By The River

1517 Words4 Pages

The treatment of women during the nineteenth century was abhorrent, with their very existence being considered the property of their male family members. In the short story "By The River" by Jack Hodgin, Crystal Styan, the despondent wife of Jim Styan, navigates the countless challenges her gender faced during that period. Consequently, who once was an ambitious young woman, Crystal became confined to the traditional roles of a wife. However, when Jim Styan abandons her, the opportunity to take reign of her future develops, and she must find the internal strength to continue surviving without the support of the males in her life. Jack Hodgin uses the character of Crystal Styan to illustrate the unique female experience regarding societal expectations, …show more content…

However, with Jim's exit from her life, she began the journey of decentering men from her life and began to live for herself. Women often felt compelled to compromise their values and customs for their husbands, with Crystal taking a similar journey. Crystal is a pensive person, shown by how she chooses to watch her step and tie her hair back in the treacherous terrain she finds herself in. Meanwhile, Jim ridicules her cautiousness and continues making haphazard attempts at his dream, even after failing countless times. In a period when men were the ultimate authority and most knowledgeable in society, Crystal demonstrated the necessity to retain the qualities of herself, even in the face of oppression. Due to her tenacity and knowledge of the terrain, strengths that originate from herself without any outside source, Crystal survived in the thick bushes without Jim for six months. Despite this, Crystal encounters challenges in establishing autonomy; her mental health deteriorates, evident in how she both despises and admires Jim after abandoning …show more content…

The love was reciprocated until Jim realized his dream was futile, and then he fell out of love with the remainder of his failures, Crystal. However, Crystal only knew the comfort he had once given her, willing to abandon her studies for his whims. She is unable to move on from a man who has abandoned her, which would have been her demise, but the ending provides a hopeful outlook. Every time Jim is not on the train coming back to her, it is as if “...a giant hand is pulling, slowly, a stray stitching thread out of a fuzzy green cloth,” and eventually, the cloth will be reduced to nothing. Jack Hodgin uses the cloth to symbolize that she was built to be his perfect wife, but once there is no more hope of his return, no more thread, she can start anew, and build a future for herself on her own terms. Crystal’s ambitions had only been dormant in the presence of her husband. By herself, she can find what works for her and what does not without the nagging fear that she is overstepping her role. The love she held for Jim, her husband, the man who promised her that he would take care of her, must dissipate and in its place, she will build a new sense of

Open Document