Marriage: Whose Justice? Which Diversity?” in response to John Corvino’s, “What Marriage Can Be” article. Corvino’s article introduced the inclusivist view of marriage and then attacked Girgis’ conjugal view of marriage, which was introduced in Girgis’ book, “What is Marriage? Man and Woman: A Defense.” Corvino’s inclusivist view was meant to expand the definition of marriage, not re-define it (Corvino, p.6) and although Corvino’s defense of the inclusivist view was, “sophisticated, civil and well-informed” according to Girgis, it was also, “Contradicting virtually every philosophical and legal tradition until yesterday, it nonetheless offers no positive case for its thesis” (Girgis, p.1). Girgis obviously does not agree with Corvino’s inclusivist/revisionist view, but he does so on the basis that it has too many weaknesses. The conjugal view is superior as it most properly defines what true marriage is and should be. In the ensuing sections, I shall describe what the conjugal view of marriage is and why Girgis believes it to be superior to both the

    Read More

  • Importance Of Justification By Faith

    2131 Words  | 5 Pages

    Justification by faith is of great importance, it is the foundation of our whole position and standing with God. Martin Luther wrote, “When the article of justification has fallen, everything has fallen.” John Calvin called it, “the main hinge on which religion turns.” Thomas Watson said, “Justification is the very hinge and pillar of Christianity.” The issue of Justification was the primary dispute between the reformers and the Roman Catholic Church, and the problem was, and still is, between salvation by faith alone and salvation based on good works.

    Read More

  • The Potentials and Pitfalls of Interfaith Marriages

    2100 Words  | 5 Pages

    As more Americans enter the cultural melting pot and cross ethnic and social barriers, the rate of interfaith marriages has increased, not because persons are less committed to their faith traditions, but because there is a new reality in which old barriers are breaking down. In the western hemisphere the issue of interfaith marriage is widely debated among all religious traditions. Many conservative denominations believe that, "A believer marrying or intending to marry an unbeliever is clearly going against the expressed commandment of God" (J.J. Lim) . Other religious denominations view intermarriages as, "The unity within diversity that adds a richness and beauty to marriage and to life" (Rev. Tom Chulak) . Regardless of one's religious denomination, a person's religion comprises the framework of meaning and the source of his or her values. When two people marry they bring with them their strengths and weaknesses, hopes and fears, and their religious dimension that plays a significant role in their relationship, decisions and responses to each other. For this reason, many issues and challenges arise within interfaith marriages that require accommodations by each person including how the couple will deal with their religious difference, what religion they will teach to their children, and how their respective religious communities will respond to interfaith marriages. No two couples manage the adjustments that need to be made within an interfaith marriage in the same way. This is because there is no standard or typical Christian, Hindu, Buddhist or Muslim. Their knowledge, commitment, practice and attachment to the respective religious traditions, and their knowledge of, attitude and affinity toward the religious tradition of their spouses are so different that no two couples have the same experience.

    Read More

  • John Wesley's View Of Sanctification '

    541 Words  | 2 Pages

    Paralleling this broader doctrine of salvation by faith, John Wesley highlights that this narrower part of salvation, specifically justification, is the outcome of a narrower concept of faith. This narrower faith is the belief that God has personally reconciled the believer to Himself through the atoning life and death of Christ. It is by faith that we put on the righteousness of Christ. For John Wesley, faith was the only condition of justification: “no man is justified till he believes; every man when he believes is justified.”

    Read More

  • The Development of Marriage

    999 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Catholic marriage is set apart from all other relationships because Catholic marriages are a sacramental path to sanctity. Paul wrote that marriage is a true sacrament and the sign of the conjugal union of Christ and his Bride, the Church.(Matrimony 2). At Lateran Council II in 1139, it was first defined as infallibly true that matrimony is as true a sacrament as Eucharist and baptism and at The Council of Lyons II in 1274, it was included among the list of seven sacraments.

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Marriage And Marriage

    974 Words  | 2 Pages

    Religious marriages have a background rich in tradition and symbolism. Often that tradition becomes visible during the marriage ceremony. Each religion will have distinct traditions that take place during the ceremony in order to represent the couple’s mutual respect for religion and religious principles as they apply to the relationship. As early as the 12th Century, Roman Catholic scholar and writers referred to marriage in religion as a sacrament, a sacred ceremony tied to experiencing God's existence. “However, it wasn't until the Council of Trent in 1563 that marriage was officially deemed one of the seven sacraments, says Elizabeth Davies, of the Catholic Bishops' Conference of England and Wales. Following the development of Protestant theology, which did not recognize marriage as a sacrament, the Council felt a need to ...

    Read More

  • The Role Of Family In Familiaris Consortio By Pope John Paul II

    1350 Words  | 3 Pages

    Sex out of wedlock, divorces, childbirth out of wedlock, etc. are all seen as normal circumstances currently. Marriage is an indissoluble bond which means it cannot be broken for the rest of the life after the bond is made. The Church wants to stress the importance of marriage to a relationship and the significance of marriage in reference to Jesus’ loving sacrifice to all. Marriage is a symbol of the sacrifice Jesus made of himself out of love for mankind. Through marriage, the Lord allows us to experience that love with one another as Jesus loves us. Conjugal love can reach that extent of love which all married people are called

    Read More

More about Christian Marriage: A Theological Argument Analysis

Open Document