Because the police are expected to be able to deal directly with mentally ill persons on the street, the development of Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) training has been crucial in giving police officers the education they need to respond to situations involving persons with a mental illness, persons in a mental health crisis, persons who have attempted suicide, persons who are threatening suicide, or persons who are emotionally disturbed. In order to best understand CIT, it is imperative to note the statutory definition of mental illness. According to Ohio Revised Code 5122. 01 (2016), mental illness is defined as, “a substantial disorder of thought, mood, perception, orientation, or memory that grossly impairs judgment, behavior, capacity …show more content…
to recognize reality, or ability to meet the ordinary demands of life”. The CIT model also helps people with developmental disabilities. Police officers need to be trained to handle potential situations where mentally ill persons pose as threats to themselves or others. The development of Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) programs have allowed police departments to train their officers in appropriate responses to mental health calls, as well as learning how to relate to people presenting signs of mental illness. Crisis intervention training proves itself valuable because it gives officers more confidence when dealing with high-stress situations such as someone threatening suicide. If the police are called to a home invasion and the perpetrator or victim have a mental illness, his or her behavior may be unpredictable, putting everyone in danger. If officers can properly identify and respond to mental illnesses, they may not be forced to make fatal decisions. The CIT model was created in 1988 when a man who had a history of mental illnesses and substance abuse was shot by a Memphis police officer.
After this fatality, the Memphis CIT model was constructed. According to Watson, Ottati, Draine, and Morabito (2011), “the goals of CIT are to increase safety during mental health crisis calls and to divert individuals with mental illness away from the criminal justice system and to appropriate mental health services”. Aside from forty hours of classroom training and scenarios, a major component of the CIT model is referring people to a mental health facility where they can take advantage of community resources. This also includes police officers transporting people for mental health evaluations. Residential crisis stabilization programs are paramount to modern crisis care. Because of this, police officers need to be familiar with community mental health resources so that they can have a designated drop off place for psychiatric emergencies. This also means that crisis facilities need to have a rapid law enforcement drop-off area where officers can drop a person off quickly, so they can return to their jobs and not be tied up with these calls for hours. A quick turnaround time is critical to providing a viable and good option for police officers that are responding to mental health …show more content…
calls. Some police officers think that assessing crisis situations and transporting individuals is time consuming and they do not like the available options. It is important for police departments to build good relationships with providers in the mental health system. A collaborative effort is required in order for CIT to work most effectively. Crisis stabilization facilities function within a strong CIT partnership. According to Compton, Bahora, Watson, & Oliva (2008), “CIT is considered by many to be the most rapidly expanding and promising partnership between law enforcement and mental health professionals”. Officers need to be able to link a person with treatment so that they can resolve the mental health call. There also needs to be good resources for individuals in need of treatment that do not meet the criteria for an emergency evaluation. Availability of mental health services is key to ensuring CIT effectiveness. According to Lamb, Weinberger, and DeCuir Jr. (2002), “Collaboration between the law enforcement and mental health systems is crucial, and the very different areas of expertise of each should be recognized and should not be confused”. If there are good mental health services available, officers will be more likely to have voluntary transports rather than having to involuntarily take a person which can often end violently, thus putting officers in dangerous situations or in bad positions. Officer safety can be in jeopardy when a mentally ill person reacts violently to the options an officer gives them. According to Finn and Stalans (2002), “It is estimated that mental health calls account for about 5-10 percent of all calls for police service” (p. 279). It is important to remember when a call goes to dispatchers, dispatchers try their best to rely as much pertinent information to the responding officers, but this may not always include information about a suspect’s or victim’s current mental health diagnosis or any mental health conditions. This is one of the reasons why officers need to be properly trained in identifying and responding to mental illnesses. When an officer arrives on scene, they need to be able to appropriately assess the situation and assess any threats, as well as assessing a person’s state of mind. Officers are the calming factor on the scene. These types of situations require a specialized perspective.
They not only have to handle such calls with a tactical and safe approach, but they have to handle these people with empathy and understanding. If someone poses as a threat to themselves or others, officers need to be able to gain control of the person without having to call a negotiation team and preferably with a low-lethality method. Interventions they may use include de-escalation, risk assessment, and lethality determination. Officers are also responsible to use good discretion when determining whether a person should enter the mental health system or the criminal justice system. With crisis intervention training, officers can prevent a number of mental health crises by understanding the nature of these calls and can develop better discretion, as well as develop patience and compassion. Sometimes it is better to be patient with a mentally ill person, rather than trying to clear the call as quickly as possible. Patiently managing a situation with a person suffering from severe symptoms of mental illness ensures not just their own safety, but others’ safety as well. Giving the person clear choices during the interaction will also help facilitate a positive and patient interaction. Patiently managing a mentally ill person can prevent detainment, which is a big goal of CIT. Too many mentally ill people are ending up in jails where they receive little to no treatment at
all. It has been debated whether crisis intervention training should be mandated or not. All departments differ on this position. CIT is now in forty states and in two-thousand jurisdictions. The Columbus Police Department has about three-hundred and seventy CIT trained officers right now. Columbus has now provided crisis intervention training for the last two recruit classes because of the complexity of these types of situations. According to the Communications Bureau (2018), Columbus alone had 6,300 mental health calls and 6,199 suicide calls in 2017. This number proves that police officers are almost guaranteed to come in contact with people who are going through mental health crises. Because this number is fairly high, police officers must learn to take a trauma-informed approach to policing. Trauma-informed policing is taught by good CIT training. Instead of asking someone “what’s wrong with you?”, officers need to take the approach “what happened to you?”. The police need to understand that a lot of mental issues stem from a trauma history. According to Hogan (2018), “ninety-percent of people with serious mental health issues have trauma histories”. Taking this trauma-informed approach is a core principle of crisis care.
Constantine, R., Andel, R., Petrila, J., Becker, M., Robst, J., Teague, G., Boaz, T. and Howe, A., 2010, ‘Characteristics and experiences of adults with a serious mental Illness who were involved in the criminal justice system’, Psychiatric Services, vol. 61, no. 5, pp. 451-457.
Police departments would have to hire certain outside professionals such as psychiatrists to train the police officers on how to handle mental health situations or how to recognize the time. Some police departments only train a few specialized members to go on calls with mental health situations to help, but they cannot go on all of the calls. The funds for mental health are not being used correctly. Most funds are going towards mental health institutes or therapies and treatments. Little is going to the police departments.
The public’s views on mental illness. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the National Association for Mental Health. Swindle,R.,Heller,K.,& Pescosolido,B.(1997,August). Responses to “nervous breakdowns” in America over a 40-year period: Mental health policy implications. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Sociological Association, Toronto, Ontario.
New South Wales Police Force, 2011, Mental health intervention team news, brochure, NSW Police Force, New South Wales
...ng experts to identify mental health symptoms such as delusions, hallucinations, and identifying if any instances of malingering are present. Evaluating a defendant is essential in understanding whether or not they are capable of following legal proceedings. If an individual is in fact found incompetent, attempts to restore competency are performed through treatments with medication or mental training about legal information that is vital for them to know in their case. It is imperative to acknowledge competency to stand trial cases in the legal system to not only ensure fairness in the courtroom, but offer mentally ill defendants an opportunity to have a lawful trial depending on their psychological state.
Lamb, H. R. (2004). Mentally ill persons in the criminal justice system: Some perspectives. Psychiatric Quarterly, 108-126.
Spencer, Susan. “Mental Health First Aid: A Concept Whose Time Has Come.” Worcester Telegram & Gazette [Massachusetts] 15 Jan. 2014: n. pag. NewsBank Special Reports. Web. 7 Apr. 2014.
Many times people with an untreated mental illness behave in an abnormal manner that is disturbing to the public, causing them to be perceived as frightening and dangerous which attracts the attention of police officers. Harrington agrees that, “Without the medication they need to keep their illness in check, they sometimes lapse into psychophysics and behave in bizarre ways.”(Harrington) A mentally unstable individual’s perspective of what is, and what is not acceptable varies from that of a healthy person. Therefore, they are unable to comprehend proper public behavior. From public urination to public nesciences, they are charged with misdemeanors and sentenced to jail. Shannon Fiack emphasizes that “There is a fundamen...
Dizard’s (2015) newspaper article on the demise of Tanisha Anderson, a mentally ill Cleveland woman in police custody, is evidence of police brutality against the mentally ill. A clear point of understanding in this article is the fact that the police were aware of the victim’s mental illness and yet used an unprofessional method in an attempt to restrain her. The reason why mental health illness is still prevalent in our society is as a results of the stigmatization of the illness that prevents an individual from seeking the proper help. Even in the heightened sense of awareness around the issue of mental health in our society, many mentally ill individuals become victims of abuse on a daily basis. Several researchers have shown the relationship
Lamb, H. Richard., Weinberger, Linda E., & Gross, Bruce H. (2004). Mentally ill persons in the criminal justice system: Some Perspectives. Psychiatric Quarterly 75(2): 107-126.
Additionally, correctional psychologists are on-call to handle emergency situations involving mentally ill inmates, such as hostage negotiations and crisis intervention. The treatment of mentally ill individuals in jails and prisons is a prominent concern that is becoming more so as more ill individuals are sentenced to jail and prison stays. Currently, the United States correctional facilities are the largest provider of mental health services. (Reingle Gonzalez, et al.
Both legal and mental health professionals have long struggled to establish a clear and acceptable definition of insanity. Insanity is a legal term, not a psychological or medical one. The Sarasons prefer to use the term “maladaptive behavior” instead of insane or insanity. Maladaptive behavior is, “behavior that deals inadequately with a situation, especially one that is stressful” (5). Adaptation is the way people balance what they do and want to do, and what the environment/community requires of them. Successful adaptation depends on a person’s stress (situations that impose demands on him or her), vulnerability (likelihood of a maladaptive response), and coping skills (techniques that help him or her deal with difficulties/stress) (5). Consider the recent school shootings as an
Several states authorize police officers to arrest mentally ill people who have not broken any law. It is argued that this process is a way to promote public order. Hospitals also transfer mentally ill patients to jail in order to deal with the overflow. It is not uncommon for children to be confined to criminal detention centers because there is a lack of facilities for severely mentally ill children. Relying on the criminal justice systems to be surrogate mental health systems conflicts with the basic notions of justice. (Aufderheide,
Necessary Behavioral Mental Health intervention does not end at the point first responders have successfully contained the actual crisis. The ongoing need for Behavioral Mental Health services will continue for an extended length of time when a traumatic event such as that depicted in the scenario occur. A copious number of individuals will have ...
When patients are labeled with a mental illness they start to believe they actually have that illness. In more severe cases, misdiagnosis can result in the patient’s death or simply taking their own life. According to Dr. Mercola “Diagnostic errors are just one type of error that occurs in the medical field, and you might be surprised at just how common errors occur. While the 1999 IOM report blamed 98,000 deaths a year on hospital errors, a 2013 study in the Journal of Patient Safety projected that medical errors now account for 210,000 to 440,000 US deaths annually”. To better understand the severity of misdiagnosis, imagine a close family member getting diagnosed with a mental disorder that he or she doesn’t have and from that they decide to take their own life due to unnecessary treatment that is harmful to their